City of Chicago $420 Million Short; Department of Housing Activities, Five-Year Housing Plan Affected
On August 14, the Office of Budget and
Management released the 2009
Preliminary Budget Report. The budget report
affirms the troubling news that many had been
speculating: the economic downturn will
result in a projected $420 million
shortfall
for the 2009 fiscal year. This includes the
estimated $141 million deficit by the end of
this year.
The culprit, to no surprise, is the
significant loss of revenue from real estate
related activities such as the real estate
transaction tax, which was just increased in
April to help fund the CTA. Moreover, the
slowdown in housing and construction activity
has resulted in fewer sales of city land and
collection of building permit fees. The City
projects that revenues tied to real estate
will be over 27 percent below budget
expectations. "Based on year-to-date trends,"
the report states, "the real estate
transaction tax alone is expected to decline
by $ 50.8 million."
Expenditures by
the City
are also expected to rise. The harsh winter
and costs of public safety contributed to the
higher expenses in Streets and Sanitation
and Police and Fire personnel
expenditures in 2007 and anticipated for 2008.
Department faces challenges
The news of a looming budget crisis comes as
the City prepares for the next Five Year
Affordable Housing Plan. The effects of the
economic slump have not only decreased the
resources towards
the creation of affordable housing but also
placed a greater need for affordability
as many Chicagoans cope with their own
financial difficulties.
At Chicago Rehab Network, we continue to
maintain that rental housing is an essential
component of the housing market, serving the
needs of low and moderate income households,
seniors, young families, and those
who are not yet able to afford to buy a home.
We also uphold the merits of place-based
development strategies, which take into
account the housing needs and existing
neighborhood assets in Chicago's many diverse
communities and guided by the local knowledge
of community development corporations and
community groups.
The creation of affordable housing serves as a
true catalyst for Chicago's economic growth
by creating jobs and giving households and
families the ability to spend less of their
income on housing so that more can be spent
on other needs. Now, more than ever, the
City of Chicago needs the kind of leadership
that will herald new policies and creative
measures that prioritize and preserve
affordability.
We are nearing the final stages towards the
renewal of the next Five Year Plan for
Affordable Housing. The renewal of the five
year plan in times past provided a synergy
and strengthening of the city's housing plan.
We look back to the first five year plan
campaign in 1993 which introduced the
quarterly reporting process and continues to
be a model of transparency for other
departments.
We expect the introduction of
the final Plan to the Committee on Housing
and Real Estate and the full City Council in
the Fall. Being fully aware of the austere
conditions in our economy and its impact on
the city revenues, it is imperative that all
residents of Chicago are given adequate and
timely opportunities for public comment to
aid the decision-making of our elected and
appointed leaders.
CRN has a number of documents to help
individuals and
your organizations prepare for the Five Year
Plan renewal. Policy
reports, foreclosure data, and fact
sheets are available by
clicking the links below. We are also
available for any assistance. Contact us at
312-663-3936.
|
|
Housing Rescue Bill Becomes Law |
|
Substantial progress was made by the Federal
government to help curb the foreclosure
crisis that has gripped many communities and
homeowners throughout the country. The
successful passage of the landmark bill, The
Housing and
Economic Recovery Act of 2008, stands as a
remarkable departure from the current
administration's earlier promise to veto the
bill.
Although the highlight of the bill is the
much-anticipated $4 billion in emergency
assistance for redeveloping abandoned and
foreclosed homes, it also establishes key
programs that impact broader housing issues
and policies.
Here is a summary of
important components of the Housing and
Economic Recovery Act below:
Emergency Assistance for Abandoned and
Foreclosed Homes
- $4 billion for the purpose of
redevelopment of abandoned and foreclosed
residential properties.
- All of the funds must serve households
earning 120 percent or below the area median
income. At least 25 percent of each funds
must be used to serve households whose
incomes are 50 percent or below the area
median income.
