Media Newsletter
GujaratGlobal
Issue 27
September 27, 2008
Greetings!

This Newsletter from the GujaratGlobal  brings to you the latest happening in the media particularly in Gujarat, whats hot and whats not , who's in and who's out , you want it and you get it here !This newsletter is about people who craft voice and image of others. It is about the real newsmakers.
 
 

                Editor........ Judgmental Reporting 
 


Our way of reporting particularly hot topics relating to crime is leaving people with bitter sense of hurt. This is one of the main reasons for the readers developing an attitude of mistrust and hatred towards media. Arushi murder case is one of the best recent examples. The father of Arushi was declared offender by the media while the truth was totally otherwise. No doubt, later Dr. Talwar was given a clean chit. But what about the hurt and agony he and his family had to suffer. This was an individual case.
But when it comes to terrorism, an entire community is painted villain. Adjectives like hard core terrorist, master mind of the terrorist operation involve individuals, but they have community effect. Police has its limited agenda when it "plants" stories in the media. It is just to show that police is a great performer. What is used as image building strategy by police becomes image demolishing action for a community.
In the long run such judgmental stories from the highly placed reliable sources become a damaging action for society. Then we need laws that do not need evidence. Is their any merit in this? We support such demands in the name of nationalism. Now who can argue against national interest?
In this issue I have article Media Muslims and Mujahideen by Mubasshir Mushtaq in which he has brought this point very well. He has written this article on his blog Sunday Gentleman. The article brings out this issue very well.
I think that in the national interest we must have an open debate on this type of reporting and police and other agencies should keep these issues while planting stories in the media.
I have used the word plant for police stories because we have no means to cross check. We have to take police version in good faith.
There are other stories about happening media.  

Have A Happy Reading.


With love  

Yogesh Sharma

Gujarat Global

Join Our Mailing List
Archive...

Did u miss out on any of the action which has taken place or want to sneak a peek again?? Here is our Archive.
Now you can find all our earlier issues here.


Archive Gallery..

Media Masala

 
Limca record increment of Mirror
 
Five digit salaries are quite common and so hefty increments, even as newspapers are up in arms against the idea of the wage board. Times of India's midloid Mirror started a new trend with its launch in Ahmedabad.
It recruited staff which did not know English at a pay packet four to five times these journalists were getting in their Gujarati publication. A team of translators turn the facts collected by these journalists into a readable fiction in English.
Recently, the publication gave an increment to one of its senior journalist that can fit into some category of Limca book of Records. It gave an increment of Rs21000 to its reporter Dilip Patel. Dilip who was picked up at a salary of about Rs 56,000 pm from Divya Bhaskar has now his monthly pay packet of Rs 77,000!!!
 
 
 
Jayantilal ban gaya spokesperson
 

Last week I had written about the training of the spokespersons of the Congress at Mumbai. Here Viruppa Moiely and others had given them tips about handling media. I ad said that Moiely should see that there is good presence at such workshops
Jayantilal Parmar SMSwala had also attended the workshop. He says that the presence was very good at the meeting as 59 of the 131 registered participants had attended the programme. Others could not come because of frequent changes in the dates of the programmes and heavy rains that lashed several parts of Gujarat. All had appreciated the attendence from Gujarat.
Certainly our Jayantilal was following one of the tips of the workshops in which it was said that spokespersons should defend the party and its leaders. Jayantilal who is known for his SMS to journalists and is also a spokesperson of Gujarat Congress has shown that he is a good student also! So he is not an appointed but a qualified spokesperson!!!
Chief spokesperson Arjun Modhwadia was quick to remark that attendance is a relative term.
 
Paramount Test Ride
 
This week Paramount Airways had its press conference in Ahmedabad. It was to announce introduction of Ahmedabad Chennai flight. All business class flight.62 newsmen and photographers were invited and all were there at the meet. It was really great achievement for Vipula Shukla of PR Agency Vital Relations.
Though, the flight from Chennai was late, journalists of all hue waited with patience. When the flight arrived, media persons were taken into the aircraft and they hovered over the city for ten minutes. It had just routine safety belt demonstration and usual in flight announcement. The event was company's unique way to make buzz in the market.
However, journalists had a bumpy ride off flight when CEO of the company was missing for long. He appeared only when journalists decided to quit the lounge. The 31 year CEO was a young man in hurry. He had no time for long interaction. For personal interviews, he offered only three minutes. For most of questions, he had just one comment, no comment.
His flight crew also followed him. They did not want journalists in the aircraft for long because, according to them it was at the cost of their valuable customers who had paid for the tickets. Journalists had to tell them that they were not there on their own and had no time to waste. Only such argument made the flight staff mellow down.
The company had to pay for the bumpy ride of journalists as none photographed the water salute event organised by the company. Though the company did not make any claim about its in flight service, the TEST RIDE was more than enough to tell how jerky the Paramount flight can be from take off to landing!!!!
 
