Emotions, Logic, and Reliability
By: Kelly Hammel, LMSW
It's a common saying that "Facts don't lie." Sometimes, though I wonder if interpretation of facts is quite that clear cut. Interpretation usually is influenced by feelings and emotions. How reliable are emotions? When it comes to decision making, some of us tend to lean on our emotions while some of us want our judgement to be based solely on reason and logic. What is the right role for the influence of emotions on our brains?
Research in the past 10 years has shed a great deal of light on our brain and how it is affected by trauma. We now can see through functional MRI's that our brain's responsiveness to the world around us is actually changed by trauma, drug abuse, physical abuse and even extreme emotional abuse, especially early in life.
Due to the brokenness of our world and the effect it's had on our minds, many of us struggle with difficult emotions and difficulty making decisions.
Emotions are very powerful and can often cloud the process of decision making. On the other hand, those who may rely entirely on logic and judgement can also find themselves detached from key elements of decision making and often "stuck" searching for the perfect choice.
The truth is that we should not rely entirely on either our emotional responses or our cognitive processes. God gave us extremely complex minds and due to sin our minds have not been "perfect" since The Fall. Research now shows that our life experiences are so powerful that they are capable of changing our brain chemistry. However, we have an all loving and graceful God that is waiting for us to turn to Him for clarity of thought, peace of mind and direction. God also gave us the Bible, the Holy Spirit, trusted friends, prayer, tradition, as well as emotion and the ability to reason.
If all of these God given tools are carefully employed together, Godly decisions can be made. So, as we grow in faith we should strive to function using a balance of healthy emotion AND reason, along with the other tools God has made available to us. It may seem easier and sometimes natural to just rely on one tool entirely, but Truth is often found when we slow down and make sure all of our God given resources are in agreement with each other!