- Allocation and appropriation of funds
will be based on a
formula determined by HUD and based on the
following criteria: The number and percentage
of homes
foreclosed in each state; The number and
percentage of homes
financed by subprime mortgages by state; The
number and percentage of homes in default or
delinquency in
each state.
The funds will be treated just like
traditional CDBG funds. Every state receives
at least 0.5 percent of the total funds (at
least $19.6 million) within 60 days, which
must be used for the redevelopment of
abandoned and foreclosed homes. These funds
must be used within 18 months by the state.
The specific amount has yet to be
appropriated to Illinois. As of June 2008,
Illinois accounted for 4 % of the national
foreclosures.
Housing Counseling
- Authorizes $260 million for housing
counseling services.
- At least $27 million must be provided to
counseling organizations that target loss
mitigation counseling services to minority
and low income homeowners.
Hope for Homeowners Program
- Provides authority for the Federal Housing
Administration (FHA) to refinance up to $300
billion in mortgages of at-risk borrowers,
still living in their homes who can afford to
make a reduced loan payment. This will
help roughly 400,000 homeowners nationwide
- This program is designed to benefit
borrowers who spent more than 31% of their
monthly incomes on their mortgages as of
March 1 on loans that were written before
January 2.
- The program starts October 1,
2008 and will terminate September
30, 2011.
Increase Assistance for Homeless
- The authorization level for homelessness
will increase by $30 million (McKinney-Vento
homeless assistance programs).
- These funds will be used to provide
emergency assistance for homeless children
and their families, who have become homeless
due to foreclosures, whether they are renters
or homeowners.
- These grants will be made by HUD to state
educational agencies, who then in turn make
sub-grants to local entities.
Low Income Housing Tax Credits
- The bill will temporarily increase, by
10%, the amount of low income housing tax
credits to states for 2008 and 2009. CRN
estimates that additional funding will be as
follows: Illinois: $3,999,225.8 and
Chicago:
$876,334.2
- The bill will also include an additional
$11 billion in tax-exempt mortgage revenue
bond authority for the next two years.
- The bill allows LIHTC's to reduce an
investor tax liability under the alternative
minimum tax, allowing these investors to
benefit from the LIHTC. This is expected to
increase the pool of LIHTC investors, and
hopefully cash going into the development of
LIHTC.
- The bill will protect rental income to a
LIHTC property by not allowing AMI declines
for LIHTC properties.
- The bill increases the maximum initial
Section 8 voucher contract term from 10 years
to 15 years and allows PHA's to pre-commit to
unlimited renewals of these project-based
vouchers.
- The bill also includes provisions that
should help the LIHTC serve lower income
household. The bill will allow states to
boost the value of LIHTC in properties by
30%.
National Housing Trust Fund
- Establishes a National Housing Trust
Fund,
a permanent program with a dedicated source
of funding not subject to the annual
appropriations process.
- At least 90% of the fund must be used for
the production, preservation, rehabilitation,
or operation of rental housing. Up to 10% can
be used for the following homeownership
activities for first time homebuyers:
production, preservation, and rehabilitation;
down payment assistance, closing cost
assistance, and assistance for interest rate
buy-downs.
- At least 75% of the funds for rental
housing must benefit extremely low income
households. And all funds must benefit very
low income households.
- Funds for the Housing Trust Fund will come
from annual contributions made by Fannie Mae
and Freddie Mac. The funds will be based on a
percentage of each company's annual business.
Using this formula, the amount in 2007 would
have been $557 million
- However, 25% of the funds each year must
first go to a reserve fund at the Treasury to
offset scoring problems. The remaining 75% of
the funds will be divided between the Housing
Trust Fund, which gets 65% and a new Magnet
fund which gets 35%.
- For the first three years, a percentage of
the funds (100% in FY09, 50% in FY10, and 25%
in FY11) will be diverted to a reserve fund
to cover losses that the FHA might incur by
refinancing troubled mortgages through the
new HOPE for Homeowners program.
