US to Play 'Very Major Role' In Helping Europe: Geithner
(Click on image or headline for story)
Say What?
You may remember that it was just this past summer that this chart was making the rounds.

The stories that accompanied it purported to show that there was very little exposure to the US from what was going on in Europe. You may recall that we questioned that belief at the time.
Well now we have Treasury Secretary Geithner saying that the US will play a "very major role" role in the European bailout.
A Few Questions!
-How are we (the US taxpayers) going to play a major role?
-Why are we going to play a major role?
-What is the risk to the US in playing that role/what is the risk in not playing that role?
-And finally, can we afford to play that role?
The How
Let's start with the how. Here is the second paragraph from the article.
"With global leaders preparing for next month's Group of 20 nations (G20) summit in Cannes, France, the International Monetary Fund - of which the U.S. is the greatest contributor - is being relied on to help underwrite whatever efforts are needed to backstop toxic European sovereign debt ."
We are the greatest contributor to the IMF. That means that a great share of the money that the IMF uses to bail out the PIIGS comes directly from US taxpayers so that is the how.
The Why?
Why? If there is so little risk to the US from what is going on in Europe, why are we playing a very major role? We've got our own problems here at home to deal with.
My belief is that the reason we are doing this is that there is way more risk to the US system than they have been letting on. I believe the feeling is that they would rather "stop it over there" before it spills over to our shores.
What Are The Risks?
As with any strategy there are always risks so the issue becomes which risks are the more prudent or acceptable? I just want to address here what I think are the two main risks, so this is not meant to be an all-inclusive discussion of risk.
I think that the main risk in playing the role is that we waste resources that could better be used here at home. As Jim Rogers pointed out in this article on September 28, 2011 ( http://www.moneynews.com/StreetTalk/Rogers-US-Threats-Europe/2011/09/28/id/412527 ), the US has states that are bigger than Greece that are in worse financial shape than Greece. Might those resources better be used here at home.
On the other hand if we don't help and things come crashing down over there it will surely spread to this country. I think seeing it happen on our shores will have a much more severe impact on our citizen's confidence than seeing it happen over in Europe.
Can we afford it?
Here is my biggest concern. Can we afford it? Why is Greece (and the rest of the PIIGS for that matter) in trouble? They have too much debt! Other countries were willing to loan to Greece as long as they had a reasonable expectation of getting paid back.
Unfortunately for Greece, it has become apparent that they don't have the ability to pay the money back so other countries have stopped loaning to them.
Now here comes the US (through the IMF) saying we will help guarantee this bailout of Greece, et al. But where does the US get the money that they give the IMF? Is it surplus from our tax revenues? Nope. We borrow it!
So let's see, Greece is in this mess because they borrowed money until no one would loan to them anymore. Now the US is going to help guarantee the bailout by borrowing (until they can't borrow anymore?). Wow, isn't it ironic?
As I've said in the past folks, the only real difference between the situation in Greece vs. the situation here in the US is that Greece has reached the end of their credit limit, the US hasn't, YET!
Our advice going forward continues to be use caution, there is way more risk out there right now than many want to acknowledge. If you would like some ideas on how to do that give us a call!
ECONOMIC CALENDAR:
Monday - Empire State Mfg Survey, Industrial Production Tuesday - Producer Price Index, Treasury International Capital, Housing Market Index, Ben Bernanke Speaks at 1:15 PM ET Wednesday -Consumer Price Index, Housing Starts, EIA Petroleum Status Report, Beige Book Thursday - Jobless Claims, Existing Home Sales, Philadelphia Fed Survey, Leading Indicators
|