top
I N N O V A T O R
News about high school innovation
.
May 15, 2009
Welcome to INNOVATOR, a bimonthly report on high school change in North Carolina from the North Carolina New Schools Project. INNOVATOR informs practitioners, policy makers, and friends of public education about high school innovation in North Carolina as well as success stories and research from across the nation.
Quick Links
NC New Schools Project

In This Issue
New early college graduates help lead innovation in NC
Gov. Perdue calls early colleges critical to the future
NCNSP coaches see gains in effective teaching practices
Congressional committee weighs high school crisis
First graduates of early colleges blazing trails for innovation

Among the 314 associates degrees being conferred tonight at Isothermal Community College in Rutherford County, 20 will be handed to graduates who just a few days ago received their high school diplomas.

They'll trade the black-and-silver tassels they wore for high school commencement for the all-black tassels of the community college.

The graduates are among the first students who helped launch Rutherford Early College High School when it opened in the 2005-2006 school year -- one of 13 early colleges established that year. Four years later, those students represent the leading edge of high school innovation in North Carolina, where for a growing number of students, one tassel isn't enough. Sixty early college high schools were open this year, and 12 more are on track to open next year.

Nearly 300 students are graduating this spring from the state's first early colleges, and while not all of them earned an associate's degree, many who did are the first in their families to do so. Even those who are finishing without an associate's degree now have a head start on college with a year or more of transferable credit. Many other students who started early college in 2005 are returning for a fifth year to earn their associate's degree.

Jessica Butler didn't just earn an associate's degree from Isothermal and her high school diploma from Rutherford Early College, she accomplished both in three years. She'll attend East Carolina University beginning this fall with plans to study microbiology. Neither of her parents went to college.

She said the school's small size helped her forge close relationships with teachers and other students, creating the kind of school "family" that supported her to do her very best.

"You're friends with everyone," Jessica said. "It makes the learning environment so much more fun. This has been the best decision of my life."

Cross Creek Early College High School, on the campus of Fayetteville State University, will also reach a milestone during its commencement ceremony May 22, when 64 students are expected to graduate -- the largest inaugural class yet to finish one of the state's early colleges. Close behind is Josephine Dobbs Clement Early College High School at N.C. Central University in Durham, with 59 graduates expected, which claimed the distinction last year of graduating the state's very first full, four-year early college class.

Kurtys Haumann-Neal, who will graduate next week from Cross Creek, will attend UNC Greensboro in the fall, just a few courses shy of his junior year. As an eighth grader, Kurtys said, he thought he'd never finish high school.

"Things weren't going so well," Kurtys said. "My academics had been terrible."

In the essay he wrote as part of his application to Cross Creek, he said, "I told them straight up that I didn't think I would do anything with my life." He went from a D average in middle school to an A-B average during his senior year. For his college classes alone this semester, his GPA was a 3.2. What made the difference, he said, were his teachers.

"When I first got to Cross Creek, I didn't like teachers and hated school," he said. "I wasn't good in school, and I didn't like being there. Several teachers changed things for me." Two, in particular, reached out to him during his freshman year, which had been complicated at home by a two-year deployment of his mother, an Army master sergeant, to Korea.

"I realized that teachers can also be your friends," Kurtys said. "I realized what good teachers are. They show you. They make things real. They're there when you need them, and they let you know they'll be there for you."

Teachers at Cross Creek, he said, show students how to learn. "All students at Cross Creek would agree that that the school educates them, it doesn't just teach them.

Now Kurtys wants to be a teacher himself. He wants to teach math or English to 9th graders, back at Cross Creek or a similar kind of break-the-mold school.

"All students should have the same opportunity," he said.

Early college high schools put a priority on student success, so whether a student finishes in four or five years is less important than reaching the goal of strong college preparation and attainment.

Challenger Early College High School in Hickory saw 13 students graduate last week, all with high school diplomas and associate's degrees or two years of transferable college credit. Two more will do the same by the end of the summer. But about 60 others will return in the fall and finish in December or next spring -- all with a high school diploma as well as significant college credit.

"We run ... exactly the same way the college does:  there is no 'not making it,' there's only 'when you make it,' " said Robert Daniel, Jr., principal of Challenger ECHS, located at Catawba Valley Community College. "No matter what, every student who finishes this program at all finishes with 2 credentials:  a high school diploma and some kind of terminal credential from CVCC."

Other early college high schools with graduates this spring include GTCC Early/Middle College-Jamestown, Robeson ECHS, Davidson ECHS, Edgecombe ECHS, Nash-Rocky Mount ECHS, Anson ECHS and Buncombe ECHS

Gov. Perdue reiterates support for early college high school

In a recent video blog, Gov. Beverly Perdue pledged continuing support for early college high schools after receiving an email from a citizen concerned about funding for the innovative schools.

Here's part of her response: "It's critical that we do whatever it takes to keep kids in school, and kids have got have skill sets to compete in the 21st century workforce. I believe a lot of these early college programs make it possible for kids who don't fit in to the traditional public school classroom to go on and get what they need and two years of community college."

She notes that her budget proposal includes nearly $2.5 million in additional funding to add 12 new schools this year, so the program "is not just intact but growing."

"Early college programs are critical to the future," she said. "Early college is a definite tool that works in a 21st century economy."

