Media Newsletter
GujaratGlobal
Issue 31
October 17, 2008
Greetings!

This Newsletter from the GujaratGlobal  brings to you the latest happening in the media particularly in Gujarat, whats hot and whats not , who's in and who's out , you want it and you get it here !This newsletter is about people who craft voice and image of others. It is about the real newsmakers.
 
 

                Editor.....Press Club elections 


Elections of the office bearers of the Press Club of India will be held on Saturday, October 18. Election campaign this year has brought out certain issues that should be debated in the media. One of the issues is about the activities of the Club. There are clubs in other cities also.

It is generally remarked that the Press Club of India has become a Sharaabkhaana. With Associate Members from the corporate houses too eager to foot bills of journalists, there are many who go for free drinks or bargains. It is very unfortunate that PCI, set up in 1957, today has 5,000 plus members of whom only 2500 are voting members.

There is a general impression that now no new voting members are taken while membership in Associate Category is open. In the last one year only 36 journalists were given membership of the Club. Old members fondly recall programmes like Meet the Press which have almost disappeared. There is hardly anything intellectually stimulating for journalists by way of activities other than cheaper daru.

No doubt, the Club had guests. But the agenda of such functions is to get financial support from the guest. Certainly, it has some untold but well understood riders attached to it.  More associate members and guests with an eye on their M potential have badly affected creativity and professional utility of the Club.

In such a situation, agenda of some candidates certainly make sense that there should be activities that add to the professional growth of the members. Revolt against present Secretary General Pushpendra Kulshreshta earlier this year has made the issue of transparency quite central this time.

Pushpendra is seeking election for the post of secretary general for the third time. There should be some kind of bar on remaining office bearer to bring new blood in the management. This is more important considering the great influx of new generation in the recent years.

Besides PCI elections, it has regular stuff. 
 

Have A Happy Reading.


With love  

Yogesh Sharma

Gujarat Global

Join Our Mailing List
Archive...

Did u miss out on any of the action which has taken place or want to sneak a peek again?? Here is our Archive.
Now you can find all our earlier issues here.


Archive Gallery..

Media Masala

Z plus challenge of Modi
Covering a VIP with Z plus security like Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi is a challenge in itself. One has to be in the media enclosure well before the beginning of the function. What happens if you fail to turn up well in time?
This week, Health Department had organised a high level consultation in the Hotel Pride. Chief Minister Modi inaugurated it. However, those who reached after Modi's arrival, it was a tough time to get entry. Police and others posted outside the gate won't allow you to get in..
Even when a journalist showed his accreditation card, young sub-inspector flooded him all kind of queries like what is your name. This is despite the fact that the card is a photo identity card. You just cannot anyone outside. During the presence of Modi, jammer are installed at the venue and one cannot contact use his mobile. It was only after the journalist threatened to create a scene, the young PSI obliged him entry.
Another reporter had a kind of hurdle race to reach the venue. He reached Hotel Grand Bhagwati by mistake. He saw huge security arrangement which further convinced that this was the right venue. It took about half an hour to get into the hall of the hotel only to learn that the consultation venue was Hotel Pride.
It so happened that there was reception of a ward of BJP leader Vijay Rupani at Hotel Grand Bhagwati and the CM had to come there. However, this had made entry into the Hotel a kind of hurdle event. Modi had to come to the Hotel after the Health Department function. At both these hotels even people staying in the hotel were not spared by police.
The journalist had to pass through another series of hurdles when he reached the venue, the Pride Hotel. By the time, he reached there inaugural session was over!

Nano exclusive

Nano is still roaming on the pages of newspapers of Ahmedabad, even as the actual car will take time to hit the road. A senior journalist of a Delhi based newspaper got hold of Chief Minister Narendra Modi at a function and asked him about the price of the land given to Tata for the relocation of the Nano plant.
Modi patiently heard the correspondent and told him that the rate was yet being worked out. However, journalist asked what about delay. Modi said that the government would charge eight percent compound interest. Modi found another journalist taking interest in the conversation.
He told the outstation correspondent that he should hurry up with the story lest the other journalist flash it electronically.  Soon, it struck to our outstation correspondent that eight percent interest on delayed payment is a common practice. But Modi had left the venue by that time and our friend was wondering what to do with Nano exclusive since Modi did not tell the principal amount while talking about the interest.

