New Orleans Council Reverses Position, Votes to Double Attorney Contract
Despite Budget Woes, Outside Firm Handling E-mail Controversy Gets Another 125K
New Orleans, LA -
Nov. 19, 2009
Just days before tackling the estimated $68 million
shortfall in next year's city budget, the New Orleans City
Council found money to double the contract for its
outside attorney who battled constituent requests for
council e-mails.
The move represents a complete flip-flop from the
council's stern June 4 position that it simply didn't
have the money to increase the contract. At that
meeting, when the e-mail issue was still very much
being played out in public, the council withdrew an
identical measure that would have send an additional
$125,000 to the Herman, Herman, Katz and Cotlar law
firm, which already had a $125,000 contract.
Increasing the $125,000 contract to $250,000 is minor in
the scope of a city budget of $486 million. Still, it's a
whopping figure compared to the total lack of money for
legal work that the council has budgeted for itself next
year.
At the recent council meeting, Councilwoman Cynthia
Hedge-Morrell wasn't clear on what the extra $125,000
covered. She initially said it was for a computer
consultant, but then said she didn't know whether the law
firm was getting money for its own troubles.
In responding to questions from The Pelican Institute,
Steven Lane, managing partner of Herman, Herman said
"the vast majority" of the cost was to pay for the
consultant. However, he also said his firm incurred "the
vast majority" of the costs covered by the new $125,000.
In a Times-Picayune article on June 16, though, Lane
provided information that showed the consultant cost
$33,000. Lane didn't say in his written response whether
more costs were charged after that date, which would
have been after the council turned down the request for
more money.
Asked to explain what happened in the five months
between the two council votes, Councilman Arnie
Fielkow said through a spokeswoman that Lane's
response spoke for him. Hedge-Morrell said more than a
week ago that she had someone researching the matter
but didn't respond further.
About the Pelican Institute for Public Policy
The Pelican Institute for Public Policy is a nonprofit,
nonpartisan research institute dedicated to the
principles of individual liberty, the free market and
limited, accountable government. Through research
papers, policy briefings, commentaries and
conferences, the Institute seeks to educate and inform
Louisiana's policymakers, news media and general
public.