- Based on this formula, if funds didn't have
to be diverted, approximately $300 million
would have been available for the Housing
Trust Fund during Calendar Year 08.
- That said, Fiscal Year 2010, is the first
year the Housing Trust Fund will gain funds.
Photo credits: Carolyn Yu, Medill Reports
http://news.medill.northwestern.edu
|
|
|
|
Treasury Takes Control of Fannie and Freddie |
|
On September 7th, it was announced that the
government has taken over mortgage guarantors
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.
Under the
takeover, the government replaced the
companies' chief executives and shifted
management control to their regulator, the
Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA). The
government has pledged to provide as much as
$200 billion to help both firms ride through
their expected losses.
The news signals a shift in the government's
confidence in the ability of the two leaders
in the secondary mortgage market to handle
the housing downturn fueled by the wave of
foreclosures on its own.
Intervention by the U.S. Treasury could mean
the reduction of mortgage interest and allow
Fannie and Freddie, who have had difficulty
raising capital in the rough economy, to
begin backing more mortgages, at least
temporarily. Furthermore, housing demand
should get a marginal boost, by enticing
potential buyers who have been sitting on the
fence because of high interest rates.
Looming in the future is a fight on Capitol
Hill over the future of Fannie and Freddie.
The Treasury's plan leaves unresolved their
ultimate fate and gives Congress the job of
figuring it out. Many Democrats are pushing
to retain some sort of structure that
provides funding for home mortgages, while
many Republicans wants the firms privatized
and severed from the government.
|
|
|
|
Constitutional Convention Update |
|
CRN has been following the debate on whether
the state of Illinois should hold a
Constitutional Convention. (See latest
article in the Network News Spring/Summer
Issue here)
A convention will allow the ability to review and
take into account the state's activities thus
far and
as CRN has said in the past, addressing
housing affordability through a
constitutional review needs to be on people's
minds.
Since June, interest over the Con Con
referendum has increased in several arenas.
On July 14th, the formation of the Alliance
to Protect the Illinois Constitution, an
anti-Con Con group, was formally announced.
The Alliance draws together diverse interests
from the business community. The Alliance's
websites cites
"significant risks and costs" for their
opposing stance claiming that the Convention
is dangerous both politically and financially.
Reasons against holding a Convention
include costs, the belief that existing
governmental structures are sufficient for
change, and the fear that inviting change at
a politically volatile time could be
detrimental.
The Convention is seen as an opportunity to
change policies in educational funding, term
limits, recall procedures, affordable housing
and more. So far, the pro Convention camp
has had little financial support but a modest
presence in the media. A University of
Illinois poll
in early 2008 found that while most
people have yet to give the Constitutional
Convention much consideration with 43% of
those polled undecided, another 40% would
support the referendum.
United Power for Action and Justice
has been
actively supporting the passage of the Con
Con. A rally has been organized for October
12th. Visit their website
for more information.
|
|
|
|
CDC Census Update |
|
CRN has completed the pilot of the 2008 CDC
Census, which means that this online tool
will soon be available to nearly 100 CDCs in
the Chicago metro area. With the help of
The Resurrection Project who piloted
the Census, CRN is now compiling
organizational data from developments,
pipeline projects, budgeting, staffing,
research, as well as answers to qualitative
questions about organizational strength,
weaknesses, opportunities, and threats into
easily accessible information.
The goal of CDC Census is to create and
disseminate a broad picture of the work of
CDCs at large and provide data to help
increase capacity among and between CDCs. It
will also provide a busy organization with
the opportunity to look back at their record
of accomplishments, as well as a look inward
to assess steps to move their organization to
the future. Further details as to the release
date will be available soon. Please contact
Rachel Johnston at rachel@chicagorehab.org
for more information or with any questions.
|
|
|
|
Things are Moving at Germano-Millgate |
|
Alderman Pope lends his support to the
Tenant Council
Germano-Millgate Apartments, a
350-unit Section 8 development located in
South Chicago, has seen ups and downs in its
30 years of existence. Since its renovation
in the 1980s following tenants' successful
lawsuit against HUD over abysmal living
conditions, Germano-Millgate has been a
valuable source of affordable housing. It is
one of the few remaining federally-subsidized
housing developments in South Chicago.
