Pristine Classical header
Newsletter - 1st April 2011  
Beuron Abbey
QUICK LINKS
BEURON Easter
MEWTON-Wood
PADA Exclusives
INFORMATION
LATEST REVIEWS
CRQ
Vocal reviews

Spring
2011   
By Bruce Latham

"Elisabeth Griimmer was in her sweetest voice and has never been surpassed in the role of Eva; whilst Rudolf Schock - a very under-rated and under­used tenor - holds more than a candle to recent interpretations of Walther von Stolzing"

 
PACCO052

Pristine Audio have resurrected some old operatic war-horses from the EMI and Philips back catalogues. In the 1950s, Philips issued a number of complete opera recordings on LP, both popular and obscure, with comprehensive libretti and booklets. The majority of these sets were mono only; only three I think - Rigoletto, Cavalleria rusticana and Pagliacci - were in genuine stereo. One of the rarer operas, Mussorgsky's The Fair at Sorochintsi can only really claim fame through its inclusion of the original music for Night on a Bare Mountain, before Rimsky- Korsakov re-orchestrated the sequence without chorus as a stand-alone piece. Apart from that, there is nothing spectacular about this set. It is adequately sung by soloists from the Slovenian National Opera and well conducted by Samo Hubad. The sound is typically decent for its time (1955) with an excellent mid-frequency range but lacking the extremes of treble and bass, as was the case in most of these Philips issues. The transfer by Andrew Rose reflects this and matches well with the original. As fill-ups, Pristine have added perfectly passable performances of the "Polovtsian Dances" from Prince Igor and the Rimsky-Korsakov version of Night on a Bare Mountain with the Vienna Symphony Orchestra under Wilhelm van Otterloo, recorded three years later (PAC0053,130mins).

 

In the same vein comes Prokofiev's The Lovefor Three Oranges. Recorded in the same year as the Mussorgsky with similar Slovenian National Opera forces and conducted by Bogo Leskovich, this opera seems to work a little better than Sorochintsi. The sound is brighter and the transfer just as good (PAC0061,109mins). 

 

Possibly of more historical interest are two more offerings from the Philips catalogue in the form of Berg's Lulu (PAC0049, 121mins) and Weill's Rise and Fall of the City of Mahagonny (PAC0055, 134mins). This Lulu is the world premiere recording of the unfinished version of 1949, which includes the orchestral music composed for the finale. It boasts a strong cast. Ilona Steingruber is particularly good in the title role; Otto Wiener is Dr Schon and a young Waldemar Kmentt doubles as The Painter and The Prince. Herbert Häfner holds his forces together well with expert playing from the Vienna Symphony Orchestra. The recorded sound, transferred by Andrew Rose, is really very good and doesn't sound 60 years old. 

 

Weill's Mahagonny is a dark, satirical tale concerning prostitute Jenny and her lover Jimmy, who is later executed. Recorded in Hamburg in 1956, the intimate balance allows Weill's orchestration to be heard quite clearly and although the good mono sound cannot perhaps provide the sleazy atmosphere, the performances make up for that. Jenny is portrayed by the wonderful - and never bettered - Lotte Lenya. As Mrs Bigbeck Gisela Litz makes a good impression, and conductor Wilhelm Brückner-Rüggeberg gives solid support to his cast with the North German Radio Orchestra. Can we look forward to any more Philips releases as downloads in the future I wonder ? I hope so. Operas like Richard Strauss's Salome (with Rudolf Moralt) and Smetana's The Bartered Bride (Dimitri Gebre), could well do with another airing after being rather undervalued at the time of release. 

 

From Italian Columbia sources comes a 1928 Milan recording of Verdi's Aida conducted by Lorenzo Molajoli (PAC0054, 137mins). The cast features Gianina Arangi-Lombardi as Aida and Aroldo Lindi as Radames. Maria Capuana, who sings Amneris, sounds rather nasal in the upper register, but perhaps this is due to the unkind acoustic. The starry line-up also includes Tancredi Pasero and Salvatore Baccaloni as Ramphis and The King respectively. On paper this would have been an excellent set had it been recorded a few decades later! Ward Marston has made a very good transfer, considering the age of the originals, but recordings of Aida need more punch and brashness in the ensembles to make the required impact which only more recent performances can give. 