Krishna joins TOI portal
 

Times of India has created a separate department to handle its online "products". Krishna Shah who has worked with various print publications in Gujarat has joined Times Portal as Deputy Editor. Her assignment is to look after the online service in Gujarat.
Krishna who started her career with Financial Express(Gujarati) and was with Garvi Gujarat, a UK based publication, as its resident Editor in Ahmedabad is presently  in Delhi for induction. Her first assignment is to develop portal for ET Gujarati.
She is expected to operate from Gujarat after Diwali.
 
Mahesh Langa and Vikas Bhargav now with PTI
 
Two more reporters have joined PTI Ahmedabad. Mahesh Langa who was principal correspondent with DNA is going to join PTI from the next week. He will be in Delhi for one month for induction. Langa started his career with Tahalka five years back was with Indian Express before joining DNA.
Vikas Bhargva who was with Ahmedabad Mirror is now with the PTI.




 
An appeal

 
Friends as I told earlier, the newsletter has a subscriber base of 2100 plus. There are many more who are reading it either directly from the website or through forwards. I request you all friends to mobilize more subscriptions to the newsletter by enrolling your friends in media. This is your platform. Help it grow.
 
 
   Media, Muslims and Mujahideen

This article is written by Mubasshir on his blog Sunday gentleman.

Now that the Delhi Police has "cracked" the bomb blasts, I can make my own confessions. Suspicion is not a fundamental right enshrined in Indian Constitution but it is an unalienable right in a flourishing democracy. Suspicion is the fundamental premise on which the edifice of our intelligentsia stands. Therefore, intelligence agencies cannot be denied the right to suspect. The same right to suspect cannot be denied to ordinary Indians. Equality is the hallmark of a true democracy.

The journalist in me has a problem when an official declaration, a chronological monologue, is treated as the gospel. It is not the job of a journalist to arrive at conclusions. The job of a journalist is to stand outside the circle and communicate nuances and niceties taking place inside the circle. When a journalist jumps into the circle, he becomes part of the story. Proximity breeds bias. Bias breeds bigotry. A true journalist can be anything but he can never be a bigot.

Journalistic bigotry is dangerous for it plays a vital role in shaping public opinion. Each such story leaves an imprint on public consciousness. In each blast, media, the fourth estate, behaves like fourth mistake. The needle of suspicion automatically swings towards Muslims whether it is Mecca Masjid blast or Malegaon blasts in which devout Muslims were specifically targeted inside their mosques. Every time there is a blast, Muslims find themselves in the no man's land. They are caught in the crossfire between intelligence agencies and terrorists. Neither of them will trust Muslims. The day-today Muslim problem is bread and butter rather than the bomb.

Each blast is viewed from the green lens of Islam although saffron lens is equally making India red. One of the reasons for these blasts is to put the entire Muslim community in the defensive mode by systematically manipulating Islam. The trick is like a psychological warfare before the beginning of actual war.

It is true that a minuscule minority among Muslims has become radical. It is equally true that a minuscule minority among Hindus has gone on the extreme. SIMI, RSS and Bajrang Dal, are competing identities, each one claiming to represent their respective community. It is competitive extremism at work which can be summed up in one-line: My version of extremism is better than yours! Media plays safe when RSS and Bajrang Dal are involved in bomb blasts while it indulges in triumphant journalism when SIMI comes under the scanner. The reason for this differential approach is commercial: No businessman would want to antagonize the majority Hindu readers. Media, therefore, claims to be nationalistic but it only practices majoritarian nationalism.

From a journalistic point of view, I have a problem when Police changes the names of 'alleged' (it is one adjective which we in the media have abused and used at will) masterminds overnight. First it was Abdus Subhan Qureishi (alias Tauqeer), now it is Atif, the "terrorist" who has been gunned down.

The journalist in me finds it hard to digest that Mufti Abul Bashar, the alleged mastermind of Ahmedabad blasts, is linked to Delhi blasts. If Bashar is really connected to Delhi blasts, the bomb blasts should never have taken place since he was in police custody when the blasts took place. How can Bashar, a poor madrasa-educated person mastermind Ahmedabad blast with such precision? When did Indian Madrasas start producing tech-savvy Muslims? Indian government would love that to happen! There won't be any need for Central madrasa board for modernization then!

Police says that the educated Muslims are involved in the blasts yet they arrest who will not be termed 'educated' by worldly standards. Mufti Bashar is just one example. A section of the mainstream media is extremely behaving like the nautch girl of Indian intelligent agencies. Instead of investigating the police claims, media is promoting self-contradictory journalism.

The journalist in me has a problem when a TV correspondent spits out the intelligence feed that there was a meeting of SIMI in 2001 where 200 youth were recruited to wreak havoc across India. What was our intelligence agency doing for the last 8 years?

