Pristine Classical header
Newsletter - 16 December 2011  
E-mail header
QUICK LINKS
KARAJAN Gala
CURZON Beethoven
PADA Exclusives
FREE ALBUM
 PACO045

A FREE 128k MP3!

 

MOZART

THE MAGIC FLUTE  

[CD1 only) 

 

 

Featuring:
Helge Roswaenge
Tiana Lemnitz
Gerhard Hüsch
Irma Beilke
Wilhelm Strienz
Erna Berger


Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra
Favres Solisten Vereinigung 

conducted by
Sir Thomas Beecham

 

Recorded in 1937

"We have come to expect impressive sound from Andrew Rose... I would have guessed it was a good mono recording from the 1950s...heartily recommended..." 

Göran Forsling, MusicWeb International 

 

XR remastered by  

Andrew Rose 

 

 

Download it now - for one week only - it's only free from our Cover Page!

 

 

 

OR PURCHASE "UPGRADE" to full quality 320k MP3, lossless 16-bit or 24-bit FLAC downloads (where available), download free covers and cue sheets, scores and notes here:

 

PACO 045 - Mozart  

 
LATEST REVIEW
Audiophile Audition

13 December
2011

CANTELLI'S TCHAIKOVSKY   

By Gary Lemco

 

"Guido Cantelli delivers Tchaikovsky performances with potent vigor and a degree of elegance that testifies to his classical adherence to form even in the midst of theatrical passion"

 
PASC316


The tragically brief career of Italian maestro Guido Cantelli (1920-1956) has the consolation of the powerful recordings he bequeathed us, including the two performances of Tchaikovsky herein revivified by restoration master Mark Obert-Thorn. Each of these London-based inscriptions appeared both on 78 rpm and LP formats; but on this CD the seamless sound rarely indicates anything like their "interrupted" source. The Romeo and Juliet (13 October 1951) enjoys the expert discipline of the Philharmonia Orchestra, which could boast French horn Dennis Brain among its luminaries. The La Scala Orchestra performance of the Fifth Symphony (23, 26 September 1950) drives a "fateful" and self-absorbed work forward with minimal histrionics but rather a noble and often heroically lyrical series of gestures to excellent effect.

The Romeo and Juliet Overture in B Minor, composed at the urging of Balakirev to set Shakespeare's romantic tragedy as a symphonic poem in sonata-form, provides an excellent vehicle for Cantelli and his London forces. The conception remains tight and taut, the various moods of the drama, the animosity of the feuding families, and the ardent passion of the doomed lovers conveyed with sweep and inexorable doom. The relative speed of the reading does not detract from the urgency of the various sentiments, and Cantelli utilizes, unlike Stokowski, the aggressive ending to the score. Like his master-mentor Toscanini, Cantelli effects elegant transitions within the spiraling drama itself.

Toscanini had little respect for the Fifth Symphony of Tchaikovsky, but Cantelli championed the work, and we have readings from New York, London, and Boston. I find Cantelli's approach to the first movement somewhat ambivalent, in that he nurtures a lofty sonority and elegant resolve to the "fate motto," but he has a tendency to render glib phrases that Koussevitzky and Mravinsky would milk to the fullest. Still, the long line that Cantelli propels by its own inertia and élan vital quite compels our attention, as does the coda. The La Scala trumpet work proves engrossing and committed. The effect distills a neo-Classical design on an ultra-Romantic conception, especially in the Valse, taken at the directed tempo, which slows down the "accepted" versions. Happily, Cantelli does not take the devastating cut in the finale as Mengelberg and Sargent do, which ruins their otherwise imposing accounts. The true heart of the performance clearly lies in Cantelli's soaring reading of the Andante cantabile, truly a heartfelt paean to personal melancholy that practices self-overcoming. The Philharmonia cello line rarely receives the credit it deserves for sheer beauty of articulation and tonal warmth. Here, resplendent in their collaboration with the Philharmonia winds, brass, and tympani, the enduring song attains a firm self-assurance without whimpering or false sentimentality. Sound restoration in both works warrants repeated listening for the authenticity and vivid expressivity rescued from 60-year-old originals belying their age at every bar.     