Commodity World restructured
 
Commodity World, the local Gujarati Financial daily is desperately trying to survive the pressure of bubble burst which has led to the closure of the Gujarati edition of Business Standard and shelving of the Gujarati edition of Dainik Jagaran before its launch.
It has moved to a smaller place and outsourced its content requirement. The publication which originally started from Rajkot in Saurashtra has hardly any news gathering staff of its own. Gradually, some staff has left the publication on its own sensing the gloomy days ahead and some have been said GOOD BYE by the management.
This Thursday, one of the last few surviving staff Dipak Mehta joined Sambhav Metro.

Haresh Jhala joins Voice of India
 
After a long wait, Haresh Jhala who was last seen with E TV has found job. He has joined Voice of India as Principal Correspondent. Haresh has worked with several publications.

Tikendra back HOME
 
Tikendra who had joined Sambhav Metro last month is back with Jaihind daily this month. He says that he did not find himself at ease in the new environment. Metro is a noon paper.
Tikendra is back with his old beats, Education and BJP.


 
An appeal

 
Friends as I told earlier, the newsletter has a subscriber base of 2100 plus. There are many more who are reading it either directly from the website or through forwards. I request you all friends to mobilize more subscriptions to the newsletter by enrolling your friends in media. This is your platform. Help it grow.
 
 
 Women candidates vocal in Press Club Elections
-Yogesh Sharma
 
This weekend will decide the fate of the controversial general secretary of the Press Club of India Pushpendra Kulshreshta as the annual general election of the Press Club India will be held on Saturday October 18. Pushpendra is seeking election for the third term.
 
His style of functioning led to revolt by several members and office bearers including the President of the Club. Many of them had resigned. Transparency is a key word in the election this year which is dominated by the fierce door to door campaign. Participation of women in Press Club elections is not new, but this year campaign of some women candidates is very remarkable.

Vice President of the Club, Karuna Madan, is a serious contender for the post of the Secretary General. In The constitution of the PCI, post of the SG is the most important. Other woman candidate for the post of the SG is Seema Kiran, feature editor of Daily Veer Arjun. She is a former vice President of the Club. The fourth contender for the post is Javed Faridi.

There four candidates are for the post of the President and ten for two posts of Vice President and two for the post of Treasurer. Neelam Mahajan Singh is regarded a very formidable candidate for the post of President. For the post of vice presidents there are Savita Shrivastav and Aruna Singh and Lucy Chattopadhyay for the post of Treasurer.

Like previous election, Pushpendra is facing allegation of Pakistan connection. He represents Aaj TV of Pakistan, a private popular channel. Going by the dirty politics game, there are many stories doing round about Pushpendra. People of a country which his channel represents are bound to interact with him more, one of his friends Arvind Kumar Singh, Resident Editor of Hari Bhoomi says. Earlier Pushpendra was with BBC, Sahara and some other Indian companies, he points out.

Singh says that it is good that candidates were focusing more on door to door campaign as this would give them fair idea of the views of members and the reasons for lack of interest in the activities of the Press Club. About the charges of Karuna Madan of gender bias in the club, Singh says it is serious since it has been made by an office bearer.

He points out that the feeling of the neglect of women members had led to the formation of Indian Women Press Core more than a decade ago. He feels that there should be more activities to promote professional development of journalists, there should be representation of government media. Despite this, he says, in the last two years the active participation of members has increased.

However, Anil Tyagi, editor of Gfiles, India's first magazine on bureaucracy and governance , a senior member of the Club has very serious reservations about the Club. He says that in the absence of professional management, the Club has become a loss making institution and does not have any substantial activity besides food and drink serving.

He points out that the Club with a turnover of three crore has loss of Rs 55 lakh. Its staff of 120 is the real boss and not the committee. How journalists who cannot manage their salaries can manage a club with such a turn over, he asks.
Candidates are using e mails for the campaign. But SG candidate Karuna Madan got her views on Bhadas 4 media, a website devoted to media, particularly Hindi media. In this she talks about gender bias in the Press Club and assures that she would have ladies even behind the Bar of the Press Club.

On her blog Unfulfilled  Karuna Madan says I request all my journalist friends to campaign for me as much as they can because those contesting for the post of Secretary General have either a godfather to back them or the godfathers themselves are contesting. I have none. And I am none. I may not know you so well but I want people like YOU to support me with all your might and genuine blessings so that I can prove this godfather theory wrong. Please campaign for me most honestly and aggressively and make me win so that we all can fight the destructive and tyrannical forces active for long in the Club. When I win, I promise to take you along and we all will work as a team for the betterment of the Club and our journalist community.

