LATEST REVIEWS
| MusicWeb International February 2011 By Jonathan Woolf
"This release of rare recordings goes a long way to cementing the Sammons discography" 
| |
When I was 22 I walked into a long extinct record shop in Chancery Lane and bought an LP of Elgar's Violin Concerto. I had liked the Cello Concerto - the Anthony Pini recording with van Beinum, with its cover photograph of Worcester Cathedral - but found the composer's recording with Menuhin strangely stodgy. I wanted to try again. This time, then, fresh from Chancery Lane, I tried Albert Sammons's recording with Henry Wood. This time I was transfixed. This time it made sense.
I've changed my mind since about Menuhin's recording, which I greatly admire, but the sense of rapture evoked by Sammons has never left me. I began a quest to find more recordings by him. There was the World Records Delius Concerto, and I found the Sinfonia Concertante on an old LP devoted to Lionel Tertis. But there wasn't much else, until the gatefold double of Elgar's chamber music which contained the Violin Sonata recording with William Murdoch. So I looked further afield. I put an advertisement in a music magazine and people wrote to me-the days were pre-CD, pre-internet-and I went to their houses and bought 78s of Sammons, and they saw a young chap starting out, and looked kindly on me. They played discs for me, showed me how to care for records and how to play them properly. They were glad I was collecting, when they had themselves begun that slow winding down, to which all collectors must succumb. And I went to Betterton Street in London, one of the last shops with 78s on its racks, and made the pilgrimage to Stockport, to The 78 Record Exchange, where, contrary to the warnings of others, I breached the portals and was allowed upstairs, where vast racks of 78s stretched from side to side, unimaginably vast. The owners sat behind their counter, polishing shellac with chamois leather. I bid on auction catalogues: I attended record fairs: I scoured antiques shops.
And the more I collected, the more I wanted to collect, to account for the fault of history in disregarding musicians such as Sammons. In time, because they were not much valued, and were numerous, I'd collected almost all his recordings. And then I wrote to his surviving family, to one of his daughters, Peggy, and also to Lionel Hill who'd married another daughter, Betty, who may still be alive. And in time I managed to acquire some letters, and programmes and, later, when Peggy Boswell-Cuming died, I was able to acquire more things, including recordings and more letters. This is how most things go, I suppose, increasing in intensity and breadth, if sufficiently concentrated in focus. And it struck me how fragile these things are; a letter that Ysa˙e wrote to Sammons in 1915 was among the things I found when I opened the plastic bag containing the mementos Sammons had bequeathed his daughter. How easily might it have been destroyed. If you collect, you shake a fist at destruction; you acquire to deny Time its potency. You hoard to preserve. You can go mad too, as we know. But better a collector than the skip.
Some collectors refuse access. Many others prove amazingly generous. One such is Paul Steinson, whom I know, and who has provided these copies for Pristine Audio. One is the Kreutzer Sonata, recorded in December 1926 at the Wigmore Hall, and which saw long service. It was originally released by Columbia on L1884-88 but a year later withdrawn in favour of 9352-56. It remained in print in total for 13 years. The other is the Fauré sonata in A. This is very different. It was recorded in November 1937 at Abbey Road on HMV's private JG label. Some may know the Maggie Teyte recordings on this label, which do turn up quite regularly. But I have never seen this Fauré offered on a record list in 25 years. It belonged to the violinist himself and was part of his daughter's collection. I'm fortunate enough to have seen it, in its album, with its appealing yellow labels, and have had a tape copy for a number of years. Pristine Audio's Andrew Rose speculates that it might be the only set in existence. It's possible, I suppose, but the BBC certainly had a set, though I don't know if they've retained it. And others must surely have been bought.
The Kreutzer was re-released on LP by Pearl when they coupled it with the Concerto played by Isolde Menges, another strong candidate for a new transfer. I wouldn't wish to quibble too much with the CD cover's use of the word 'rare' in relation to this disc. These things are hooks for the purchaser. It's rare inasmuch as it's been transferred only once before, but it's not especially rare as a 78 set. It was issued in America and also - the best pressing in my experience - in Australia. Sammons had performed the sonata with Vassily Safonov (in 1915) as well as his regular sonata partner William Murdoch. He was later to perform it many times with such as Gerald Moore, Geoffrey Tankard, Ernest Lush, Leslie Heward, Mark Hambourg, and Frederic Lamond. The notes refer to this recording as 'truncated' but it's necessary to amplify or qualify that. The second part of the first and second variations in the second movement is cut, as is the repeat of the first part of the finale.