  

     

PASC 316 - Cantelli

 

    
LATEST REVIEWS
MusicWeb International

December 2011    

HANSON CONDUCTS AMERICAN MUSIC, VOLUME2 1-3 

By Rob Barnett

  

"A fascinating slice of American musical history from the 20C all romantically and energetically spun by Hanson"

 

PASC292

IPR law and the passage of time has freed up enterprises such as Pristine to liberate recordings now more than fifty years old. These mono Mercury LP derivatives take wing again courtesy of Andrew Rose and his marvellously applied XR re-mastering.
 
Hanson's Fourth Symphony (there are seven) is sumptuous. The music wells up in great gouts of sound. Everything is burnished and regal with a slow sovereign eruption of melody. If you know his first three symphonies all issued by Universal in stereo then you will instantly relate to this throbbing convulsive music. I am not sure that the Requiem title and movements add solidly to the music, They stand as sincere indicators of the moods and senses the composer had in mind. The music was written in memory of Hanson's father. The very short Dies Irae recalls his gritty propulsive way with the fast movements in the first and second symphonies and link in turn to The Rite and Rimsky's Antar. The finale is Lux Aeterna which is also the title Hanson gave to an earlier work for orchestra. The sense of striving and majestic heavenly flight and bell-tolling is there again. Hanson is, as ever, a master of building the romantic climax as he was to be again in the glorious Sixth Symphony. So it proves here though the work ends in taciturn rather than refulgent style.
 
The sound is always plenary, affluent and burnished: golden among the horns and silvery heroic in the trumpets. There is, at times, a slight sense of tizz when the audio pressure is really on; otherwise the sound-picture is very agreeable. It upholds across the decades the vaunted Mercury reputation.
 
The poetically coloured Loeffler has not been freshly recorded though this is the second version in historical sound. It sound better than it did on that Guild 2CD set of Tocanini Americana. The music is affectionately cast in an idiom that echoes that of Rimsky-Korsakov with a Gallic aspect. The whole thing is in a single track. It's quite magical. I do wish we could hear more Loeffler. By the way it's Loeffler's Life in a Russian Village not as Pristine have it Live in a Russian Village.
 
Hanson's Song from Drum Taps to words by Whitman clamours for attention. It has a fire in common with similar works by RVW (Dona Nobis Pacem) and Bliss (Morning Heroes). The choir is fervent and the flames are fuelled further by the edgy attack of drums and brass. David Meyers guides us mysteriously in hushed tension through By the bivouac's fitful flame with the choir taking a tactful and unassertive shading. The clamant rapture returns for To Thee Old Cause (also set by William Schuman). This is the most masterfully spun of all the three movements and rises in molten fervour. The words can be had on Pristine's website.
 
Good to hear this old friend in such good fettle. This leads us to Randall Thompson's Jefferson-based Testament of Freedom which has a clear affinity with the Hanson work. I recall the inspiring experience of hearing these recordings thirty years ago when the box of rare LP Americana arrived by post one summer morning. The Thompson is stirringly four-square and full of admirably earnest commitment to humane values. The rhythmic life that transforms the Second Symphony is touched on but not fully replicated. It's well worth hearing and there is a transcendent gleam in I shall not die without a hope which is the finale. The singing by the Eastman School of Music Chorus never once relents from commitment and patriotism. It reminded me of John Ireland's These Things Shall Be more than once. The music swings indomitably along lit by that unwavering blaze of democratic rhetoric.
 
PASC 296 is a confident entry with two post WW2 symphonies written within a year of each other. The evolutionary-paced bloom of Piston's Third is strongly controlled by Hanson. The conductor must have warmed to its sonorously unhurried heroism no doubt coloured by the country's experience of a World War and the impending Korean conflict. His surefooted way continues to impress across this four movement 35 minute symphony. It's not as catchy or as accessible as its predecessor which was unmatchably recorded by DG with the Boston Symphony Orchestra and Michael Tilson Thomas in 1971 and can still be heard on XXXX. Even so the impudent irrepressibility heard in the finale of the Second Symphony skitters its way through the first Allegro. The chill-blasted bleach of the 3rd movement Adagio is almost tender but certainly melancholically pained. One senses splintery stamping mid-western zest in the finale. The second Allegro and the taut and tight pummelling of the final few moments speak of Piston's control if not of unbridled exuberance.
 
