|
Issue 30
|
October 12, 2008
| |
Greetings!
This Newsletter from the GujaratGlobal brings to you the latest happening in the media particularly in Gujarat, whats hot and whats not , who's in and who's out , you want it and you get it here !This newsletter is about people who craft voice and image of others. It is about the real newsmakers.
|
Editor........ Good P and Bad P
Gujarat newspapers are talking about good M (Narendra Modi) and bad M ( Mamta Banerjee). This fits into Modi's style of rhymes. Here this week, the newsletter is based on good P and bad P. Here P is for PR. Though the word PR is becoming outdated , corporate communication is yet to fully replace it. This week there were two major events in Gujarat. One was the 50 years of discovery of oil in the post independence period another was the relocation of Tata's Nano. Media reports of the two events represent two extremes. If discovery of oil went quite unnoticed, media hype of Nano orchestrated by Chief Minister Narendra Modi is becoming repulsive. In the case of oil discovery event, it is sheer contempt of the Navratna ONGCL for the professional approach to the PR work. Its top brass does not considers its PR mechanism (it has a fancy word of corporate communication) more than clerk and runs the unit on its fads and fancies. The event was one of the best cases to showcase bad PR approach of a department. And when it comes to an organization like ONGCL, fortune 500 company, it badly exposes the dark side of an Indian MNC. Despite a heavy dose of the "overdo" of the Nano event, one has to accept the PR skills of Modi. Daily, newspapers are out with exclusives of different aspects of the Nano, but the exact details of the deal have yet to be come out! Even before the arrival of the Nano plant here, newspapers are full of stories of Nano effect. This issue has stories about the good P and bad P besides regular stuff.
Have A Happy Reading.
With love
Yogesh Sharma
Gujarat Global | |
Archive...
Did u miss out on any of the action which has taken place or want to sneak a peek again?? Here is our Archive. Now you can find all our earlier issues here.
Archive Gallery..
|
Media Masala
Nanofied Modi
In the recent days Chief Minister Narendra Modi has become quite media friendly. He has given interviews to seven TV channels and some Gujarat newspapers carried his interviews about Nano coming to Gujarat. It all started with his interview to Prabhu Chawla. It brings out apparent change in Modi's media strategy. It began with Gujarat police claiming success in arresting the mastermind of July 26 serial blasts in Ahmedabad and later blasts in Delhi. And, he has appeared in almost all prominent channels since then. First phase focused on Modi as a leader with will and skill to fight terrorism while the second , the Nano phase , is aimed at presenting Modi as the Chief Minister who knows his business of governance better than many other CM. At the joint media interaction along with Ratan Tata, the most striking thing was the ease with which Modi allowed media to ask questions. No snubbing, no cutting short of questions. People within his own party and so called political pundits are abuzz with the talk of Modi's Nano with destination Delhi. Mad media Nano race
For the last one week or so Gujarat media is reverberating with Nano sound. Newspapers are writing similar stories with exclusive tag. The day after the Nano announcement by Chief Minister Narendra Modi and Ratan Tata, Sandesh and Divya Bhaskar both came out with the claim that they were first to come out with the Nano arrival story. Just on the left corner of the masthead, Divya Bhaskar announced that it had first published the Nano story on August 31. Certainly a Nano piece about Nano Sandesh had a big page two item that their news of Nano of September 23 proved true. It reproduced the news item. Obviously, Divya Bhaskar with its headline "Nano nee savaari, mukam gujarat nee taiyari" was more definite and early than Sandesh which had expressed possibility of the Nano coming to Gujarat. What is more, Divya Bhaskar's reporter turned Resident Editor Ajay Umath showed the copy of Divya Bhaskar to Ratan Tata soon after the joint press conference of Tata and Chief Minister Narendra Modi, took Tata's autograph on the newspaper of that day just under the first page news item of August 31. Ajay told Tata that he was confident that Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi will successfully bring Nano to Gujarat.
Nano inspired creativity
Nano has inspired great creativity among our journalist friends. Creativity cannot be defined by any logic nor can it be measured by any yardstick. Friends here are some examples, just read them with open mind and heart. The day Nano deal was announced, a Gujarati newspaper had a shouting headline-Gujarat me aatishbaji (fireworks display in Gujarat) An English paper says Nano sparks off early Diwali. All these expression are to explain that there was an organised firework display by Gujarat Chamber of Commerce and Industry and one or two others!!! Tata wins a battle they lost 23 years ago is another innovative headline with an article which explains to the YUM readers what is Licence Raj. Now one wonders where was the battle. Orphan Nano finds home in Ahmedabad, is also a way of describing the relocation of Nano plant in Ahmedabad. Modi drives Aapno( all of sudden Ratan Tata has become ours) Ratan home, Tata Nano: A new Ratan in Gujarat's crown, Modi's Gujarat bags Nano project, Modi ko Tata kaa tohfa, After Nano, pujas bring in Bengal touch, After Nano-high tech taxi says hello to Ahmedabad, Modi's top secret order made officers accomplish mission Nano. If a student of journalism wants to have doctoral thesis on something like Nano and media, nano inspired media, nano inspired creativity, he can have a good readable and entertaining material from newspapers of just seven to ten days! | |
|
|
Friends as I told earlier, the newsletter has a subscriber base of 2100 plus. There are many more who are reading it either directly from the website or through forwards. I request you all friends to mobilize more subscriptions to the newsletter by enrolling your friends in media. This is your platform. Help it grow.