 

Leaving the best until last, here's the classic 1956 Rudolf Kempe recording of Wagner's Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg (PAC0052, 260mins). This set was considered one of the best recordings available at the time and we can see why. Elisabeth Griimmer was in her sweetest voice and has never been surpassed in the role of Eva; whilst Rudolf Schock - a very under-rated and under­used tenor - holds more than a candle to recent interpretations of Walther von Stolzing. Ferdinand Frantz is not perhaps the best Hans Sachs, but his is still a satisfactory account of the part and Benno Kusche is a wonderfully comic Beckmesser. All the small parts are well taken. It's a pity that Andrew Rose has taken his transfer from American Angel LPs (3572E/L) rather than the UK HMV LP issue (ALP1506-10) where the upper frequencies are not quite so accentuated, but all in all, this is a worthy attempt to make this superb performance once again, provided you can bypass the "ambient stereo" effect and listen exclusively in mono mode.


Releases reviewed:

  

PACO 053 Soronchinsti     

PACO 051 Oranges 

PACO 049 Lulu  

PACO 055 Mahagonny 

PACO 054 Aida 

PACO 052 Meistersinger

 

 

  



 
LATEST REVIEWS
CRQ
Orchestral reviews 
Spring
2011   
By Alan Sanders

"I found Miss Glazunov's playing quite enjoyable in its own unpretentious, straightforwardly expressive manner"

 
PASC249

Wilhelm Furtwangler's live October 1944 performance of Bruckner's Ninth Symphony with the Berlin Philharmonic has been issued in several editions. It remains his only recorded document of the work, an extraordinarily potent, doom-laden account which must reflect his feelings of despair at that late point in the second world war. The problem with this particular Magnetophon tape recording has always been a measure of distortion and flutter, but somehow Andrew Rose has managed to eliminate at least some of this, and the sound he has achieved is better than on any other transfer I have heard (PASC251, 58mins).

Elena Glazunov, the adopted daughter of the composer, received very contemptuous reviews of her performances of her father's two piano concertos when they were first issued on a Telefunken LP, and again when the record was reissued. She was a professional pianist who had given the first Paris performance of the Second Concerto, and she was probably still in her fifties when the recordings were made in 1956. It's true that the Hamburg Philharmonic Orchestra under Alois Melichar doesn't exactly shine, and there's nothing special about the recording quality, but I found Miss Glazunov's playing quite enjoyable in its own unpretentious, straightforwardly expressive manner (PASC249, 51mins)


Release reviewed:

  

PASC 251 Furtwängler 

PASC 249 Glazunov

 

  



 
Join Our Mailing List
CONTENTS
Editorial        Notes
Beuron          The Easter Liturgy - Gregorian Chant
Mewton-Wood   Stravinsky and Chopin Concertos
PADA              Poulenc's Sextet for Winds and Piano

Editorial - A few short notes


I'm cutting this very short this week - I've been suffering from a stinker of a cold for the last couple of days and trying to organise thoughts into any coherent column is probably beyond my pounding head right now, so instead I'm just putting a short note together which may be of help or interest to you.

New player problems? - I've had a small number of e-mails concerning the new MP3 player we've introduced recently from people having difficulties with it. For what it's worth, I've tested it on Windows XP, Windows 7 and iOS, using Firefox 3.6, Firefox 4, IE8, IE9, Chrome and Safari, and it's worked on all of them.

All of which is confusing when someone tells me it's not working for them. Then an e-mail yesterday from Philippe Bonin (whose Mewton-Wood LPs have been so used to me) discovered that when he switched from the old pristineaudiodirect.com domain to pristineclassical.com everything magically started working. So if you're not seeing a working player on the newest pages on our site, please check your browser is connected to Pristine Classical and not Pristine Audio Direct - it might just do the trick!