By now a partnership of over a decade's standing, Sammons and Murdoch play with rock solid ensemble and powerful temperament. This is a speedy, intensely purposeful performance, replete with drama and oases of calm, and wit. The muscular, masculine bowing produces the fabled big tone but Sammons can, despite his reputation, fine down the tone when necessary. His trills are tight, his portamenti full of expressive intensity, pathos and significance. His pizzicatos ring out. The two musicians locate great sentiment but also nobility in the variations of the second movement. The tempi are never allowed to drag - that was never Sammons's way - and there is always sufficient colour and texture to keep things alive. The finale meanwhile is buoyant and yet flexible. There are moments, perhaps, but only in passing, when there is an insistence to the violinist's tone, but it is dwarfed by the rapt sense of introspection and, once again, of pathos, toward the end of the sonata.
Thibaud and Cortot had recorded the Fauré sonata back in 1927. Another French pairing, Denise Soriano and Magda Tagliafero, recorded their beautiful version in 1934, whilst Heifetz and Emanuel Bay recorded their set in 1936. Quite what prompted the Sammons performance, with pianist Edie Miller, is something of a mystery. He was certainly attuned to the Gallic muse, though this is not especially appreciated now. He had given possibly the earliest performance of the Debussy Violin Sonata in England, and one of the earliest anywhere. He'd performed at the memorial concert for Fauré in 1924. He'd undoubtedly have encountered the music when Thibaud and Cortot and other colleagues enjoyed after-hours music-making at Muriel Draper's house in Fulham, in London, just before the First War. The basement was a music room. When I went searching for the house I found it had gone, replaced by flats. Not much is known of Edie Miller though she played at the National Gallery Concerts during the Second World War. She also accompanied Sammons in a Decca-pressed private recording of Turina's First Sonata, so clearly there was a deal of such recording going on at the time, possibly financed by others, as Sammons would have been very unlikely to have subsidised the venture himself. There would have been no point.
Critics always pointed to Sammons's singing tone as a characteristic feature of his playing and musicianship. This is a rather woolly word when applied to string playing. But one does appreciate the superb legato, the variegation of colour, the highly expressive portamenti, the sense of directional tension sustained by the violinist, the elasticity of his phrasing within a regular pulse, and the perfectly graded approach to the climax of the first movement, where the sense of assertive declamation is marvellous. His sense of phrasing allows the slow movement to blossom uncontaminated by sentimentality, and though there are maybe the briefest moments of wavering intonation, the playing is marvellously communicative, honest, direct and unselfconscious. The B section of the scherzo is played with enormous charm whilst the outer sections are boldly bowed. And the finale is bracing, exciting and truly involving. Miller is a decent ally but obviously not in Sammons's league. It would have been altogether better for Kathleen Long, a French music and specifically Fauré specialist, to have accompanied, but that was clearly not possible.
As to the transfer questions, firstly, I am very glad that surface noise has been retained between tracks. Second, side joins are imperceptible. Third, surface scratch has been kept to a bare minimum. Now a few words about the XR process. I have, as noted, heard the Fauré set. The scratch was quite pronounced. I have also heard an internet download (now withdrawn) which was made available for a time. XR has boosted response and my distinct impression is that the process has slightly realigned the violin spectrum. Sammons was occasionally covered by Miller and that balance has been retrospectively rectified to a large extent. Things are more extreme in respect of the Kreutzer. Columbia's engineers seemed to struggle on some of their location recordings, and the results in the Wigmore Hall in these early microphone days were somewhat erratic. Whichever pressing I listen to, I always find this a distant affair. To this extent the XR work has brought the sound stage very much into the foreground, and the dynamic variations register in a pronounced way. This is especially true of the pizzicatos, for instance. There is considerable depth here, and I find that the process has wrought considerable changes in spatial perspective. I'm sure some will not welcome this approach but, on this occasion, I must say that I do.
There is much to do with Sammons's recorded legacy. I see that more discs from this source are on their way, namely the Archduke Trio and the Mendelssohn op.66 trio, both of which have already been transferred to CD by other labels. But record companies can only put out material that comes into their possession or is made available to them. Generous collectors are needed to enrich the living current of our lives. So may I make an appeal, should it still exist (and it was still around in the 1960s), for someone to unearth the set of the unpublished 1927 Beethoven concerto with either, and I've seen both names mentioned, Henry Wood or Hamilton Harty. Then we must have the Turina sonata alluded to above; the only set I've seen on a list was sold a few years ago for $900. I know; I was the underbidder (but that was when I had some disposable income). Grieg's Sonata No.2 is magnificent, especially in the American pressing, so too the Devil's Trill sonata and Vitali Chaconne. I would also urge a 'Decca Recordings' release. This would include the remake of the Mendelssohn trio, with Murdoch once again, but this time with Cedric Sharpe in place of Lionel Tertis, hence an untranscribed recording. It would be coupled with the delightful morceaux albums that each man recorded, each of five 10-inch discs. There is also a broadcast performance of Stanley Wilson's Double Concerto with Bernard Shore, the violist, recorded off-air in 1937. I've heard a copy and whilst I don't know the whereabouts of the original, it would be marvellous to track it down. Ruby Davy, Australia's first woman Doctor of Music, also recorded privately on Decca with Sammons. We know she returned to Australia in the early days of the Second World War with the recordings, but nothing has been heard of them since.