|
(This is a good example of bad PR. Senior officers of the ONGC were so Boss centric that media was an unwanted entity. This is despite that ONGC had organised the event with advertisements of millions of rupees and it had invited media for the event.. Officers of the Corporate Communication had no say and those who ran the show had no idea of the CC or the importance of the event. It had three ministers, Union Petroleum Minister Murli Deora, MOS Petroleum Dinsha Patel and Textile Minister Shankarsinh Vaghela.) On Sunday ONGC organised a function to mark 50 years of discovery of oil in Gujarat. This was the first discovery of oil in the post Independence period in the country. A museum was also to be opened at the well site Lunej, 81 kilometers from Ahmedabad. By any count it was a major event. The ONGC planned a media visit to Lunej at sharp 7.30. A ramshackle State Transport bus, 3x2, was arranged for the media by the fortune 500 company known for high level of comfort and convenience for its staff and officers. Bus started around 8 am. It was not before some journalists had a public show of their bad mood over the bus and the delay. Soft spoken, low profile Corporate Communication Manager, Kashyap Joshipura was the target of all queries as DGM CC Pallab Bhattacharya, who was also there, was a stranger to the media. It was told that the bus was late because of delay in the arrival of refreshments. Hospitality department (Guest House) of the ONGC was looking after refreshment. The bus started without the stock of refreshments. ONGC had two categories of journalists! For category one they had Innova cars and for others the bus. You can call it split branding innovation of the ONGC! No one knew the way to the site! The driver of the ST bus had the idea of Khambat, but not Lunej. None of the PR staff knew the exact route. All followed the bus and the navigational aid was mobile phone. Even the elite group was at the mercy of the ST bus driver. At Lunej, ONGC had a special tent for the function with a helipad for the ministers and its officers to come from Vadodara and Ahmedabad. At the pandal, a police sub inspector stopped journalists and wanted to see card. He himself was not aware of the type of card. At this point DGM Pallab intervened. The PSI wanted first Pallab to establish his own identity. Poor chap had to show his ID card to get journalists in the pandal. As per the printed programme there was a press conference at 1.20 pm. But no one there knew about it's venue. There were two DGMs from the CC unit of Vadodara. No one knew them and they preferred to remain in their seat in the front section of the Pandal enjoying the programme. Secretary to Union Petroleum Minister Murli Deora curtly told journalists that the minister was in hurry and so journalists could talk to him while he was walking. While, this gentleman was saying this, there was an announcement from the stage that journalists should gather at the stage for the press conference!. All rushed toward the stage. After some journalists gathered on the stage , police stopped the entry of journalists. It was for the safety reasons, police said. Weight might lead to the collapse of the stage, journalists were told. However, all were allowed after some heated arguments. While journalists were trying to adjust to make shift arrangements at the stage, Director HR of ONGC came on the stage. He asked security not to allow anyone to come close to the ministers and positioned himself just behind the Minister. It was a vantage point to appear straight in the visibility zone of the cameras. Certainly, it was a great opportunity for anyone to be seen in the news and to be archived in the records of the ONGC for the 100 year event of Lunej discovery. Journalists had to scribble standing at the stage evenas the press conference was part of the programme.
All did not end with the media interaction. There was another round at the lunch session. They had two pandals, one for the ministers and the ONGC top brass and the other one for the rest. Officers at the VIP pandal would not allow any journalist to get in. Some could manage to get in courtesy Joshipura who had to request to his seniors for media entry. Many of those who went to the other pandal had to literally struggle to get food.
In the VIP pandal, some journalists complained to the Minister of State for Petroleum Dinsha Patel about the bus and poor arrangements. Some had told about this around 12 noon when the Minister had reached the place. The minister called officers of the ONGC and asked them to make arrangements of cars to ferry journalists back to Ahmedabad. However, when journalists came out there were no promised cars. The top brass had left in helicopters and the ministers were also not there. And they had to return in the 3x2 ordinary khatara bus in the scorching heat of the dry region of Khambat oil field. There is something more to this tale of the Navratan. ONGC had honoured five of its retired staff since they were with ONGC in 1958. But at lunch, only one of them was allowed entry. It is just because he happened to be a senior officer.
When someone drew the attention of Dinsha Patel to this insulting treatment to the honoured guests, he sought details. A senior officer said all were given entry in the VIP pandal. Minister wanted to meet them. The officer vanished in the thin air of the VIP pandal. The event was about the discovery of oil in 1958 and the museum at the site. No journalist was taken to the site , nor anyone from the stage spoke about oil. Right from Shankarsinh Vaghela to Local MP Bharatsinh Solanki talked about more money to be spent by ONGC in the villages around Lunej. And like a pre fixed game, the ONGC announced Rs three crore water supply scheme for villages around Lunej for coming years.
|
|
Sheikh new PRO to Governor
M M Sheikh, Deputy Director, Information Department, has been appointed PRO to Gujarat governor. Sheikh with long experience of media has replaced Manoj R Dave in the Raj Bhavan. Manoj has been transferred to Mumbai as Deputy Director of Information. The post was vacant for longtime. Rathod with AIR Ahmedabad
Baldev Rathod who retired four years back is now back with the All India Radio Ahmedabad. His post retirement assignment is in view of coming Lok Sabha elections and he will be attached with the news section of the AIR, a section with which he had remained associated for long. It is certainly, a temporary re-installation of Rathod.
Manish Suresh with the Aajkaal
Manisha Suresh has joined Rajkot based noon paper Aajkaal in Ahmedabad. She is among those who had lost job because of the winding up of Dainik Jagaran project even before the paper was launched in Gujarat. Earlier , she was with , Metro, Ahmedabad based noon paper.
| |
"There was a time when the reader of an unexciting newspaper would remark, 'How dull is the world today!' Nowadays he says, 'What a dull newspaper!'"
-Daniel J. Boorstin
|
With Love,
Yogesh Sharma GujaratGlobal.com |
|
|
|
|
|
|