Coalition credits grass roots partners with victory over economy-killer SB-956
The Coalition to Protect Our Freedom to Drive today praised Gov. Jerry Brown's veto of Senate Bill 956 that threatened to wipe out thousands of independently owner used car dealerships, deny financing to hundreds of thousands of credit-challenged motorists, and cut state and local sales tax revenues by hundreds of millions of dollars a year.
While the Coalition to Protect Our Freedom to Drive aggressively opposed all three bills in a so-called consumer protection package, including Assembly bills 1447 and 1534, which the governor signed into law on the day before his deadline, coalition consultant Larry Grooms said Laguna Beach Democrat Lieu's SB-956 was the greatest threat to both dealers and their customers.
Grooms credited the broadly based coalition's more than 100 active individual citizens, state and local elected officials and chambers of commerce and business associations for winning the fight against SB-956.
Roger Niello, president and CEO of the Sacramento Metro Chamber of Commerce, said, "We're pleased that Gov. Brown vetoed SB 956. This bill would have led to the closure of small businesses in this industry segment, limiting consumer choice. Further, the bill would have done nothing to better educate consumers on the choices available to them. The Sacramento Metro Chamber of Commerce opposed SB 956 on those grounds and we're pleased Gov. Brown vetoed this job-killing bill."
Although the bills were introduced in January, the Coalition to Protect Our Freedom to Drive wasn't formed until late May when all three bills were already passing in their houses of origin after having been promoted in a one-sided crusade by the Los Angeles Times. Coalition research identified and helped to publicize the serious economic and tax revenue losses from the bills that the legislature had overlooked, including state and local sales tax revenue cuts projected to be as much as $337 million a year.
In the end, Lieu's SB 956 was opposed by Brown's Department of Finance. It would have required dealers to register with the Department of Corporations, limited the interest rates they charge to 17% plus the federal funds rate and would have given consumers a 15-day grace period after a missed payment before repossession.
But the coalition pointed to the governor's mildly worded veto message as leaving the door wide open to another attempt by Lieu to attack self-financed used car dealers in 2013.The Coalition to Protect Our Freedom to Drive will continue to monitor the implementation of the two bills signed by Gov. Brown Saturday, with particular attention to unintended consequences that could harm consumers and businesses.
Independent dealers expressed relief at the veto of SB 956, but have concerns about the way new regulatory requirements in AB 1447 and AB 1538 will be imposed.
"At first glance, both these bills look like they will protect consumers. But after careful review they will actually harm the people they are trying to protect as well as the small business owner," said Antelope Valley dealership owner, Gus Camacho.
Camacho credited the Independent Automotive Dealers Association of California, the National Independent Automotive Dealers Association, the Community Auto Finance Association, and the Coalition for their efforts in opposing the legislative package and ultimately persuading Gov. Brown to veto SB 956.
He said that although AB 1447's requirement for a 30-day warranty isn't likely to be an issue for his company, which already offers a three-month warranty to buyers, smaller dealers may be unable to afford or even find state-approved warranty insurance the law requires.
Camacho said AB 1534's mandate that dealers post fair market value of the vehicles they sell offers no real help to consumers, since multiple sources provide constantly changing valuations that don't address the two most important considerations for BHPH cars: history and condition.
Camacho said it is unfortunate that Gov. Brown didn't look into AB 1447 and AB 1534 more critically. He added, "Our industry, like most industries, has bad apples. But the vast majority of dealers are good people, doing the right thing. Our industry is already highly regulated and the bulk of dealers follow the rules. It is unnecessary to create laws and regulations for an industry that does not need them. It would have been better to enforce the rules that already exist."
___________________________________________________________________
Opposed to SB 956, AB 1447 & AB 1534!