Although residents face challenges there is
reason to be optimistic. The recent hiring of
a brand new security company has helped
immensely to restore a measure of peace and a
feeling of safety at the development. During
a recent walk-through of Germano-Millgate
with members of the Tenant Council and
Angela Hurlock of Claretian
Associates, Alderman John Pope (7th
Ward)
commented on the good physical condition of
the development, while offering his support
to the Tenant Council as well as helpful
suggestions on how to further improve Germano.
"Germano Millgate represents the largest
concentration of affordable family units in
our neighborhood," says Hurlock. "Its
physical and/or social destruction would mean
devastation to the hundreds of families that
call this neighborhood home."
CRN and Claretian Associates have partnered
with the Germano-Millgate Tenant
Council to
help build the organization's capacity and
bring together South Chicago leaders who hold
a stake in the long-term preservation of
Germano's 350 affordable units. Community
allies will be invited to attend the upcoming
Germano-Millgate Resident Forum, a major
event organized by the Tenant Council which
will focus on examining tenant rights,
responsibilities, and challenges. Speakers
will include representatives of local service
organizations, tenant leaders, Tio Hardiman
of Ceasefire and Alderman Pope.
**Coming up in October: Germano-Millgate
Resident Forum**
|
|
|
|
Preservation: Funding of HAP Contracts |
|
CRN has been working with the Preservation
Working Group nationally to ensure that
timely HAP payments are maintained. For more
information, click here.
|
|
|
|
Meeting Held to Explore Challenges Faced by Housing Cooperatives |
|
On Saturday, August 23rd, a meeting among
cooperative board members was hosted by the
Preservation
Compact, including the Rental
Alliance Initiative--represented by the
Chicago
Rehab Network and the Sargent
Shriver National Center on Poverty
Law. The meeting
was a learning experience for all involved.
The board members shared their stories and
view points on the challenges faced by
cooperatives. Other meeting participants
added legal expertise, practical knowledge,
and a historical understanding of cooperatives.
Cooperatives are an important housing
strategy that can be beneficial in providing
stability and affordability to their
residents. Within a co-op, residents
purchase a share and then pay a monthly fee
to cover mortgage, repairs and other costs
that the co-op may incur. Purchasing the
share gives the resident a right to live in
the property but also the ability to
participate in the governance of the property
making cooperatives a democratic housing
option.
Cooperatives can be tied to affordability
restrictions, making them a viable
avenue for providing affordable housing.
One of the goals of the Preservation Compact
is to maintain the affordable housing stock
in Chicago and cooperatives with
affordability restrictions are an important
part of this stock. Different affordability
options for cooperatives were discussed at
length during the meeting, specifically the
particularities of Section 8 subsidies in
regard to cooperatives. This proved to be
an important lesson as several co-opers
shared stories of how cooperatives have faced
financial hardship during a transition from
project based Section 8 subsidies to voucher
based. The Preservation Compact's
Interagency
Coordinating Council can be
helpful for mediating interaction between
government agencies to make such processes
easier for cooperatives.
The meeting also served to explore areas
where further education may benefit
cooperatives. Participants indicated that
board members and co-op residents could use
further education to help understand the
fundamental differences between cooperatives
and other forms of housing and to help clear
up questions about share prices, monthly
charges and other issues. But participants
indicated that government agencies and policy
makers need similar education to help
understand the uniqueness of their housing
option and their needs. Such education could
aid both the day-to-day functioning of
cooperatives and also allow interaction with
housing agencies to run more smoothly.
|
|
|
|
CRN Analysis of DOH 2nd Quarter Report Available |
|
CRN presented its analysis of the
Department of Housing's 2nd Quarter Progress
Report on Tuesday, September 16th at 10 am at
the Committee on Housing and Real Estate
meeting in City Council Chambers.
