5-39/225- October 24, 2010
 
 

logo for e-letter on black


HORSE SENSE
Periodic updates about issues and actions concerning New York City's Carriage Horses +
Coalition to Ban Horse-Drawn Carriages www.banhdc.org

Horses Without Carriages International www.horseswithoutcarriages.org

PLEASE FORWARD TO LISTS, FRIENDS & COLLEAGUES ** Where the issue is ** Lea Michele blogs ** Mark your calendars ** Videos ** Rome

THE ISSUE -- WHERE WE ARE
We have made a lot of progress
horse tied up 2 No one ever said banning the carriage horse industry in NYC would be easy. Certainly not us. We went into this with our eyes open knowing it could take years. But that is what campaigns are all about -- whether it was abolishing slavery or getting women's suffrage. It is about having the stamina, resolve and fortitude to stick it out through thick and thin. It is about not giving up. The campaign for women's rights began in 1848. Remember the names of leaders - Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Susan B. Anthony and Lucretia Mott? They staged demonstrations, engaged in civil disobedience, began legal challenges, and pressed their case state by state. But it was not until 1920, with the passage of the 19th Amendment, that the United States finally got universal suffrage. This was a much bigger and more complicated issue, but I bring it up to show that it took a long time and was a consistent well fought campaign. So knowing how institutionalized this politically connected trade is, it makes sense that it would take a long time - although we certainly do not expect that it will take that long. The issue must remain in the spotlight; must remain on the radar screen and we can never allow our elected representatives to assume that no one cares about these horses.

Please make note of some of our major accomplishments over the past 4 1/2 years and know that we are not going away. While we do not yet have a ban, we have made progress:

  • We persuaded the Comptroller's office to do a first ever performance audit of the City agencies that oversee the carriage industry - Department of Health and Consumer Affairs, which turned up damning evidence
  • We got the NY Times to do a story when the actual audit was not even on the Comptroller's web site suggesting that it was being suppressed
  • We convinced former Council Member Tony Avella to introduce the first ever bill to ban the industry -- this was a major accomplishment and brought much attention to this issue.
  • We persuaded Council Member Melissa Mark Viverito to combine both the Avella bill and the vintage electric car bill - so that it would save the horses from the auctions -- something that the electric car bill did not do on its own.
  • Over the last 4 1/2 years, we have made this an issue where there had been none for over 12 years -- reeducating the media, City Council and the public.
  • We rescued Bobby, a former NYC carriage horse, from the slaughter auctions in June of 2010 -- proving that some of these horses do go to the auctions, where they are made available to kill buyers.
  • In the last 4 1/2 years, we generated countless letters to the editor, articles, TV coverage on this issue -- educating many people and keeping the issue alive.
  • In 2008, we started Horses Without Carriages International - a global coalition representing 19 cities that want an end to their horse-drawn carriage trade.

Unless Speaker Christine Quinn and Mayor Bloomberg have a major epiphany, there is no chance that Intro 86A will pass and be signed into law during their term in office. We need to accept that. But that does not mean that they are off the hook. They represent you. And you cannot let your Council Member off the hook either. Please contact your Council Member through the council web site by clicking here. Do the same with Mayor Bloomberg. Click here. Tell them that you want to see an end to the horse-drawn carriage industry and ask them to support Intro 86A.

As with most campaigns, it takes a village. While we have been involved consistently with this campaign for almost five years, other organizations have put in a few years, did flashy campaigns, raised money and left town. Fair weather friends. Still others say they are for a ban, but they do not show it with their actions. So I want to acknowledge our two Coalition partners -- Friends of Animals, an international animal rights organization, and Heart for Animals, a local grass roots animal rights organization for sticking with this. Special acknowledgment to Priscilla Feral, president of Friends of Animals, for understanding that this was a campaign that needed time and attention.

LEA MICHELE OF GLEE
guest blogger on The Kind Life - talks about NYC's horses
horse eating on ice #1 The Kind Life is Alicia Silverstone's blog. She recently invited Lea Michele to be a guest blogger. This is her entry. Horses - By Lea Michele - October 21, 2010 - Friends, My name is Lea and I grew up in New York. Growing up, I was the little girl who always wanted to save the animals. I even would ask my mom to buy me stuffed animals that looked sad because I felt bad for them. When I was about 10, I found a box of kittens someone had left on the beach. I tried my best to care for them, and while some were able to be saved, many were taken from their mother too early and we didn't get to them fast enough. To this day it's still sometimes so hard for me to not get overwhelmed by all the animals out there that need help.

My biggest trouble these days are the poor horses in Central Park. Living in New York City, I see them sadly standing on the sides of busy streets with their heads right in the asses of the horse right in front of them! They walk in the rain, snow, and heat, pulling people all day long, rarely getting proper food, water or care. I know people may not understand - maybe they just want to take their kids for a ride through Central Park, but trust me, you'll do better for you're kids if you take them for a walk! Sometimes I wish I could just go and set them free on some sunny field somewhere where they could just roam free and run around all day. I know that sounds cheesy but if you saw them, trust me, you would want to do the same.

If you live in New York, next time you're walking down Central Park Blvd. and you see tourists considering going for a ride, suggest to them that they take a stroll through Strawberry Field instead--the horses cant go through there-or rent a bike...or now they even have people who ride bikes and have seats for people on the back! It's so much more fun! Like I said, some people just don't understand the severity of this situation so it's our job to spread the word in a loving way. If you're traveling to NYC and see these sweet creatures, give them a pet and send them some love, and hope that this will end soon. So that's all for today. Much love...

OUR HOLIDAY PLANS FOR THE HORSES
mark your calendars
water trough 2 The busiest season for the NYC carriage horse trade is from Thanksgiving through January 1st. This is the time when people line up to take a ride. The water troughs are empty and filled with garbage. The horses work non stop with no rest. The ASPCA HLE officers do not enforce the law that requires a 15 minute break every two hours.

We will be planning events through this period - please stay tuned for details. One definite day to save is Saturday, December 4th, which is Horses Without Carriages International Day when groups in cities around the world protest the use of horse-drawn carriages in the tourist trade.

CARRIAGE HORSE ISSUE VIDEOS
a must see
crowd lined up Intro 35A was signed into law by Mayor Bloomberg in April 2010. It is a bogus law and does nothing to help the horses. Its main purpose was a raise for the drivers. Click here.

In case you forgot or did nor know what happened at the bill signing. Click here.

WHAT'S HAPPENING IN ROME
petitions presented to government on Monday, 10/25
Rome - child On Monday, October 25th, representatives from several animal rights groups will hold a press conference in Rome to present 5,000 signatures to the mayor -- signatures of people who want the carriage horse industry in Rome -- called Botticelle - to be shut down. For those who speak Italian - this is a link to an article in Il Messagero dated October 24th.

The circle on the picture is calling attention to the driver helping to move a young child to the seat next to him. This is against the law, as it is in NYC. It seems like the authorities look the other way.

A recent survey in La Repubblica Roma asked if the Botticelle should be banned from Rome. The results were: 85% voted yes; 14% voted no and 1% did not know. Anytime a poll is done in NYC, there are similar results.

JOIN US ON FACE BOOK & SIGN ONLINE PETITION
facebook logo

See our Facebook page called No Walk in the Park. And while you are there, please join another anti carriage horse page by a colleague called 212HorsePower

"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has." Margaret Mead.

Thank you for caring about the horses, Elizabeth Forel - Coalition to Ban Horse-Drawn Carriages - a standing committee of The Coalition for New York City Animals, Inc.

Please DONATE to our campaign to ban the inhumane and unsafe carriage horse industry.

Email Marketing by