She points out that her views can be read on Bhadas and India News Magazine. She says that she was not allowed to do any constructive work while working as vice president. I had to fight for many issues but I did not resign as they would have given more freedom to Pushpendra, she says. My fight against the autocractic and destructive forces of the club would continue, she says.
 
Another candidate Seema Kiran has this five point agenda as SG
Bringing Club back on rails and making it as a one of the best clubs in the country for bonafide journalist.

Introducing schemes like Insurance and Journalist's welfare funds (already existing in Some Press Clubs of the country)
Encouraging family culture.
Encouraging, intellectual and professional activities; seminars; symposiums and workshops relating to journalist and journalism.
 Facilitating opportunities for great interaction among bonafide journalist members of the PCI and other club of the country.
Presidential candidate Neelam Mahajan Singh also talks about transparency She sends her appeal mail with a letter from a very senior member M L Kotru.

Yashwant Singh Editor of Bhadas4media strongly feels that there should some limit for office bearer to remain in office so that new faces play active role. The Club should be more than club and take up activities for the growth and development of journalists, he elaborates his views.
 Scattered voices of Ayesha Khan
 

Ayesha Khan, Assistant Editor of the Indian Express has come out with  an anthology of poems that reflect the agony of post Godhra Gujarat. It is a translation of poems that have appeared in Gujarati, Urdu and other languages. She is brought up in Gujarat .
While Ayesha has named English anthology Scattered Voices, the Hindi version has its title, Kuch to kah yaaro. Ayesha, a student of Physics has tried to understand the Chemistry of the Muslim society under vector addition of different forces Gujarat faced after 2002 incident at Godhra. She explains what went into the making of the anthology, her first literary work.
 
Call it a book or a self imposed labour - it is an attempt to document unusual voices responding in unusual times to unusual acts and unusual silences.
 
It's now six years after Godhra-Gujarat 2002.  The bloodied summer of year 2002 remains a watershed not only in Gujarat's history but also in free India's contemporary history. Amongst its many firsts in inhumane brutalities, it remains  this country's largest ever state-sponsored and planned genocides post-independence,   Indians against Indians.
 
The deafening silences after, except for some largely ineffectual criticism by the national media, have been searching for voices that belonged to that very state, articulated in the same cultural milieu and language.

It was the inadequate literary response by Gujaratis themselves, more so the Gujarati Muslims, that was more disturbing.  

And therefore began the exercise of compiling this book. There was just one criterion for the selection of the poems it contains - that they be written by Muslims in Gujarat in the last six years, on any issue related to the Godhra carnage and thereafter. Language was no bar: Gujarati, Urdu or Hindi/Hindustani or any language.

It was a deliberate choice: to document the literary response of the victimized community: to explore their responses to the situation-the varied moods: and most importantly to create a platform where they could emote their responses fearlessly. A fact revealed during the collection of poetry as many remained hesitant to read out, while some perplexed as to why would anyone be interested in hearing what they had to say; and more importantly, quiet often complete ignorance of their responses amongst the non-Muslim Gujaratis.  

In addition to poetry compilation, the effort was also to introduce the poets- more so those who have emoted from within the comforts of their ghettoized neighbourhoods in cities and villages across the state. Among them a butcher's experiment in ghazal meter or a school teacher's in tribal area in Gujarati _ mostly decidedly earthy free verse that is at once exciting as it is promising. The response in a literary milieu instead of street harangue and violence is also a reason for hope, for it is not mere expression, but also craving for a legitimate space for legitimate expression in a legitimate way.
 
There have been many a poet whose work has been included who agonized and argued that the compilation should not remain only of Gujarati Muslim voices. It was a difficult admission but nevertheless an admission that creativity too now comes with an imposed realization of being a Muslim.  There were some who sought assurance that in the end humane values triumph.
 
The expected emotions were of fear and anger, of frustration and even of violation. But the literary responses from the most amateur voices retain a semblance of hope, with the predominant feeling of being betrayed by the consensual silence and their patriotism questioned again and again. Even as the Muslim community refers to those killed in the riots as shaheed (martyrs), it takes a quiet assurance that it has not resorted to frustration in suicides and retaliatory violence as expected from the community

Both versions will be released on Saturday evening (6 pm) at a function at Gujarat Sahitya Parishad in Ahmedabad
 
"Listen or thy tongue will keep thee deaf.'"


With Love,
 
Yogesh Sharma
GujaratGlobal.com