Since the days when I walked into the record shop in Chancery Lane, things have changed. Generous-minded people freely made time to help me but, even so, I should not have thought it possible to have Sammons's unreleased 1929 recording of Delius's First Sonata made available. Where had it been? Who had kept it? And now we have all Sammons's recordings with Tertis on Vocalion and Columbia on CD, and other things too. Things are immeasurably better now, and can only get better.
This release goes a long way to cementing the Sammons discography. In giving us the Fauré sonata, in so very rare a recording, we are given a glimpse of a Sammons that most people have never encountered. He, for whom recording was often something of a trial, would be astonished by releases such as this; astonished but, I like to think, glad.
Items reviewed:
PACM072 Sammons
|
|
|
YouCONTENTS
| |
Editorial Joy of XMBC - Win a download! Toscanini His first NBC SO concert - complete
Katin Plays Tchaikovsky in stereo Decca recordings
PADA W. H. Squire with Draper and Harty play Brahms
|
Editorial - Joy of XMBC - and our ongoing competition! Something I regularly get asked about is how our downloads might work with such and such a piece of gadgetry, or what brand or model of some kind of device I'd recommend. From PC speakers to hard-drive players to portable iPods and similar, the questions come in quite regularly, and I suspect I have disappointed a number of people with my lack of knowledge. The PC speakers one is pretty easy to brush off - my PC speakers are ex-BBC Rogers LS5/8 studio monitors, each with its dedicated BBC-modified Quad power amp, and each the size of a small washing machine. Not only are they hard to come by, they're also not really ideal for most PC desks. As for the iPod, well I do own one - though as a non-commuter it took me a while to get around to it and I don't really use it much. It came in handy in the car last weekend for a six-hour drive with my son to Barcelona to watch this year's Formula One motor racing pre-season testing, but it was a rare outing I have to admit. Where I can offer some real recommendation and advice is with the software we suggest online for audio and video replay: XBMC. I've had some feedback on this subject before, and it suggests people have struggled and, in some cases, given up with it, which is a shame as I've not seen anything else with quite the scope as an all-round system for a home entertainment centre based around a computer for replay. One of the first things that attracted me to XBMC was its ability to play just about anything and everything, video or audio, I asked it to. A lot of media players get very fussy about file formats and simply refuse to recognise some of the most popular types of media - FLAC being the obvious example here when trying to persuade iTunes or Windows Media Player to co-operate with it. There are workarounds for both - we've got help files which show you how - or you can spend a little time converting from FLAC to something else, but for me I'd rather use a player which will play whatever I ask it to, without me having to give it a helping hand. Likewise the multitude of video formats. Video has always (as far as I can see) been a minefield of competing formats. When I worked at the BBC, a call for archive audio from a TV tape often opened up a whole can of worms as one scoured the building for a machine which would play whatever format was being used for a few months in 1997 before being superseded by something newer and (usually) smaller. The software formats seem an equally bewildering collection of incompatible file types, some of which contain further, even more diverse file types. I'm so glad I don't work with video every day! The point is, XBMC seems to play them all. If something new comes along, the software writers take a look at it, try and figure out how it works, and write a decoder for it to be incorporated into XBMC. Unless you are a programmer or want to look behind the scenes at the development of the software (XBMC is open source and collaborative, so this is entirely possible if you know what they're talking about) all this is transparent to the end user. I just tell it to play movie X or album Y and it gets on with it. I suspect the biggest problem with XBMC derives from precisely its greatest strength: as a free, open source project, there's no one person managing it, and no commercial imperative to come up with a simple, coherent beginner's guide or operating manual. It seems people are too busy improving it to be too fussed about telling us how it works in a language we can understand. So I'll have a go - by relating how it works for me (there's also a quick tutorial on our website here). First of all, I have XBMC installed on a small PC in my living room. The PC runs Windows 7 and has just enough power inside it to play back full HD movies smoothly. It connects to my TV via a digital HDMI cable. I have an external E-MU USB0202 digital to analogue converter to improve the sound quality, and this hooks directly into my hi-fi. The PC links wirelessly to audio and video servers which hold all the data for movies and music. XBMC is designed to be operated from a distance. The on-screen writing is big, which means that when you see it on a TV from the other side of the room you can read it clearly and easily, unlike iTunes, Windows Media Player, and many other standard computer replay systems designed for close-range desktop use. It is also what's called "skinnable", which means the entire look and feel of XBMC can be modified using