Back to top
 
Instructional coaches see gains in teaching and learning

As the school year nears its end, students aren't the only ones taking stock of what's been learned since August. On Thursday, 37 of NC New Schools Project's Instructional Coaches gathered at a day-long session to discuss progress they have seen in innovative high schools across the state and challenges that remain in transforming teaching and learning, as well as to share examples of effective practice that emerged in their work with teachers.

During a "speed share" of one-minute reflections on success, coaches mentioned changes that ranged from a skeptical English teacher opening her classroom to allow a coach to model literature circles to a lateral entry science teacher who had moved away from constant lectures after collecting data from students about how they learn to a teacher nominated for a district award who chose to present her work on integrating NCNSP's common instructional framework to demonstrate outstanding practice.

Coaches noted that receptivity to their work has grown this school year. "Last year, I had to ask teachers about when I might come to their rooms," a coach remarked. "This year, they stop me in the hall and ask me to come see something they are doing."

At the same time, coaches believe their own practice is stronger. "We were much more passive voice last year," said coach Deborah Matthews. "Now, we're much more active voice saying, 'This really is the way it is.' "

Coaches spent most of the day sharing portfolios of their work one-on-one and in small groups. Coach Becky Finger described her work with a senior English teacher who built her course around a set of themes and essential questions, mixing class-wide and student-selected readings and offering different project options for students to demonstrate their knowledge. Finger also helped the teacher include 21st century skills such as communications and teamwork into the assessment of student work.

Nearby, coaches Donna Clelland and Mary Jo Pritchard were deep in discussion about the relative merits of the approaches each took to observing teachers' questioning techniques - one providing a structured self-assessment, the other offering an external appraisal.

Coaches noted that work remains to be done to continue to raise rigor in teaching and learning, to integrate elements of the NCNSP framework and to use data to guide instruction.

But the impact of their work is already clear, coaches said. "The student engagement is so incredibly positive," said coach Anne Murr.

Back to top
House panel studies US competitiveness, high school success
 
The connection between the nation's economic competitiveness and its persistently high dropout rates and low graduation statistics were put under a microscope earlier this week by a Congressional committee.

The panel heard testimony from a number of leading experts in high school innovation, including Vicki Phillips, education director for the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation; Bob Wise, president of the Alliance for Excellent Education; and Robert Balfanz, a leading high school researcher and co-director of the Everyone Graduates Center at Johns Hopkins University.

Rep. George Miller, a California Democrat who is chairman of the House Education and Labor Committee, opened the hearing by taking a measure of the scope of the problem.

"Some may think twice about using the word "crisis" to define what's happening in our high schools," he said in prepared remarks. "But the truth is, we aren't just facing a crisis -- the house is on fire."

He cited the statistics: 70 percent graduation rate, 55 percent four-year graduation rate for black students, 52 percent for Hispanics, Census data showing that nearly 20 percent of males between 16 and 24  have dropped out, the nation's low rank among industrialized countries -- 18th of 24 -- for high school graduation rates.

In her testimony, Phillips said that even among students who do graduate, too few of them are making strong gains during high school.

"We need to face the fact that too many students in high school are frozen; they are not making nearly the academic progress they need to make to be ready for the demands of college, work and life," she said in her prepared statement.

To reverse that, she said, students need to make a "breakthrough" in performance, which the Gates Foundation believes can be achieved with a three-pronged strategy that focuses on teacher effectiveness and empowerment, the importance of standards that are fewer, clearer and higher and the pursuit of innovations that can lead to dramatic improvements in performance.

"The evidence is clear that the combination of high schools as currently constructed and the tools in our hands will not be sufficient to meet our goal of 80 percent of low-income students ready for college by 2025," Phillips said. "We cannot make a leap in performance without a leap in innovation that much more directly and productively engages students in accelerating their learning.

"We are going to continue to fund school models that break the mold and achieve results, and next generation models of teaching and learning. The measure for the success of any innovation will be true acceleration of performance -- as measured by student achievement."

Phillips said also that the Gates Foundation will focus more sharply on innovations that drive improvements in 9th grade performance. "Students' achievement in 9th grade is remarkably predictive of their later performance," she said. "If they fall behind in this crucial year, it is very hard to catch up."

Balfanz, who has done pioneering research into what he has termed "dropout factories," said that the urban and rural areas where such schools are located face dim prospects.

"There is no way for these cities, towns and neighborhoods to reinvent themselves without high schools that prepare all their students for post-secondary schooling or training," Balfanz said in his testimony.

But he also said that the concentration of these schools -- about 2,000 -- in a limited number of locations around the nation makes the problem solvable. He pointed to cities such as New York and Chicago, and states such as North Carolina, Alabama, Arkansas and Kentucky that are making notable progress and pioneering innovations that are gaining national momentum.

"This tells us that progress occurs when will and know-how are combined with sufficient capacity and accountability systems that encourage effort and innovation."

Back to top

ncnsp logo

INNOVATOR is produced by the North Carolina New Schools Project, an initiative of the Office of the Governor and the Education Cabinet with the support of the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and other businesses and foundations. For story suggestions or to opt out of receiving this e-mail report, please send an e-mail to innovator@newschoolsproject.org or call Todd Silberman at (919) 277-3760.