The United Horseman's Front is listed at www.guidestar.org
as a 501 (c)(3) nonprofit charitable corporation under category "Animal
related / (Animal Protection and Welfare (includes Humane Societies and
SPCAs))" established in 2009. Dave Duquette, owner of Duquette Quarter
Horses in Hermiston, OR, is the president. The United Horsemen's Front
was registered as a nonprofit corporation in Oregon in November of 2008.
The US Internal Revenue Service defines a 501(c)(3) charitable organization as follows:
To be tax-exempt under section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code, an organization must be organized and operated exclusively for exempt purposes set forth in section 501(c)(3), and none of its earnings may inure to any private shareholder or individual. In addition, it may not be an action organization, i.e.,
it may not attempt to influence legislation as a substantial part of
its activities and it may not participate in any campaign activity for
or against political candidates....The organization must not be organized
or operated for the benefit of private interests,
and no part of a section 501(c)(3) organization's net earnings may
inure to the benefit of any private shareholder or individual. ...
However, despite exhaustive research, there apparently has been no
reported or recorded evidence that the United Horsemen's Front has
participated in any equine rescues or rehabilitations to date.
During the course of the research, the activities of the group were
in fact found to be exceedingly puzzling, especially when reviewed in
light of the above mission statement.
In July 2009, during an interview with Michelle Brence of the Oregonian, Duquette said:
"... he (Duquette) used to average $300,000 in annual
horse sales, with most fetching $10,000 to $15,000. "Now I'm lucky to
sell two or three horses a year," he said. "A horse I could get $20,000
out of in the last few years, I probably couldn't get $5,000 out of
now."
Ms. Brence also reported that:
"...the Duquettes and others have formed advocacy
groups to push a proposal they're calling the H.O.R.S.E. Act of 2009
(short for Humane and Optimal Restoration and Sustainability of
Equines) to reinstate USDA inspections. Horse meat could be exported to
China, Mexico, France, Italy and other countries where it's consumed by people. ... But Dave Duquette, who lobbied for the proposal in Washington, D.C.,
last month, remains confident. "Everybody we talked to was very
supportive of it," he said. "There are a lot of Republicans that will
be on board, but there are a lot of Democrats that will be on board,
too."
Absolutely no indication or discussion of how the United Horsemen's
Front is fulfilling its nonprofit mission of animal protection, humane
treatment and welfare.
It seems that much of the energy of both the United Horsemen's
Front, and the United Organizations of the Horse is far more focused on
other issues. In many press releases the United Horsemen's Front and
the UOH make the following statement:
"The UOH seeks to unify all like-minded equine
associations and individuals in support of its mission-to promote the
humane care and management of horses, and the continued viability of
the equine community in the United States of America."
As no clear definition is given of who and what exactly makes up "like-minded equine associations and individuals,"
one must attempt to make deductions as to who these groups and
individuals might be from some of Mr. Duquette's (and Rep. Sue Wallis')
public statements.
For example, in an exchange on the United Horsemen's Front Facebook
fan page
(http://www.facebook.com/pages/United-Horsemens-Front/261616654545),
Duquette made the following accusation:
"So from what I am hearing it is "OK" to go buy a
horse out of a "Kill Pen" for $25 and then put it on the "Rescue" or
"Bail" donation list. Then say if it doesn't meet the set amount "They"
will take it back to where it was rescued from in the first place.
Hmmm. Doesn't wash people. That is the "SCAM" that could end up..." having felony penalties.
When someone asked for clarification and facts on the incident in question, Duquette responded,
"<<name omitted>> who is on
what side of which isle???? If you believe the dribble and rediculous
rants of RT Fitch then maybe this page is not for you. There has been
much posted and written about Sue(Wallis) and I that is simply A.R.
bull that has no factual meaning. Instead of attacking this
group maybe do the research on who these scammers are. Makes me wonder
who your protecting, there is an obvious scam going on and doing the
see no evil thing makes you look more suspicious than maybe you think.
If you believe in climate change then great, Sue (Wallis) or anyone
else that doesn't should not be chastized by you or RT. I believe it's
a natural occurring change and Al Gore made alot of money SCAMMING the
public."
(R.T. Fitch is a blogger at http://rtfitch.wordpress.com who has been extremely critical of Mr. Duquette and Rep. Wallis. The A.R. abbreviation stands for animal rights.)
Mr. Duquette also spends much of his energies repeatedly criticizing
Wayne Pacelle, CEO and President of the Human Society of the United
States (HSUS), which seems odd, given Duquette himself is the president
of a group dedicated to animal protection and welfare. However, the
United Horsemen's Front and the UOH have their own particular
interpretation of what the HSUS and other animal welfare groups' true
mission is:
"The animal rights radical agenda (NOT to be
confused with legitimate and responsible animal welfare proponents,
which we all are) offers no solution except pushing for what is
essentially a welfare entitlement program for animals-Medicaid and food
stamps for horses so that every old, dangerous, unsound, unusable horse
is maintained at public expense for the rest of their 25 to 30 year
average life span. What they propose will create a mechanism to shovel
taxpayer dollars directly into the pockets of animal rights
organizations (HSUS/PETA) so they can continue to pay six figure
salaries and put more of their budget into pension plans than to
actually help any animals. Last year HSUS spent less than 1/2 of 1% of
their almost $100 Million dollar budget on direct animal care www.humanewatch.org ..." (from a UOH press release in April)
No sources are given as to how one can apply for Medicaid and food
stamps for horses (unfortunately). And, the accusation in regards to
the HSUS budget expenditures cannot be verified on any charity research
website (Charity Navigator, Guidestar), nor the website listed in the
press release.
So, in light of these statements, one can only gather that "like-minded equine associations and individuals" consist of those that do not challenge Mr. Duquette's or Rep. Wallis' "facts", plans or behavior in any fashion whatsoever.
Rep. Wallis is up for re-election on November 11, (after winning the Republican primary in her district by only 177 votes).
It is beyond disturbing that on August 30, of this year, Mr.
Duquette, president of a 501(c)(3) charitable organization specifically
forbidden under Federal law in participating in any campaign activity
for or against political candidates, was listed by the Wyoming
Elections Commission as the Chairman of the United Organizations of the
Horse Political Action Fund (http://soswy.state.wy.us/Elections/Docs/WY_PAC.pdf).
Rep. Wallis is, of course, the Executive Director of the UOH.
This series will conclude with a final article on the
questionable relationship the UOH has with horse slaughter buyers and a
recap and review of the facts.
More information:
http://www.oregonlive.com/news/index.ssf/2009/07/groups_push_to_slaughter_horse.html
http://www.unitedorgsofthehorse.org
http://www.facebook.com/pages/United-Horsemens-Front/261616654545