5-31/216- August 8, 2010
 
 

logo for e-letter on black


HORSE SENSE
Periodic updates about issues and actions concerning New York City's Carriage Horses +
Coalition to Ban Horse-Drawn Carriages www.banhdc.org

Horses Without Carriages International www.horseswithoutcarriages.org

PLEASE FORWARD TO LISTS, FRIENDS & COLLEAGUES ** fire at Chateau stable ** Take action ** Houston accident ** Volunteer

FIRE AT CHATEAU STABLE ON 48TH ST.
No horses injured -- sprinkler law required - take action
Fire Chateau According to WABC TV news and eye witnesses, a fire broke out at Chateau Stables on Thursday night. We heard that no horses were injured. This from WABC: August 6, 2010 -- WEST SIDE (WABC) -- A horse stable on Manhattan's West Side caught on fire Thursday. The electrical fire started at Chateau Stables just after 9 p.m. on West 48th street between 11th and 12th avenues. The fire department quickly got the fire under control. There were no injuries, and it appears none of the carriage horses needed to be evacuated. See this video of the damage on Youtube.

Sprinklers are not a legal requirement for NYC horse stables although stables generally house very flammable material -- such as hay, wood stalls and carriages ...not to mention the lives of the many horses who are stuck on the upper floors and whose only means of egress is the ramp, which will act as a chimney if there is a fire. This has been an issue that has been suppressed by the City Council for years. More than five years ago there was actually a bill that called for sprinklers in horse stables that was killed. More recently a bill that called for sprinklers in establishments that house animals - such as pet stores - has been ignored.

To add insult to injury, in February, the Department of Health (DoH) proposed the following changes to Article 161 of the NYC Health Code. . The DoH rescinded the proposal when Intro 35-A was passed. Intro 35-A did not address these issues.

  • (6) Fire hazards. Premises shall be kept free of fire hazards. Effective July 1, 2011, all buildings in which stables are located shall be equipped with an operational sprinkler system installed in accordance with �BC903.3.1.1 of the New York City Building Code, or successor provision. (8) Electrical wiring. (A) All electrical appliances shall be plugged directly into properly grounded electrical outlets. (B) Electrical wiring shall be installed and maintained in metal electrical conduits. (C) Extension cords may be used for brief periods of time, not to exceed three (3) hours, and 25 such cords shall be disconnected and removed when the appliances or tools to which they are connected are not being used.

PLEASE CONTACT YOUR COUNCIL MEMBER: Tell them that sprinklers must be required in horse stables, which are highly flammable by nature. Tell them about the fire at Chateau Stables, which could have been much worse. Ask them to support a bill to require sprinklers in all stables. Click Here for the council web site. It is preferred to send a snail mail letter or fax. E-mail is not guaranteed to get through. Also contact MAYOR BLOOMBERG - on line -- or by snail mail at Mayor Michael Bloomberg, City Hall, New York, NY 10007

PLEASE CONTINUE TO TAKE ACTION
contact Speaker Quinn and your Council Member
fire at chateau It is a challenge to know what to do any more. The most important thing is that you must not allow any of the elected representatives to assume you have given up on this issue. The City Council with its 51 Council Members has little power. However, it is OK to continue to let them know that you want to see the carriage industry end -- after all, they should hear from their constituents. But all the power lies with the Council Speaker, Christine Quinn, so I ask you to reach out to her in a polite way. A majority of council members could sign on to Intro 86, but if Quinn does not support it, it will go no where. She calls the shots. She decides what bills will come up for a vote and which ones will be supported.

Nevertheless, she needs to know that there are people out there who want to see this industry end. It is inhumane for the horses, but also a safety issue for people. In addition, if the classic cars became a reality, the drivers would have better paying and more secure jobs. How can she be opposed to that?

Quinn is not animal friendly and is a big friend to the industry. But she needs to hear from the opposition. She can be contacted through her web site. Please be polite. Click here to contact her. You may also contact your Council Members by clicking here.

CONTACT TOURISM AGENCY
2nd suggestion
NYC and Company is the official tourism agency in partnership with the City of NY. They are one of the prime resources to the mayor regarding tourism. Please write to the head of this agency,
  • George A. Fertitta -- gfertitta@nycgo.com

You can address such issues as the industry being a blot on NYC's image; how Central Park South smells very badly; how it is inherently inhumane; how it is dangerous and an accident waiting to happen. Because of their size and physiology, horses are unwitting weapons. They can spook easily and cause a lot of damage. Recently, an accident in Iowa involving carriage horses resulted in the death of one woman and injuries to 25 others. If you do not live in NYC, say that you will not visit the city - or how you have avoided the area if you have visited. Also say that the new legislation did not do anything to help the horses - that it was mainly about giving the drivers a raise. Horses are still deprived of water in Central Park in the winter months and their stalls are less than half of what experts suggest.