Henry Cowell's Fourth Symphony is much shorter at about twenty minutes. It has a sort of echo in the Hymn-Allegro first movement of tender 'westerniana' coupled with The Great Gate of Kiev and even a touch of Purcell. The wistful avian piping of Ballad is followed by the jig-innocent Celtic balladry and danseries of the Vivace. The final Fuguing Tune takes a punt at the Great Gate again but with Purcellian awe and bell-rung majesty. Interestingly his movement titles link with titles of many of this other works: Hymn, Fuguing Tune, Dance, Ballad.
 
The Loeffler Poem for Orchestra is another slow-blooming statement of the passions - Tchaikovskian really. It rises to stormy passions for sure. It was the first time I had heard the piece. If you enjoy the Macdowell Arthurian tone poems or those by Farwell perhaps with a tinge of early Delius then you should hear this. I had not encountered it before but was very glad to make its rhapsodic instinctive acquaintance.
 
PASC 302 is volume 3. We start with a very early work by the wondrously log-lived Carter. His The Minotaur is dynamic, virile, brutal, burred, tense and atmospheric. It's not short on Stravinskian high voltage. It can be cool as well as in the miraculous Ariadne, Princess of Crete and poignant as in Theseus's Farewell to Ariadne which brings a lump in the throat as much as Bliss's music for Hector's Farewell to Andromache in Morning Heroes. Wallingford Riegger's New Dance is more sumptuous and sounds lavish though not to diffuse its shatteringly savage rhythmic howl, blast and electric ripple. The Macdowell Indian Suite derives from the early 1890s - another era. The music is Lisztian, tenderly romantic, fleet-footed and only very faintly ethnic - a slight overtone in the lightly caricatured Village finale which yet ends in a glorious blaze. That same finale from time to time reminded me of Sibelius's Lemminkainen Suite recently issued in the elite mono 1950s version with Ormandy by Pristine (PASC 299).
 
These discs are available separately from Pristine either as discs or in various download formats.
 
After a couple of discs where I have been less than welcoming I am so pleased that Pristine have returned to their true and exultant form.
 
Let's have more please. How about the Hanson Fifth Symphony (transferred by Haydn House) and the extended ERSO extracts from Merry Mount.
 
This is a fascinating slice of American musical history from the 20C. It's all sensitively and energetically spun by Hanson. . 

     

PASC292 - Hanson

 

 

   

 

Join Our Mailing List
CONTENTS
Editorial         Reflections on the digital future
Karajan         
That ballet and gala - plus some 1940s gems

Curzon           Master of Beethoven's piano concertos
PADA              Oskar Fried conducts Brahms' 1st Symphony

Editorial - Going digital?

Reflections on the future...  



A couple of weeks ago I wrote a column in response to a rather pained e-mail I'd received complaining about the move to all things digital. (Ironic really, that it was delivered by e-mail and not on paper or parchment, inscribed in India ink with a quill pen, but there you go...)

The response to that column was one of the biggest I've had. And in amongst the messages of support and agreement, were a number which expressed, more or less, a somewhat resigned desire to move into a more "digital" future which was being driven as much by necessity and an expectation that it will be a painful process but, possibly, the least painful option for the long term.

I am of course aware that some of us like nothing better than to get our teeth into a good little home project. For some folk it may be model boat building, Do-It-Yourself renovations, or the more sedate pleasures of stamp collecting. For others (like me) it's fiddling around with computers and making them do all the whizz-bang things we dreamed might be possible when we were kids. (Naturally the children of today take PCs for granted and, if my own son is anything to go by, are about as excited about computers in themselves as I am about my refrigerator - in that case I'm usually more interested in the contents than the mechanics.)

But for those less inclined to install a PC in their living rooms than I, it seems the hi-fi manufacturers are finally getting their acts together and releasing a raft of different products designed, in one way or another, to get your digital content from wherever you have it stored and onto your loudspeakers or headphones. It's still early days for the technology, and if you wait I'm sure it'll get easier in time, but even now most of us should be able to find a system that suits us, just as we did when we last bought a turntable or a CD player. I see that the latest issue of Gramophone rounds up some of the best of these at price points to suit most pockets.

