Will Louisiana Legislators Defend Health Care Choice?
Bills from Rep. Talbot and Sen. Crowe Seek to Preserve Freedom of Choice in Health Care
New Orleans, LA -
April 6, 2010
While much attention has been focused on Attorney
General Buddy Caldwell's decision to join the lawsuit
challenging new federal health care law, Louisianians
should also take note of two important bills under
consideration by the state legislature.
Rep. Kirk Talbot and Sen. A.G. Crowe have introduced
measures that seek to protect the right of Louisianians
to make their own health care and health insurance
choices. Specifically, these bills (HB 94 and SB 26)
would prohibit any individual or employer from being
penalized for not purchasing government-defined
health insurance, and protect the right to pay directly
for medical care.
These measures are modeled after the American
Legislative Exchange Council's (ALEC) Freedom of
Choice in Health Care Act. Louisiana is now one of 41
states in which legislation modeled on this act has been
or will be introduced.
"There is no doubt that our health care system is in
need of reform," said Pelican Institute president Kevin
Kane. "But Americans are justifiably concerned that
expanding the government's role in health care will
lead to further restrictions on their liberty. The bills
introduced by Rep. Talbot and Sen. Crowe would
preserve important freedoms."
"There are legitimate Constitutional questions
about the federal government requiring individuals to
purchase a product. Even allowing for a broad
interpretation of the Commerce Clause, the individual
mandate may cross the line. Further, the current
Supreme Court has demonstrated a willingness to
protect states from federal overreach. Louisiana
legislators now have the opportunity - and
responsibility - to defend freedom of choice in health
care."
About the Pelican Institute for Public Policy
The Pelican Institute for Public Policy is a nonprofit,
nonpartisan research institute dedicated to the
principles of individual liberty, the free market and
limited, accountable government. Through research
papers, policy briefings, commentaries and
conferences, the Institute seeks to educate and inform
Louisiana's policymakers, news media and general
public.