Download the report here.
|
|
|
|
Help For Renters Affected By Foreclosure On The Way |
|
More than 35 percent of foreclosures in 2007
were on multifamily properties putting
thousands of renters at risk of displacement.
One August 14th, the city announced an
emergency assistance program for tenants of
foreclosed apartments which includes rent
payment assistance for up to three months and
moving expenses in the case eviction as a
result of foreclosure.
Many renters have been innocent bystanders in
the wake of the increasing numbers of
foreclosures in Chicago. The expanded
emergency assistance will keep renters housed
during a difficult transition. In addition,
the new program will expand free legal
services for tenants facing eviction from
foreclosure to be provided by the Lawyer's
Committee for Better Housing. For more
information read the press
release. Renters facing eviction because
of foreclosure or anyone having difficulty
paying their mortgage are urged to call 311
for assistance.
|
|
|
|
A Picture of Chicago Foreclosures |
|
The June report is available on
our website. Download the report here.
|
|
|
|
Bickerdike Breaks Ground on Rosa Parks Project: Building Green and Affordable Housing in Humboldt Park |
|
On September 4th, community members,
financing partners, Alderman Walter
Burnett
Jr., and representatives of Chicago
Department of Housing and the Illinois
Housing Development Authority turned out to
celebrate the ground breaking of Bickerdike's
new Rosa Parks Apartments. The ground
breaking celebrated the culmination of
several years of planning and marked the
start of construction of 94 new and
affordable housing units. Bickerdike's
success in this project is especially
impressive considering the record number of
sources of funding for the project, the added
complexities of green development, and
challenges added by the downturn in the
housing market.
Bickerdike,
a multimillion dollar nonprofit
corporation, has developed 1063 rental, for
sale, and cooperative units since 1967.
Bickerdike also manages 918 units, which are
located on multiple sites throughout the
Chicago communities of West Town, Humboldt
Park, Logan Square and Hermosa.
Located in Humboldt Park, the eight buildings
of Rosa Parks are planned on land that has
long been vacant, marking some of the first
new construction seen in the area in years.
The new one, two, three and four bedroom
apartments provide housing for low and very
low income families or households at 50% or
below of the Area Median Income with multiple
subsidy programs utilized to make the units
more affordable. Total development costs
are $27,147,184 and the project is slated to
be completed in spring 2010.
One of the challenges to funding the Rosa
Parks Apartments has been the changes in the
tax credit equity market. The initial
funding package had credits pinned at $0.93
on the dollar and the recent crash of the
equity market left a development funding gap
of $1,350,000. Ultimately, after extensive
negotiations and multilevel solutions between
Bickerdike and the City, IHDA and the
syndicator, the project successfully closed
on August 28, 2008. The implications of the
equity market changes for other CDCs are
unclear however - the low income housing tax
credit resources are being stretched more
than anticipated.
Rosa Parks is an exemplary model of positive
place-based development for several reasons.
Over 50% of the project is targeted at large
families with
three and four bedrooms helping to meet the
needs of existing residents of Humboldt Park.
The scattered site and infill approach of
the development spreads benefits throughout
the community. Additionally, the "green"
focus will create long term sustainability of
the asset itself.
The buildings of Rosa Parks will be examples
of affordable green development, which has
added complexity to the planning process but
will have long-term benefits. When referring
to housing, "green" can mean a variety of
things. One way of making buildings more
green is by ensuring they are well
constructed and highly energy efficient. The
Rosa Parks project goes beyond this baseline
by also offering a green roof, geothermal
heating, solar heated water, in one building
with numerous green elements incorporated
throughout the development, including native
landscaping. Bickerdike will seek LEED
(Leadership in Energy and Environment Design)
Silver certification from the United States
Green Building Council for this building.