Muslim accused are being branded as terrorists before the proper investigation and filing of the chargesheet. The actual trial by a court of law is yet to begin but the trial by media has already passed its judgement. Sample this:

"Mohammed Saif, the terrorist (emphasis added) who was arrested after Friday's encounter, even possessed a fake voter card." (TOI, September 21, page 1, Delhi edition)

Isn't it a perfect example of Judgemental journalism?

Meanwhile Muslims live under siege and fear. State, said Mahatma Gandhi, is nothing but organized violence. Friday's encounter of Jamia Nagar in Delhi raises some disturbing questions. Local Muslims have termed it as "dubious." They have reasons to believe so. As a Delhi friend put it, "No one saw cross firing yesterday. Only the police claim it happened. Did you read in any report that anyone actually saw cross-firing?" She added, "How come the two so-called terrorists managed to flee? There was only one exit." She asked, "If they knew they were going for a possible encounter, why wasn't the building or the area properly covered by the police?"

Her conclusion was chilling and disturbed me:

"But the point is that they can kill anyone anywhere. Tomorrow my brother might be the target and on flimsiest of grounds with no chance of proving the innocence. You are guilty just because they say so."

"It makes me bloody angry."

Indian Muslims live with fear, security, discrimination and terror tag. A bunch of the so-called 'Muslims' have hijacked their Faith. I detest when somebody says those who planted the bombs were Muslims. Indian Mujahideen, a faceless body, has launched a faceless jihad for the sake of Indian Muslims. A true jihad can never be faceless. If one peers through Islamic history, he will come to know that a jihad is a battle which is fought under the banner of recognition and not anonymity.

I see a problem when a country of more than one billion people can't arrest a loose bunch of murderers who want to convert India into a slaughterhouse.

Indian intelligence agencies have some much input yet they produce zero output.

India's 160 million Muslims have a problem: fear. And nobody is willing to even listen to them. They are the in-betweens of India's fight against terrorism. They want to be part of the solution and not part of the problem. India needs to integrate them. A Muslim friend put it bluntly, "Rabindranath Tagore's poem 'Where the mind is without fear' no longer adorns my wall."
 


14 year vanvas of Rathin Das
 
 
Gujarat seems to be kaala pani for journalists of outside publications. For reasons still not known, people who are transferred to Gujarat from places like Delhi do not want to stay here. What is more, newspapers do not easily transfer these correspondents once they are posted in Gujarat.
There are many who kept on trying for months and years to go out of Gujarat. Not many have succeeded. Rathin Das completed 14 years with Hindustan Times this month and still he is here. Rathindas who has passion for drama particularly street plays wonders about his fate without drama element of transfer.
 
Using all his histrionic skills he explains that even in Hindu mythology the maximum period of vanvas is 14 years . Resigning to his fate, Rathin Das , a kind of vidrohi atma(rebel soul) , is now working on writing his memoirs of 31 years in journalism. While in Delhi he was known as dissident sub editor, pole opposite to the Resident Editor. He has a theme of his memoirs, Menace called Press!
 
He hopes that by the time of his retirement after four years, his memoirs will make an appearance on the stage of the world in some form. He is the founder member of Jan Natya Manch of Delhi which recently celebrated 35th anniversary. He is the senior most member associated with the Manch.
 
One should not be surprised if theatre lover Rathin Das comes out with his Menace called Press with the spirit and form of famous Denis the menace!!!!
 


DAVP increases ad rates
 
The government on Thursday raised ad rates paid by its ad agency, the Directorate of Advertising and Visual Publicity, or DAVP, by 24%, with retroactive effect from 1 September. The publishing industry had been demanding a rate hike since April this year and in early August, information and broadcasting minister Priya Ranjan Dasmunsi said the ministry was working on hiking ad rates.
His announcement followed a representation by an Indian Newspaper Society delegation, which demanded a 50% hike in ad rates. All government agencies and ministries, with some exceptions, route their advertisements through DAVP, which enjoys low ad rates. For large newspapers such as 'The Times of India' or the 'Hindustan Times', DAVP ads account for about 10-15% of ad volumes and 8-10% of ad revenues. 

 

 CAMA INS President

 Bombay Samachar director Hormusji N Cama has been selected as the president of the Indian Newspaper Society (INS) for 2008-2009. Cama replaces Bahubali Shah of Gujarat Samachar.
While Delhi Press editor Paresh Nath has been re-elected as deputy president, Deccan Chronicle chairman Venkatram Reddy will be holding the position of vice-president once again. HT Media vice-president - operations north Rakesh Sharma remains as the treasurer. The elections were held this month in Bangalore.
On the agenda of Cama is an international newspaper conference in January 2009. Other issue is work out a model for newspapers to help fight soaring newsprint prices. One of the ideas is to get better rates from DAVP. While the INS has been asking for 50 per cent rise, the government has already announced a 24 per cent hike.



 
Every day I get up and look through the Forbes list of the richest people in America.  If I'm not there, I go to work. 
 
~Robert Orben

With Love,
 
Yogesh Sharma
GujaratGlobal.com