August 2008
Embryo Donation and Adoption Awareness Campaign
Dear Fertility Professional;
Welcome to the third edition of the Embryo Adoption Awareness Center newsletter! We hope you will become a regular reader. If you have missed previous editions, you can view them at www.EmbryoAdoption.org. The content of these newsletters is designed to assist Fertility Clinics in their efforts to manage/create/refer embryo donation programs and to improve patient understanding of potential dispositions for their frozen embryos. The number of embryos in frozen storage continues to rise. Clinics have to manage the increase in storage space and associated costs, patients have to determine what to do with remaining embryos.
|
|
| Fertility & Sterility
Reports Embryo Adoption Success Rates
Good news for couples adopting frozen embryos! A recent study published in the journal Fertility and Sterility found that the pregnancy success rate for women adopting embryos is equal to or greater than the success rate for women using their own embryos in IVF treatments. Women who use their own embryos will have a 32% chance of delivering to term, whereas women using adopted frozen embryos will have a 35% chance of delivering to term. Doctors supporting the option of embryo donation and adoption will now have some solid information to share with couples considering this option. Researcher, Dr. Reg Finger, said, "We wanted to know the pregnancy rates because that would be a very important thing to be able to tell a couple, especially since we're trying to promote this as a life-affirming option. The message that it sends us is that if a couple wants to adopt an embryo they have got a good chance of having a baby." The report is also good news for couples who worry about giving their embryos up for adoption, because it shows that their embryos can have a good chance at life with another family. Dr. Jeffrey Keenan of the National Embryo Donation Center observed, "We have had embryos that have been frozen for 14 years that have resulted in normal pregnancies and children, so really we don't have a time limit on how long these embryos can be frozen."
|
Louise Brown Turns Thirty
A momentus event for all fertility clinics occurred when Louise Brown, the first IVF baby was born in Great Britain 30 years ago this month.
Since then more than 3 million children have been born as a result of IVF treatments, some of them now born because of the relatively new practice of embryo donation and adoption.
|
2009 Embryo Law Essay Competition
Read this year's question and give us your feedback!
Last year was the first year a law student essay competition was offered. The students now studying in the nation's law schools will be the future attorneys discussing and developing laws in the area of reproductive technology, including the creation and storage of human embryos. We present this competition to stimulate thought and conversation among those future law practioners. After you read the question, will you please complete the brief, five question survey? Links to the survey are at the top and bottom of this article. Here is the question for the 2009 competition:
You have been consulted by Dr. Margo Rhinehart, the embryologist at the local fertility clinic. She informs you that her clinic needs advice in understanding what the law requires of them when transferring abandoned embryos at their clinic to other patients. The embryos in question belonged to six different patients, none of whom have paid the clinic's embryo storage fee nor had any other contact with the clinic for more than seven years. Four of the patients involved signed a document prior to creating the embryos, whereby they indicated that they planned to retain the embryos for future family building efforts. They further agreed that all of their rights to the embryos would cease if they did not give the clinic further instructions within five years of the date the embryos were created. All of these patients used their own gametes for creation of the embryos. One of the patients, a single woman, used donated sperm and her own eggs to create her embryos. She did not sign any documents indicating her preference for disposition of unused embryos and promised the clinic that she would contact them later with her decision. In searching for the patients, it was discovered that the remaining patient, also a single woman, died more than five years ago and the right to decide on the disposition of her unused embryos was given to her executor in her will. The executor has refused to pay the storage bills and refuses to make any decision on the disposition of the embryos. The clinic has patients who would accept the donation of any of the "abandoned" embryos and the clinic would like to proceed with transferring them to these potential recipients. Advise the clinic as to the following: 1. What legal risks, if any, would the clinic be subject to if the original patients, or their heirs or assigns, would request possession of the embryos after a transfer of the embryos had been made to another patient? 2. What potential actions, if any, should be filed in court to assist the clinic in fulfilling its goal of transferring the embryos to other patients? Distinguish whether different actions would be recommended based on the distinctions among missing patients. 3. Assuming legal action was appropriate: A. Discuss the strengths and weaknesses of the Clinic's position using the following legal principles, as applicable, for analysis: Contract, Property, Probate and Parentage. B. What authority should be cited in support of the clinic's request and what authority should be given to the court that would represent opposition to the clinic's request? Assume that all of the missing patients had at least one live birth from the original embryos they created.
| |
|
|
|
| IN THIS ISSUE
Fertility and Sterility Reports Embryo Adoption Success Rates
World's First IVF Baby is Thirty Years Old!
2009 Embryo Law Essay Competition Question:
Give us your feedback
Short Videos to Help Families with Embryos in Frozen Storage
|
------------------------------- Fertility clinics throughout the United States have brought joy and fulfillment to numerous families because of the diligence of medical professionals to increase the success rate of Assisted Reproductive Technologies.
Most families are counseled at the outset of their IVF treatment about the potential for remaining embryos and the choices available for the disposition of those embryos. However, the focus of couples at that point in time is 'having a baby', not 'what will we do with our remaining embryos'. As a result, the number of embryos in storage continues to increase.
Our goal is to help these families think through the options available to them. We hope to accomplish by:
1. Helping clinics inform and educate their patients.
2. Providing clinics with practical help and understanding of the latest FDA Rules and Regulations from professionals who clearly understand them.
3. Supplying the latest fertility clinic survey data completed on behalf of the Awareness Campaign by California State University - Fullerton.
4. Maintaining an Internet web site giving potential donor families comprehensive answers to their questions and access to medical, legal and adoption resources.
|
| Is your clinic on
THE LIST?
Clinics listed now on
Couples exploring embryo donation and adotion frequently visit this website. A service provider list is included on the website in the Finding Help section to assist couples in finding local fertility clinics and donation programs.
Email us at
| |