Brilliant Classics - Rumours abounded online earlier this week that the budget label had gone bust. It turns out there was a modicum of truth - their holding company had indeed folded, but the label has been sold on and will continue as before.


Online Piracy continues to be blamed by the majors for the decline in CD sales, despite heaps of evidence to the contrary. Apparently global sales have fallen by almost $1.5bn over the last year - even though this analysis clearly fails to take into account the number of teenagers buying single downloads rather than full-length CDs, the widespread demise of non-supermarket music retailers and the rise of self-publishing and independent labels - not to mention all the other distractions open to kids today!

Meanwhile I'm happy to report that Pristine's revenues (not included in the figure above) look set to grow between 30-50% this year over last year, if the first quarter of 2011 is anything to go by. The most popular releases so far have been the Stokowski Philadelphia Return Concert, Casals' Bach Suites and Furtwängler's Beethoven.




"Whoops - you did it again" - Download competition


Well, it was fun while it lasted, and yes we do have one final winner, but I think it's time to wind up this particular competition and start thinking about another for the near future.

The final winner then was David Budd, who was the only one to spot that our Trout Quintet from last week had apparently been re-scored with a second violin in place of the double bass. A download will be on its way as soon as I know what David would like.

A number of people did ask about the Fauré quote to Marguerite Long, concerning her wearing a dress in the key of F sharp major - this was indeed a genuine quote from her book! 

Andrew Rose, April 1st, 2011


 
PACO056

BEURON ABBEY MONKS  

The Easter Liturgy 

 

 

Producer and Audio Restoration Engineer:  Andrew Rose



I. Benedictiones et Praeconium

(The Blessings and Easter Song) [text ]

 

 

II. Promissio Baptismalis et Missa Solemnis

(The Baptismal Procession and the Mass of the Easter Vigil)  [text]

 


III. Missa in Dominica Resurrectionis

(The Easter Sunday Mass)    [text]

 

 

Choir of the Monks of the Benedictine Abbey of St. Martin, Beuron

Pater Dr. Maurus Pfaff, O.S.B.    

 

 

Downloads include texts and detailed contents listing

I/II
Recorded 3-5 September, 1957
Engineer: Harald Baudis

III
Recorded 27-28 June, 1953
Engineer: Werner Grimme

Issued as Archiv Produktion APM 14595/97 & ARC 3088/90
Producer: Dr. Fred Hamel    

 

 

 

Web page: PACO 056

 

 

Short Notes  

The Benedictine Monks of Beuron Archabbey in Germany produced, in the 1950s, some of the finest recordings of Gregorian Chant ever made, deriving from their own daily worship traditions.

 

Expertly recorded on location by DGG for their Archiv Produktion label, this release originally spanned three LPs, each presenting key services in the celebration of Easter and culminating in the full Mass for Easter Sunday.

 

These superbly atmospheric recordings (even more so with Ambient Stereo processing) feature the choir of 30 monks, led by Father Maurus Pfaff, together with the Abbey bells. There can be few finer examples of authentic Gregorian Chant.



 

Notes on the transfers:

The recordings presented here originally spanned three LPs, each one of which presented a complete service spread across its two sides. The editions used were published in Tornaci Nerviorum (Tournay, Belgium) in 1957 (parts 1 and 2) and 1908 (part 3). The transfers, from near-mint Archiv Produktion LPs, presented no difficulties, and I have retained the original equalisation in this remastering, concentrating instead on reducing light tape hiss and inevitable turntable rumble.

 

This is a release where the effect of Ambient Stereo processing is highly recommended: the choir of 30 monks plus Father Pfaff retain their central mono image within a stereo reverberant ambient space drawn from the recordings themselves, giving a real sense of space and air around the singers.

 

 

 

Reviews of the original LP releases 

"These two discs contain the major part of the Liturgy of Holy Saturday according to the reformed rites put into force by the general decree of the Congregation of Sacred Rites, Maxima Redemplionis Wostrae Mysleria (November 16th, 1955). The texts, as most readers likely to be interested in this recording will know, are to be found in the Holy Week Manual (Burns & Oates), but three hymns and a psalm with antiphon are sung by the Beuron monks choir that have no place in the Roman rite and are, presumably, peculiar to Benedictine congregations.