downloadable "skins". With the latest release of XBMC this became a very simple operation - skins appear in a section of System Add-Ons. You are offered a list of skins with brief descriptions and can select and download any that takes your fancy. Those you have downloaded are automatically installed and can then be selected and utilised from the Appearance section. I tried a number and ultimately decided that "Transparency" was the most intuitive and user-friendly of the lot - certainly more so than the basic skin supplied with XBMC. Once you have a look and feel that you like and makes sense to you, it's time to get your music on board. XBMC doesn't presume to know where all your music and video files are, or even necessarily what they are, so you're going to have to tell it where to look and what to expect. It operates either in a file mode or a library mode - the former allows you to browse through folders on your hard drives, the latter works like a database of your recordings. You can tell XBMC where your music recordings are in file mode, then ask it to scan them into the library. Once these files are saved by XBMC in its database you can use the library mode to browse or search recordings by name, artist, genre, year and so on. You can compile playlists or ask for random selections, and the system is flexible and powerful. As already mentioned, XBMC doesn't care whether you're asking it to play lowest-quality MP3s or highest quality 24-bit FLACs - it's just about the most comprehensive player there is, even seamlessly handling cue sheets with a variety of formats. What's more, when it's scanning your music folders it can also download artwork, biographies and album information relating to recordings in your collection, all of which potentially builds up to a useful collection of "sleevenotes" readily accessible at replay. Likewise for movie playback: XBMC distinguishes in its video library categories between films, TV shows and music videos and, as with music, you can tell it what type of video files are in any particular location - it makes sense to have a master folder of movies, a master folder of TV shows and so on. Film artwork, information about actors, directors, genre, TV episodes and so on can be automatically downloaded, together with plotlines and viewer ratings. It'll also keep tabs on what you've already watched, and allows you to pick up where you left off if you don't finish a film. If XBMC was a commercial venture it probably would come with a nice thick instruction book which would give you step by step instructions on how to do all this, as well as showing you how to hook it into YouTube for video replay, find the weather forecast for your area, and no doubt describe features I still have yet to discover. Unfortunately XBMC currently requires more of a DIY approach, though it has to be said that once you've grasped the basics it does follow a pretty straightforward logic and is quite easy to get to grips with. There is online help at the XBMC website (xbmc.org) as well as a very active forum, though both can seem rather too designed for geeks and technophiles at times, and there are specific sections for Windows, Mac, Linux and other systems. By being a non-commercial venture XBMC is being rolled out and improved (or worked on) on a daily basis, which you can follow if you wish. You can communicate directly with those who are making it happen and, just possibly, offer an idea that will be included in the software or skin - possibly within days. Full releases tend to happen when they really are ready, not when the company accountant, the PR team and the advertising schedule says they have to be ready, and it seems there's a lot of goodwill between both writers and users. But at the end of the day it comes back to one simple task that it does well where others stumble and fall - XBMC comprehensively organises, catalogues and plays all my music files and all my video files whilst looking good on my TV screen in my living room. Which seems a simple thing to ask for - but it doesn't seem to have much in the way of competition... "Whoops - you did it again" - Download competition  | | The cover picture which should have appeared last week | You know, I was sure there were no errors in last week's e-mail and that the competition would be a damp squib on week one. Naturally the big mistake was staring me in the face - just inches below this text was the wrong artwork for Heifetz's Bach! Congratulations to Prof. Patrick Turner who was the first of many to e-mail me.Here's a reminder of how this works: if you spot a glaring error in one of these newsletters (spelling mistakes excluded) - and furthermore, if you're the first to e-mail me and tell me about it - I'll send you a free download of your choice. Just send an e-mail with the title " Whoops - you did it again" to me at andrew@pristineaudio.com detailing the slip up, and the first e-mail to arrive pointing out any specific error will receive the download of your choice. Let me know what download you want in your e-mail and if you're the first you'll get it in your in-box within a few days. (NB. The word "whoops" must be in the e-mail title or it won't be registered as an entry.) I should point out again that I never intend to put any errors into this or any other e-mail deliberately - but that won't mean they're not there! Good hunting - naturally there are no mistakes this week... Andrew Rose, February 25th, 2011P.S. My apologies for two instances of this e-mail - and yes, we do have a winner for the competition this week already!