The Rosa Parks project is an opportunity to
increase green affordable housing in Chicago
and also a learning experience for Bickerdike
as it applies a comprehensive green
philosophy to the planning, construction,
management and maintenance of the buildings.
Joy Aruguete, executive director of
Bickerdike, sees the Rosa Parks as a step
towards positive change in the area in more
than just housing stating "With Rosa Parks,
Bickerdike will provide homes for nearly 300
residents. At the same time this project
brings investment to an under-invested
community and our subsidiary, Humboldt
Construction Company will create jobs for
people living in the neighborhood." Alderman
Walter Burnett Jr. of the 27th Ward where
Rosa Parks is located also speaks
passionately of the project for providing
"safe, decent and affordable places to
live...the Rosa Parks Apartments will allow
families to stay in the area and benefit from
community improvement".
|
|
|
|
Vacant Building Ordinance Passes |
|
In July, the Chicago City Council passed the
Vacant
Building Ordinance that would strengthen
penalties for owners of vacant properties
that are not maintained up to code or
properly secured.
The passage of the ordinance was preceded by
much debate over the increased fees imposed
on owners and concerns about making reuse and
rehab more difficult as result of the higher
maintenance cost. With higher number of
foreclosures high, there is also a greater
likelihood of vacancies.
CRN, along with other concerned groups, were
able to reach more agreeable fees which can
still compel owners to keep up their
properties, but also reduce the financial
burden that could make reuse and rehab
infeasible.
|
|
|
|
Network NewsMakers |
|
Dan Burke is the new Director of the
Chicago office of Preservation of
Affordable Housing, a
national, non-profit housing developer.
Mr. Burke was most recently Vice President of
the Chicago Community Development Corporation
and served in that capacity since
1988.
Sharon Legenza is the new
Executive Director of Housing Action
Illinois. Ms. Legenza previously
served as
Interim Director of ACLU of Alaska and was
Fair Housing Project Director and attorney at
the Chicago Lawyers Committee for Civil
Rights Under Law for nearly a decade.
|
|
|
|
Upcoming Events |
|
On September 20th, the fifth annual Rents
Right Rental Housing Expo will take
place at Malcolm X College located at 1900 W
Van Buren from 9am to 3pm. The Expo is
hosted by the Chicago Department of Housing
and will feature dozens of vendors as well as
workshops focusing on rental housing.
Admission is free. More information is
available at www.cityofchicago.org/housing.
The Renaissance Collaborative is
hosting its Fall Gala on Sept. 25th at 6:00 pm at
1043 West 43rd Street. The event will feature
live music, dinner, dancing, and live and
silent auctions. Click here
for more details.
Lawyers Committee for Better Housing
will hold its Anniversary Reception and
Awards on Thursday, September 25th from 5:00
pm to 7:00 pm at Wildman, Harrold, Allen, and
Dixon LLP, 225 W. Wacker, 30th Floor. Contact
Harriet McCullough at 312-347-7600 x512 or
email emiller@lcbh.org for more information.
Bank of of America will celebrate Chicago
neighborhood leadership on November 19, 2008
at 5:00 pm at its 2008 Neighborhood
Excellence Initiative Awards at the Chicago
Cultural Center. Please contact Alva Winfrey
at 312-904-0877 or email
alva.winfrey@bankofamerica.com,
|
|
|
|
Get Out and Vote! |
|
In the 2004 Presidential Election only 5.6
million of the 12.7 million Illinois
residents voted. That is less than half! Make
a difference this year and get out and vote.
The last day to register is October
7th.
Vote!
Click here
for information on Voter Registration
for Illinois
|
|
|
|
Help Build The Network! |
|
The Chicago Rehab Network is the oldest and
largest coalition of non-profit community
developers and practitioners in the Midwest.
CRN works to provide a
foundation for new
strategies for effective policy,
communications, training and technical
assistance to support the development and
preservation of affordable housing across
Chicago.
You can support our work by spreading
the word about CRN or by making a donation.
Click Here to Support CRN
|
|
|
|