Of course you don't need to throw the baby out with the bathwater. Installing a digital replay system driven from a big hard drive doesn't mean you need to dispose of all your records, tapes or CDs immediately. But if you're like me, after a while you might come to realise that you're no longer listening to them very often, if at all - and the recovery of the space they're consuming suddenly seems rather attractive. I don't personally find a wall of plastic CD box spines particularly aesthetically pleasing, I must admit. Likewise shelves of ragged LP spines might have their nostalgic value, but I've always found something I'd rather look at in their place.

The other thing to consider is the gradual nature of the process of this kind of a change. It is unlikely to happen overnight - a little like the stamp collecting analogy, I'm currently collecting cover artwork to go with my digital albums - 3000 or so right now, of which perhaps 80% had artwork at the beginning of the week, and I've added enough in my spare time since then to get that up towards 90%. Like tracking down an elusive mint Penny Black, I'm expecting the last 10% to be a trickier though not impossible prospect - and I look forward to the satisfaction of having them all in. Then of course I'll have to move on to filling in those missing artist photos - I really do know how to have fun, you know...

The only situation where this move from tangible media - CD discs and the like - was pretty much final and uncompromising was in the car. Having become sick of glove compartments stuffed with scratched, unplayable CDs, I finally got rid of the lot and invested in an in-car player which would only operate from an SD memory card or a USB stick. The price of memory has tumbled, and I also invested in a 16GB SD-RAM card which cost me roughly the price of a "meal" for the three of us at MacDonalds - not a major investment.

However, this did take a little organising, and I expect I'll be giving it an overhaul for 2012. 16GB of MP3s (the machine won't play FLACs and frankly for my car the MP3 format is more than good enough) is a lot of space and time - and a lot of albums. The card has to be filled via the PC then slotted in behind the fascia of the player in the car. That said, with several hundred albums on it you don't feel the need to swap it in and out very often.

Back in October my car developed a particularly hard-to-track-down fault, and went for a lengthy visit to the local garage. During the 6 weeks it spent being examined, poked and prodded, I borrowed a car with a radio-cassette player and, not wanting to start digging out tapes from the attic I decided to indulge in the rather dubious delights of Radio Bergerac on my modest travels.

Last Friday afternoon my own car was finally returned to me, and it struck me anew what a marvellous thing it is to have such a vast library of albums to choose from when I go for a drive. Even my big CD wallet of old couldn't accommodate anything like the same number - and changing an album is now a quick prod of a button on the player rather than life-threatening juggling of silver discs, carried out whilst trying to keep one hand on the wheel and one eye on the road. It's one of those little changes which, once made, you'd never want to turn the clock back.

I'm feeling the same way about my switch-over in 2011 to digital books, thanks to my Kindle. Right now the world seems split between those who think these devices are wonderful (usually the people who have one) and those who think they're the spawn of the devil and won't ever give up the wonderful touch, smell and feel of a real book (usually those who don't have one).

My guess is that the majority of us are instinctively and a little unthinkingly in the latter camp, probably until we get a taste of the digital option. But once that threshold has been crossed, you being to find that those paper books you had planned to read next never quite get opened. You undergo an almost overnight conversion. You also find yourself reading as never before - in all sorts of ways. I was always one for reading a single book at a time - this week I've been reading, simultaneously, Eric Fenby on Delius, the biography of Steve Jobs (still - I did have a bit of a break from it) and War and Peace (likewise!). It also doubles up as a newspaper, which I take to the local swimming baths (work that one out!). We do of course still have our bookshelves, and they're full. Somehow I find them harder to part with than CD shelves, but they're rarely if ever visited these days, bar my collection of cookery books next to the kitchen door.

When I got up yesterday morning I had an e-mail from Gramophone telling me my copy of their January issue had arrived overnight on my iPad. This morning I sat down and starting 'leafing' through its contents. My eye was caught by one of the recordings which would have been included on the cover disc if it hadn't been replaced by an online stream - piano music by Manuel de Falla, as recorded by Javier Perianes with the BBC Symphony Orchestra on Harmonia Mundi.