 

APM14104 has on it The Blessing of the New Fire (preceded by the hymn Inventor rutili), The Blessing of the Paschal Candle, The Solemn Procession, with the lighting of all the candles carried by those taking part in the ceremony, the singing by the deacon of the wonderful Easter Song- the Exultet-probab]y composed by St. Ambrose, bishop of Milan, in the fourth century, and another hymn, 0 res digna, Readings from the,Old Testament (formerly twelve, but now reduced to four: only one is included here, together with the Canticle -before called a Tract-following), The First Part of the Litanies, and the Blessing of the Baptismal Water.

 

APM 14105 has on it The Procession to the Font, with the beautiful canticle Sicut cervus desiderat, The Renewal of the Baptismal Promises, The Second Part of the Litanies, leading to The Mass of the Easter Vigil, begun at midnight (Kyrie eleison, Gloria- during which the bells of the monastery are rung-and Sanctus, and the various parts of the Proper). It should be noted that after the Epistle the choir alone sing the three-fold Alleluia-raised successively in pitch-and not, as in the Roman rite, the celebrant followed by the choir. After the Sanctus a bell is rung during the Elevation and the Mass proceeds from the doxology Per quem have omnia to Fax Domini, which is followed by an antiphon, Cito eunles dicile, and Psalm 117 and then by Lauds. After lie missa est the Easter processional hymn Salve festa dies is sung accompanied by a joyful peal of bells.

 

These discs include speech, intoning, and singing, all carried out extremely well and recorded with a good acoustic. D.G.G. are to be congratulated on their enterprise, which one hopes will be rewarded, in issuing so valuable an addition to the recorded repertory of Gregorian chant."

 

A. R. The Gramophone, July 1958 Review of Parts I and II

 

 

 

"This disc contains the whole of the Proper and Ordinary chants for Easter Sunday (the setting of the Ordinary is, of course, No. i (Lux et origo) in the Kyriale, with Credo No. r, information which, for sake of completeness, the card might have noted), the Epistle, Collect, Gospel, Preface, Paternoster, Postcommunion, and lie missa est. As in the Archive record of the Mass for All Souls (APM14002) the Monastery bells are rung after the Sanctus.

 

The acoustics and singing are again excellent, and this time the chief cantor does not anywhere go off pitch, though he shows some sign of strain in the versicle of the Gradual, Haec dies. This fine Gradual is, in fact, better sung on the DeccaSolesmes disc (LXT27o6), in which two cantors (at least) undertake it. As I noted before, the singing of the Beuron monks, virile in tone and prayerful in spirit, tends to be rather rigid and lacking in nuance as compared with that of the Solesmes monks, who have a more sensitive feeling for the contours of the phrases and a better "attack ". But one is very grateful for this complete presentation of the joyful Easter Sunday Mass to add to the growing collection of LP discs of Gregorian chant."

 

A. R. The Gramophone, March 1955 Review of Part I

 


 

  
MP3 Sample - Hymnus Paschalis: Salve festa dies
Listen

Download purchase links:
Ambient Stereo MP3
Mono 16-bit FLAC
Ambient Stereo 16-bit FLAC
Ambient Stereo 24-bit FLAC

CD purchase links and all other information:
PACO 056 -  webpage at Pristine Classical


 
PASC284

MEWTON-WOOD

plays Stravinsky & Chopin concertos



Producer and Audio Restoration Engineer:  Andrew Rose  


 

STRAVINSKY   

Concerto for Piano & Wind Instruments  [notes] 

Netherlands Philharmonic Orchestra Goehr

recorded 1952



CHOPIN

Piano Concerto No. 2 in F minor, Op. 21  [notes/score]

Zurich Radio Orchestra Goehr

recorded 1948

 

 

Noel Mewton-Wood   piano

 

 

FLAC downloads include PDF score of Chopin Piano Concerto No. 2   

 

 

 

 

Web page: PASC 284

 

Short Notes  

"...surely the finest performance the work ever received. This particular recording has been on my longer desert island list since it was released..." - Paul Shoemaker, MusicWeb International

 

Noel Mewton-Wood's tragic death at his own hands in December 1953 deprived the world of what had already been widely acknowledged as a great musical talent.