DRIVER ALLOWS CHILD TO DRIVE CARRIAGE
It's illegal but hey -- who's watching!
kid driving It's the Wild Wild West on Central Park South as the carriage drivers continue to get away with anything they want. No one is minding the store. This is a short video on Youtube showing a young girl with the reins. She may well have been an experienced carriage driver but the point is that it is illegal. If an accident happened while she was driving, the City would be sued with tax payers picking up the tab.

The law referenced is � 17-334.1 from the NYC Administrative Code, which says that it is unlawful to permit a horse carriage to be operated by a person who does not possess a current valid driver's license. We have registered complaints with the authorities (not ASPCA). Who wants to bet me a Starbucks' tall soy latte that they will do nothing?

INTERESTING BLOGS ABOUT THIS ISSUE
Some of you may be aware of James LaVeck's recent video Silencing of the Lambs. It has caused much discussion in the animal rights community about abolitionist vs. incremental campaigns. Our campaign to ban horse-drawn carriages is abolitionist as opposed to regulatory / incremental. We feel strongly from working on this issue for many years that it is a waste of time to TRY to negotiate better conditions for the horses. It did not work with Intro 35A and it really never worked before when so called improvements were lost with the next round of legislation. We would have spent the same (if not more) time on an "improvements" campaign - fighting for a square foot here or a degree there would have been enervating and exhausting and even if we won some so called improvements, which I doubt very much, it would not have significantly changed anything. The horses deserve so much more. Maybe this is why we are still energized after 4 1/2 years.

This does not mean, however, that we will not pressure the City Council to show some integrity, compassion and responsibility and pass a bill to require sprinklers in stables ... or to point out that Intro 35 A requires a minimum size of 60 sq. ft. for stalls when experts recommend 144 sq. ft. for standard bred horses. But this is not the core of our campaign, which is the end to this inherently inhumane trade.

Just a little slice of light is by Barbara Sitomer, a vegan baker who owns GonePie. Sitomer talks about abolitionist and single issue campaigns. Another interesting blog comes out of Canada by Vegan Activist: Quebec: End your use of horses in city streets.

HOUSTON CARRIAGE HORSE RESCUED FROM STORM DRAIN
irresponsible driver left her unattended
Click 2 Houston.com 7/24/10 - Horse Caught In Storm Drain Rescued Animal Taken To SPCA, Expected To Recover HOUSTON -- A horse was rescued after getting caught in a storm drain and falling in the middle of downtown Houston, KPRC Local 2 reported. Police said the mare, named Dolly, trapped her hind legs in the drain, fell and flipped her carriage over on Prairie at Travis at about 7 p.m. Friday. Witnesses said her driver had tied Dolly to a pole and went in to grab a slice of pizza when the accident happened. Police and a wrecker driver sedated Dolly, poured oil on her hooves and finally had to break up the metal plates to free her. Dolly was taken to the SPCA and is said to be walking on her own.

See this shocking video.

Her irresponsible driver left her to get a slice of pizza. We see this all the time in NYC. In 2007, Smoothie, a young mare, was tied up on Central Park South and was spooked by a loud noise. Her driver was not near her - he was most likely off talking with his friends. Smoothie panicked and pulled away from her post only to crash into a tree and she dropped dead on the spot. If her driver had been paying attention, it is possible he could have immediately calmed her when he saw her going into a spook.

VOLUNTEER & BE PART OF OUR E-MAIL LIST
We are looking for volunteers to participate in tabling to get out educational information; to help with our upcoming fund raiser and to coordinate volunteers. We are also looking for someone to do legal research - preferably a law student. Please send us an e-mail at volunteerforthecoalition@gmail.com if you can help.

If you would like to be part of our Action Alert e-mail list, please send an e-mail to coalition@banhdc.org. E-mails will be sent out when action is needed such as writing letters to the editor of a publication or a legislator.

HOLD THE DATE FOR OUR FUNDRAISER
Monday evening October 4, 2010
We are planning a fund raiser party to benefit the Coalition to Ban Horse-Drawn Carriages on Monday, October 4, 2010 in the evening. Please save the date. More details to follow. Promise: a good time!

JOIN US ON FACE BOOK & SIGN ONLINE PETITION
facebook logo

"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has." Margaret Mead.

Thank you for caring about the horses, Elizabeth Forel - Coalition to Ban Horse-Drawn Carriages - a standing committee of The Coalition for New York City Animals, Inc.

Please DONATE to our campaign to ban the inhumane and unsafe carriage horse industry.

Email Marketing by