May 2010
Market
Update - Volt Tactical US Equity Strategies
Over the last month we have seen the first signs
of
significant market weakness since the current market rally began in
mid-March
2009. The S&P 500 lost -6.3%
during the first week in May alone, and six of the nine sector ETFs that
we invest in lost
even more than the S&P 500 during that week. Therefore, while we do
not
traditionally provide market updates mid-quarter, we felt that the
extent of
the market volatility is such that an update is warranted.
In the interest of efficiency, we will
start by providing the key takeaways from the commentary Summary, and
then we
will follow with a more detailed explanation:
· While we currently have maintained a "fully
invested" investment position since late 2009 (all nine sectors
invested), the
increased volatility and market weakness for a majority of the
underlying
sectors has translated to a changed environment biased towards continued
weakness for several of the sectors.
· Based on current conditions, we would
anticipate that over the next several weeks it is likely that at least
one and
potentially three sectors could turn negative and be removed from the
portfolio.
· The likelihood of six sectors turning off and
beginning to build a position in short-term Treasuries is not likely
unless we
see meaningfully more market deterioration.
Market
Status - Backdrop
The performance of the sectors of the S&P 500 continued to weaken in May, building on the trend that began in early April. In fact, as of May 18, all nine sectors are now below their high points in 2010, with three of the sectors having declined more than 11% from the 2010 highs (Materials, Energy and Financials). The best performer has been Consumer Staples, which is only off 2.5%. To compound the challenge, based on the analytics we use, our internal evaluation of volatility has shown a very consistent increase from the beginning of the year. In fact, eight of the nine sectors have seen our measure of volatility increase 50% or more, and three of the sectors have seen volatility more than double year to date (Technology, Utilities, and Health Care). The only sector which has maintained a reasonably stable volatility level is Financials, but that is ironically due to the fact that Financials, unlike the other sectors, never benefited from as significant a decline in volatility from the extreme levels in 2008 and 2009.
Implications
for Portfolios - US Equity
We make all portfolio decisions based purely on
quantitative data and tools. Therefore, all decisions are made
completely
objectively and unemotionally. This point is worth emphasizing because
periods
where there is a meaningful change in profile of the markets,
characterized by
many of the sectors either turning off or back on, are, by definition,
highly
uncertain periods with massive amounts of conflicting data. Our track
records
have been built on the premise that such environments are prone to emotionally-based
mistakes, and that therefore an objective, quantitative approach is
the
right answer to successfully navigate such decision points. To put our investment approach in its
most simplistic terms, our analysis is attempting to determine, sector
by
sector, whether the current market weakness is likely to continue. We
recognize
that all of the sectors have shown a recent downturn and a shift in
trend from
their prior extended market gains. The key question to determine is
whether or
not the past several weeks represent a modest correction in a
longer-term bull
market or a break in environment, and now reflect a higher than
desirable
probability that the weakness will continue. Again, this assessment is
made
sector by sector. Key to our
analysis are extent of the loss, the period of time the losses are
incurring,
and whether or not the losses are accompanied by an increased level of
volatility.
Summary
At this point, it now appears that several of the
sectors appear to be in or are approaching the range where the
probability of
further losses are sufficient for turning off one or more of those
sectors.
While all nine sectors remain on within all of our US Equity portfolios,
we
would anticipate that at least one and potentially three or four of the
sectors
could be turned off over the next several weeks - assuming the current
market
conditions remain in place. After
nearly five months with all nine sectors positive, the environment for
several
of the sectors appears to have changed to a negative bias. However, we
do not
at this point see evidence that the weakness has spread to enough
sectors to
suggest beginning to build a position in short-term Treasuries. Our
investment
models require six of the nine sectors to turn negative in order for a
classification of a "bear market" and a subsequent position in
Treasuries to
begin being built. We do not see such a situation occurring unless there
is
more extended or accelerating market weakness.
** This report is meant to inform the reader
of our current market opinion, which we, as professional money
managers,use in our decision-making. It should be
noted that stock market and bond market data are subject to varying
interpretations and any one interpretation
will not necessarily guarantee investment success. The information
obtained from the sources specified herein and used as
basis for our current market opinion is believed reliable, but we do not
guarantee
the accuracy of such information.