Many U.S. coffee drinkers prefer lighter roasts, so Starbucks
set out to meet the demand. It took, according to
Fast Company, "a multitude of beans" and 80 experiments with roasting time and temperature before executives were satisfied.
Starbucks failed 79 times.
The stories of companies and individuals failing before wildly succeeding are legion. Consider Coca-Cola's "New Coke" experiment, and the Wright brothers' attempts at flying. IDEO, the design consultancy, coined a now-famous phrasethat guides its work: "Fail often to succeed sooner."
Encouraging Christian institutions to "fail often" sounds like Albert Einstein's famous definition of insanity. One bishop, being urged to innovate, fail and adapt, said the clergy in his area are far too comfortable with failure -- failed sermons, failed stewardship campaigns, failed programs and, ultimately, failing congregations.
The challenge for Christian leaders is to rethink our notions about failure.
All failure is not bad; what is bad, and what is hampering our institutions, is failing to learn from it. And that is what the bishop was talking about -- contentment withmediocrity rather than a passionate commitment to experiment, evaluate, adapt and experiment again, for the sake of the gospel.
It is true to our calling as Christians to embrace failure.
As New Testament scholar C. Kavin Rowe reminds us, "Failure is at the heart of what Christian leaders have to offer the world." We follow a Lord who died on the cross for our sins. We know humans to be broken, and we seek forgiveness for what we have done and left undone.
The practices of confession and forgiveness ought to be in the DNA of our institutions.
Pastor and author Rob Bell tells a story of a pottery teacher's experiment, recounted in "Art and Fear" by David Bayles and Ted Orland. The teacher divides a class in half, telling one group of beginning potters to make as many pots as they can. The other group is to make the best pot. Who succeeds? The potters who make the most pots -- learning through trial and (a lot of) error.
"God takes blood and rejection and a spear in the side and abandonment of the disciples, and takes the whole big mess and out of it makes something beautiful," Bell said in a speech at Duke Divinity School. "When your worth and value are tied up in outcomes, it can drain the liferight out of you, because there's no way to deal with the failures. Nothing is wasted in God's economy."
What do Christian leaders, and our organizations, need in order to embrace the type of failure that leads to innovation?
We need first to distinguish between "bad" failure and "good" failure. We can't tolerate failure that compromises the integrity of our organizations, whether through moral and financial improprieties or not following through with promises made to key constituents. Nor should we tolerate failure that is the result of bureaucratic messes or contentment with the status quo.
But we can support experiments and develop processes that ensure that we are staying true to our missions. When we encourage experiments, we will inevitably discover that things don't always work as we anticipated. So long as we learn from our experiments and continually adapt, we will be cultivating good failure.
What can we do to encourage experiments?
A first step is the development of teams and networks.
Individuals can come up with fine ideas, but friends, co-workers and colleagues in other institutions can help refine them. Teams of people with diverse skills encourage one another to take risks, help one another cope with failure and support one another in learning from that failure.
IDEO's design process includes pulling together a team of people with different skills to develop ideas in collaboration.
Duke University men's basketball coach Mike Krzyzewski said that cultivating a sense of shared purpose can bring people together and enable them to experiment in ways that promote continual learning.
"Mutual commitment helps overcome the fear of failure -- especially when people are part of a team sharing and achieving goals," he writes in "Leading with the Heart." "It also sets the stage for open dialogue and honest conversation."
Make time to experiment a priority.
Google developed a system called 70/20/10. Employees were encouraged to focus on their core responsibilities 70 percent of the time, join another team for 20 percent, and spend the final 10 percent "on something blue sky."
What guiding principles could you design that encourage employees to dream big, recognizing that such dreams inevitably will involve failure?
read more
Awakenings: A feast for the head, heart and spirit