 

Pristine Classical has already presented a great proportion of Mewton-Wood's recordings, and we round off our concerto series this week with the superb Stravinsky and the well-loved Chopin Second. Despite some less-than-ideal sonics, you'll want to hear these for Mewton-Wood's superlative performances at the keyboard.




Recording Notes

Although we are lucky to have a handful of recordings which demonstrate the wonderful pianism of Noel Mewton-Wood, it is perhaps to be regretted that these are largely drawn from the LPs made by the Musical Masterpiece Society and its various offshoots. Often, particularly in the early days, rather poorly recorded, the company also kept costs down by simplifying cover designs and information (or lack of it) as well as cheaply pressing lightweight ten inch vinyl discs.

 

The fact that these two recordings also span the often 'difficult' years as new tape technology replaced established 78rpm disc-to-disc recording methods has created extra work for the modern restorer. Both recordings are lacking in the extreme top end, and the orchestral tone at the beginning of the Chopin leaves a great deal to be desired. Happily this is to a degree rectified as the work progresses, and would have been passable for 78rpm release. Both recordings suffer from a light amount of peak distortion, but this has generally been rendered as unobtrusive as possible. What does shine in both of these recordings is the superb piano playing and generally fine piano tone of Mewton-Wood, for which we can be most grateful!

 

 

Review of previous issue, MusicWeb International

 

"...surely the finest performance the work ever received. This particular recording has been on my longer desert island list since it was released.

 

The music of Stravinsky contains many ironies-ironies of harmony, of rhythm, and, to credit Bernstein, even ironies of style and mood. Stravinsky had had many bad experiences with performers "interpreting" his music, the result of which being that one or more of the ironies would be resolved and the complexity of the work consequently reduced. Just after this recording, he began issuing firm embargos against any "interpretation" loudly criticizing any performance that went beyond playing the notes exactly at the correct tempo and volume. Any performer who attempted to add anything to a Stravinky performance was attached for making errors, and hence Stravinsky performances fell into a frozen routine, and have all sounded alike.

 

But not this one. Mewton-Wood plays parts of this music as if he's really having fun, but not so much that the ironic solemnity of other parts of the music is in any way compromised. This extremely difficult balance is hereby brilliantly achieved; whether Stravinsky appreciated it or not, I have no word. But for my money this is one of the half dozen truly great Stravinsky recordings of the century and a must for any Stravinsky collector."

 

   

 

 
MP3 Sample - Stravinsky, 1st movement
Listen

Download purchase links:
Ambient Stereo MP3
Mono 16-bit FLAC
Ambient Stereo 16-bit FLAC
Ambient Stereo 24-bit FLAC

CD purchase links and all other information:
PASC 284 -  webpage at Pristine Classical


Adrian Aeschbacher
Adrian Aeschbacher
PADA Exclusives
Streamed MP3s you can also download
 

  

FINE ARTS WIND PLAYERS  

LEONA LURIE  

 

POULENC

Sextet for Wind Quintet and Piano, FP100     

 

Fine Arts Wind Players:

Haaken Berg
flute
Mitchell Lurie
clarinet
Alexandre Duvoir
oboe
Sinclair Lott french
horn

Leona Laurie
piano

Recorded 1955
Transfer from Capitol P8258

  

 

This transfer is presented with Ambient Stereo remastering by Dr. John Duffy.

 

Over 400 PADA Exclusives recordings are available for high-quality streamed listening and free 224kbps MP3 download to all subscribers. PADA Exclusives are not available on CD and are additional to our main catalogue. 

 


Subscribe to PADA Subscriptions start from €1 per week for PADA Exclusives only listening and download access. A full subscription to PADA Premium gets you all this plus unlimited streamed listening access to all Pristine Classical recordings for just €10 per month, with a free 1 week introductory trial.