Just before beginning this column I did a quick check - it was there at €8.99 on iTunes or €6.86 on eMusic. You won't need to guess which one I bought. I've been listening to it on my studio speakers while typing this, having saved the download to my network drive. When I've finished I'll pop downstairs and continue listening on my hi-fi, or perhaps in the kitchen on my Squeezebox Radio. The Falla is available in almost any room in the house at the touch of a button (and the artwork is embedded!) - and I expect a copy of it will be in the car before long too. No CDs to copy, no LPs to tape, my entire collection is permanently backed up and safe from damage - and it all took barely five minutes from reading the review to sitting back and enjoying the recording. That, to me, is one measure of progress, as is the automatic cataloguing of my collection - I can type "Falla" or "Perianes" into my iPad (working as a remote control to my hi-fi) and it'll sift through the database of music and bring it up instantly, ready to play.

If and when you decide to take a step in this direction you might find it an overnight conversion, or you might live with both your current set-up and a new hard-drive based system running side-by-side for years or decades to come. My experience so far has been that in each year that passes the CD-free digital option gets more attractive. We're not yet at a point where anyone's being forced to make the change, and despite rumours and predictions, I don't think anybody's about to start forcing that change onto you for a good while yet.

But I have no doubt that this is a change we'll all embrace - and when we do, we'll no more wish to go back to discs and tapes and cylinders and the like than we'd wish to give up our cars and return to a life of travelling by horse and carriage, however pleasurable the older method of transport can be.

 

Andrew Rose
16 December 2011
 

 
Ballet and Gala Performance from Karajan's 1960 Fledermaus

 

Plus four stunning Strauss recordings from 1940-42     

 

  

PACO 070STRAUSS             

Fledermaus Ballet & Gala
Waltzes and Overtures         

  

Recorded 1960, 1940-42   

Producer and Audio Restoration Engineer:  Andrew Rose       

  

 

  

JOHANN STRAUSS II Die Fledermaus - Ballet

  

LEHAR, LEON, STEIN   Vilia-Lied (The Merry Widow) 
Renata Tebaldi

FERARI, PLANTE   Domino 
Fernando Corena

LOEWE, LERNER   I Could Have Danced All Night (My Fair Lady) 
Birgit Nilsson

VALENTE, TAGLIAFERRI, BOVIO   Passione 
Mario del Monaco

LAVILLA   Lullaby 
Teresa Berganza

ARDITI   Il bacio 
Joan Sutherland

LEHAR   Dein ist mein ganzes Hertz (Land of Smiles) 
Jussi Björling

GERSHWIN, GERSHWIN, HEYWARD   Summertime (Porgy and Bess) 
Leontyne Price

BERLIN   Anything you can do (Annie Get Your Gun) 
Giulietta Simionato & Ettore Bastianini

SIECZYNSKI   Wien, Wien nur du allein 
Ljuba Welitsch 

Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra & State Opera Chorus
Herbert  von Karajan
conductor


Plus, from 1940-1942: 

STRAUSS
   Künstlerleben, Op. 316 
STRAUSS   Kaiser-Walzer, Op. 437 
STRAUSS   Der Zigeunerbaron - Overture 
STRAUSS   Die Fledermaus - Overture

Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra
Herbert  von Karajan
conductor
 
 

   

 

Web page: PACO 070  

  

  

Short Notes  

When we released Karajan's ground-breaking 1960 recording of Die Fledermaus two weeks ago, we deliberately omitted a section of the original recording which effectively interrupts the flow of the piece - the ballet music and "gala performance" of music by other composers.

Instead we've opted to give these recordings their own release. They feature an entirely different array of singing stars - a truly stellar cast it must be said - performing a variety of songs from the classics and the Broadway stage - magical stuff even if it has little to do with Strauss!

This release also includes four astonishing-sounding recordings of music by Strauss recorded in the early 1940s by Karajan with the Berlin Philharmonic. These have not been simply "dusted off" for this release, but utterly transformed by Pristine's XR remastering - truly something that must be heard to be believed!