CA Department of Finance (Opposed to SB 956)
California Chamber of Commerce (Opposed to AB 1534)
Associations, Business Groups and Taxpayer Advocates
Antelope Valley Board of Trade
Antelope Valley Chambers of Commerce
Antelope Valley Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
Palmdale Chamber of Commerce
Roseville Chamber of Commerce
Sacramento Metro Chamber of Commerce
Simi Valley Chamber of Commerce
Alabama Independent Automobile Dealers Association (AIADA)
Association of California Car Club
California Taxpayer Protection Committee
Community Auto Finance Association (CAFA)
Independent Automobile Dealers Association of California (IADAC)
Integrated Automotive Finance Association (IAFA)
National Alliance of Buy Here, Pay Here Dealers (NABD)
National Independent Automobile Dealers Association (NIADA)
Elected Officials
Hon. George Runner, Member, State Board of Equalization
Peter Foy, Ventura County Supervisor & Chairman of Americans for Prosperity-CA
Steven Hoffbauer, Mayor pro tempore, City of Palmdale
Denis Weber, Mayor pro tempore, City of Agoura Hills
Ron Smith, Vice mayor, City of Lancaster
Tom Lackey, Councilman, City of Palmdale
Mike Dispenza, Councilman, City of Palmdale
Marvin Crist, Councilman, City of Lancaster
Ken Mann, Councilman, City of Lancaster
Richard P. Montgomery, Councilman, City of Manhattan Beach
Elito Santarina, Coucilman, City of Carson
Robert Alvarado, Director, Palmdale Water District
Chad Vegas, Kern High School District Trustee
Newspapers
Antelope Valley Press
Imperial Valley Press
Businesses & Individuals
Alberto's Auto Sales
Auto 500
Auto Credit 1 Inc.
Brasher's Sacramento Auto Auction
Cal West Motors
Camacho Auto Sales
Carson Cars
CC Auto Brokers
Champion Auto
Chat Auto Sales
Chuck Spaugh Auto Sales
Credit Country Auto Sales
DBS Financial
Diablo Motors Auto Sales
Dixon Motors
Dollar Bill Auto Sales
El Real Auto Center
Fowler Motor Sales
GPS Cube Device
Guy Strohmeier's Auto Center
Highway Motors
Horizon Automotive
Houston Auto Sales
Jupiter Pre-Owned Sales
LaBate Auto Sales
Legacy Auto Sales
Liquidation Center
LR Auto Sales
Madera Car Connection
Maple Leaf Motors, Inc.
Mark's Auto LLC
MCMC Auto Ltd.
M G Auto Wholesale, Inc.
Motion in Motion
Mountville Motor Sales
My New Used Car
National Auto Group Inc.
New Start Auto
Petra Auto Sales, Inc.
Pinnacle Auto Lease
Reliable Auto Finance
Team E-Z Auto
Texas Auto Center, LLC
Trey Crouch's Wheels on Credit
Valley Auto Center
Abdullah Barakzai
Alberto S. Luna
Alejandro Gonzalez
Amy Torres
Angela Parra
Angelica Gomez
Anthony Rinaldi
Audrey Kamenetsky
Ben Shirley, Bonita Auto Sales LLC
Bill Heald
Cale Urbrich
Charlene Lash
Chet McPhail
Chris Leedom
Chris Martin
Chris McPhoe
Chris Moring
Chris Smiley
Chuck Spaugh
Danny Carlin
David Aahl
Donald M. Wimbish Jr.
Douglas Albee
Emmett Snellenberger
Eric Baqain
Erika Blankenship
Ernest Estrada
Frank Blair
George Klinke
Greg Meier
Greg Zak
Guy Strohmeier
Holly Libby
Javier Obeso
Jeff Baker
Jerry Khan
Jim Holman
John Crouch
John Kalfayan
Juana Navarro
Kenneth W. Starr
Khalid Latif
Les Perry
Mark Reconnu
Michael Zak
Mike Carson
Mike Casey
Mike Gough
Patrick Graves
Paul Hashemi
Paul Tanner
Phillip Thomasson
Rex Roden
Rey Guluarte
Robert Hernandez
Rod Davis
Ronald Brown
Russell C. Canterbury
Sam Ortega
Terry Degmetich
Thomas LaBate
Todd Smith
William Beyerbach
Windel Whitmore
Zharid Giovanni Cornejo
|