 

 

 

REVIEW Original LP issue (excerpt)

  

There is indeed a whole procession of turns or party pieces added in to the festivities at the place (after "Dui-du") where custom sometimes interpolates a long ballet sequence. Here we get an inch or so of party music and then, like a cabaret, come the interpolations. Miss Resnik as Orlofsky (not quite as dashing as one could have wished in "Chacun a son gout") is supposed to be entertaining not merely "die schoene junge Ratten" from the Opera but a galaxy of Decca's top recording stars as well. There is polyglottery a la St. John's Wood: jokes in English and Italian as well as the current German and, for the purist I daresay, a very considerable disruption of the kind of mood so far established. Tebaldi leads off with a very serious, slightly heavy but beautiful "Viljalied" (in German). Corena obliges with the sort of song I associate with Yves Montand, also charming. These like every other item elicit a tumultuous welccrne frcm the other guests. Nilsson's song from My Fair Lady is sung in excellent English; does the conjunction of music and artist show up either? I know which comes off second best: the composer. One just longs for him to provide something for this Brunnhilde to get her teeth into! I could have done without del Monaco in this particular drawing-room, but it too earns vociferous applause; Berganza's basque Lullaby is lovely, so are Leontyne Price's "Summertime" and in its daring and agility, Miss Sutherland's Waltz. The late Jussi Bjorling begins "You are my heart's delight" in Swedish and finishes it in German (this has brought us to side five), Simionato and Bastianini get a smile out of the incongruity of their double act and last of all, rather touchingly, Ljuba Welitsch expressing the hope that she is really welcome at the party, sings from the heart Wein, wein nur du allein; thus more or less bringing us back to the locale, if hardly the mood of Die Fledermaus.

What are the rights and wrongs of this interlude? Apparently it follows a tradition honoured on New Year's Eve at the Metropolitan, where other artists not actually singing in the performance contribute something to the party. It is after all only following up the precedent whereby eminent divas in the last century used to sing Comin' through the rye and the Carnival of Venice during the singing lesson scene in The Barber of Seville. (I've heard the Shadow Song thus introduced as late as about 1936 at Covent Garden.)

Some people will frown. I should like to be present when Desmond Shawe-Taylor unpacks his copies. On the other hand I have played it to persons of highbrow and middle-brow taste and neither was in any way "shocked", only amused. After all, one can quite easily skip (or fairly easily, though one would find it easier to begin again with the prison scene).

P. H-W. - The Gramophone, November 1960

 

   

  

Notes On this recording   

  

Our remastering of Karajan's 1960 Die Fledermaus (PACO 068) was drawn from the a 1962 SXL issue which excluded the Ballet and Gala sequence of the original LPs. Immediately following the release I was asked by a number of correspondents to restore both the Gala (which also appears on the current Decca CD reissue) and the Ballet (which does not). For my own personal tastes the present, separate release, is a more satisfactory solution both to the interruption otherwise of the flow Die Fledermaus, and to the difficulties of fitting the entire thing onto two CDs. I have applied exactly the same XR remastering treatments to the Ballet and Gala as were applied to the previous issue and faded out the present recording at the point at which the two begin to match once more.

This splitting of the works not only allows for the Ballet to be issued, but also for us to explore Herbert von Karajan's four Johann Strauss recordings of the early 1940s, made with the Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra for 78rpm release by Deutsche Grammophon. In each case the recordings have been completely transformed from dull, wartime issue sound into music which sparkles and shines in a quite remarkable and unexpected manner. Despite the occasional flaw one expects from recordings of this vintage, the detail and range of the recordings is astonishing when heard in these 32-bit XR-remastered reincarnations. 

  

 

 

     

MP3 Sample 1  Anything You Can Do    

Listen 

 

MP3 Sample 2  Künstlerleben    

Listen   

Download purchase links:

Stereo MP3  

Stereo 16-bit FLAC 

Stereo 24-bit FLAC   

  

  

CD purchase links and all other information:

PACO 070 - webpage at Pristine Classical  

 

Clifford Curzon is  

"the ideal pianist for the Fourth"

 

Two excellent Decca recordings given new life by Pristine's XR remastering

 

 

  

PASC318 BEETHOVEN

Piano Concertos 4 & 5         

Recorded 1954 & 1957

 

Producer and Audio Restoration Engineer:  Andrew Rose               

  

   


BEETHOVEN Piano Concerto No. 4 in G, Op. 58 
BEETHOVEN Piano Concerto No. 5 in F flat, Op. 73, "Emperor" 

 

Clifford Curzon piano 
Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra 
Hans Knappertsbusch conductor

 

 

Web page: PASC318  

  

  

Short Notes  

This week we mark Beethoven's 241st birthday (on 16th December) with fabulous performances of two of his very finest works - the Fourth and Fifth ("Emperor") Piano Concertos.

Recorded in Vienna in 1954 and 1957 by Clifford Curzon with the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra under Hans Knappertsbusch, these were well received Decca releases - the Fourth in particular: "This is a very fine issue indeed ; Curzon plays the entire work with authority" (Gramophone, 1954); "Every note is a pearl, and every note sings... you have in Curzon the ideal pianist for the Fourth... very special indeed" (MusicWeb International, 2000).

These new XR-remastered transfers have completely transformed the rather dim, "plummy" sound of Decca's 1954 original to bring the listener closer than ever to a magnificent recording - likewise the Emperor is significantly improved. Superb all round.

    

  

Review of Decca CD Reissue (2000) 

 

The somewhat plummy piano sound of the 1954 mono recording of the Fourth cannot dim the wonderful translucency of Curzon's passage work. Every note is a pearl, and every note sings. Add to this the most exquisite shading of the lyrical melodies and, in the relatively few moments where this concerto calls for it, considerable strength, and you have in Curzon the ideal pianist for the Fourth. The orchestral sound is a bit raw at times so you don't quite get the amalgamation that this concerto needs, and Knappertsbusch was notably unconcerned over minor matters of ensemble. He conducts with a good deal of character, however, and the booklet reveals that, after two days spent setting down the piece, the performers just played it straight through, more or less for fun, and then opted to use that version. This not only explains the spontaneity but makes the perfection of the pianism seem even more wonderful.

The "Emperor" is a stereo recording from 1957, sounding well for its age. Here Knappertsbusch directs the outer movements with a proud splendour that never becomes heavy and the sound of the strings at the beginning of the slow movement provides the best possible of reasons for recording with the VPO. Curzon adds to the qualities already heard some very full, powerful tone (the opening of the finale is most arresting), so this is a performance which, while perhaps savouring the lyrical moments more than some others, gives a very complete view of the work. Tempi are fairly broad and the finale is amiable rather than impetuous so those who want Beethoven with a furrowed brow may be disappointed. All others will put it on their shelves alongside other favourite versions.

Of the two, though, I would say it is the Fourth which is very special indeed. It was Curzon's only recording of the work, while the "Emperor" was the last of four. Might we have the chance to hear at least one of the others? And I hope BBC Legends are examining the archives thoroughly, for Curzon's repertoire was by no means as slender as his recorded legacy suggests.

  

Christopher Howell MusicWeb International, December 2000



Notes on the recordings  

 

These two recordings straddle Decca's move in the mid-50s from mono to stereo - the mono Fourth Concerto here is presented in Ambient Stereo, retaining a central mono sound but allowing hall ambience some realistic stereo spread. Both recordings were rather constrained and a little boxy in sound, something that XR remastering has largely cured. Viennese orchestral pitch was notably high in the Fifth Concerto, something I've confirmed with electrical hum analysis - both original pitches have been accurately and precisely restored.

  

Andrew Rose

      

    

MP3 Sample  Concerto No. 5, 3rd mvt     

Listen

 

Download purchase links:

Stereo MP3  

Stereo 16-bit FLAC 

Stereo 24-bit FLAC  

  

CD purchase links and all other information:

PASC 318 - webpage at Pristine Classical   

 

 
Oskar Fried
Oskar Fried

PADA Exclusives

Streamed MP3s you can also download     

 

BRAHMS
Symphony No. 1 in C minor,  

Op. 68   

 

 

Berlin State Opera Orch.
Oskar Fried conductor

Acoustic recording, 1923

NB. Sound quality poor

Transfer from Past Masters LP, Cat. No. PM 32


 

This transfer is presented with Ambient stereo remastering by Dr. John Duffy. Additional restoration work by Andrew Rose.  

  

 

Over 500 PADA Exclusives recordings are available for high-quality streamed listening and free 224kbps MP3 download to all subscribers. PADA Exclusives are not available on CD and are additional to our main catalogue. 

 

 

Subscribe to PADA Subscriptions start from €1 per week for PADA Exclusives only listening and download access. A full subscription to PADA Premium gets you all this plus unlimited streamed listening access to all Pristine Classical recordings for just €10 per month, with a free 1 week introductory trial.