|
TOSCANINI NBC Early Years: Concert No. 1 Producer and Audio Restoration Engineer: Andrew Rose
VIVALDI Concerto Grosso in D minor, Op. 11 No. 3 [notes / score] Mischa Mischakoff, violin Edwin Bachman, violin Oswaldo Mizuki, cello
MOZART
Symphony No. 40 in C minor, K550 [notes / score]
BRAHMS
Symphony No. 1 in C minor, Op. 68 [notes / score] Full concert programme as broadcast, 25th December 1937 from Broadcast from Studio 8H, NBC Radio City, New York Introduced by Howard Claney
Downloads include full scores of each work NBC Symphony Orchestra conductor Arturo Toscanini Web page: PASC 275 Short Notes Thus began one of the great musical partnerships of the 20th Century: Arturo Toscanini and the orchestra created for him by the National Broadcasting Company. Featuring their first broadcast together in its entirety, live from Studio 8H, NBC Radio City, New York, now in much improved XR remastered sound, this is truly a moment of history in the making. Originally engaged for 10 concerts, Toscanini was still conducting his NBC Symphony Orchestra nearly two decades later, and between them they left a legacy of broadcasts and studio recordings which are still regarded as some of the greatest ever made. Hear now how it all began - in superb fashion - back on Christmas Day, 1937.
Notes on the transfers: This first ever broadcast by Toscanini and the orchestra created for him by NBC radio is presented here in its entirety, including all preserved applause and announcements. This decision was made both on historic grounds and also because the musical content alone was slightly too long for a single CD issue. Sonically the concert is reasonably well preserved for a broadcast of its vintage, and though I have had to battle for long sections an almost ever-present disc surface noise, it is a battle that has largely been won. As well as a full XR remastering filling out the original, highly constricted sound considerably, I also took the opportunity to soften the hard 8H acoustic with a touch of convolution reverberation, using the perhaps appropriate acoustic one finds in the concert hall at La Scala, Milan. Reviews: "The presentation of senior Toscanini and a superlative orchestra as its contribution to the world on Christmas night was a high pinnacle for radio for which the National Broadcasting Company is entitled to handsome appreciation. Musically it was an even of the most obvious importance. The departmental specialists are appraising its technical merits and magnitudes in expert terms, but it also is a milestone in the radio's social development because here a broadcasting network seized on the thing it could do best and proceeded to do it in the finest and most dignified and useful way... The performance stands for a thousand irritations of the radio for which it atones, and the public today can look forward gratefully to nine further Toscanini concerts in this great series." Editorial, The New York Telegram, December 1937 "When Toscanini and his magnificent National Broadcasting Company Orchestra finished the concluding strains of the Brahms First on Saturday night, the hearts of the music critics present in the audience were very full indeed. The reviews the next morning has the hushed tones of those who had seen the corner of the veil which hides the central mystery of music lifted. It was, several of them said, the experience of a lifetime. So it was, and what interests us is that this experience of a lifetime was shared by at least 20 million persons in America and many millions abroad. What interests us is that the Toscanini broadcast had been looked forward to for a good eight months, and it was the biggest item of news Saturday night and outweighed our last note to Japan in general conversation, that it brought listeners to the loudspeaker who had never willingly tuned into a symphony before, that the country is still talking about it. But Toscanini has been a conductor for fifty years. There is therefore something odd and exciting in this rediscovery of something we have had for a long time. Suddenly a nation, pictured in the sniffy periodicals as clustered about the loudspeaker to hear 'The Moon Come Over The Mountain' gathers to hear Mozart and Brahms and to talk about it. Is this one of those moments of realisation that make artistic history? One of those pivotal points of popularisation? One of those accidents of publicity that may have permanent result? We think so, somehow. The National Broadcasting Company may have built better than it knew." Editorial, The New York Evening Post, December 1937 A musician's perspective: "I was a violinist in that orchestra, and we were awaiting the first appearance of our conductor. There was no audience. The men, instruments in hand, sat nervously rigid, scarcely breathing. Suddenly, from a door on the right side of the stage, a small, solidly built man emerged. Immediately discernible were the crowning white hair and impassive, squat, high-cheekboned mustached face. He was dressed in a severely eut black alpaca jacket, with a high clerical collar, formal striped trousers, and pointed, slipperlike shoes. In his hand he carried a baton. In awed stillness we watched covertly as he walked up the few steps leading to the stage.
As he stepped up to the podium, by prearranged signal, we all rose, like puppets suddenly propelled to life by a pent-up tension. We had been warned in advance not to make any vocal demonstration and we stood silent, eagerly and anxiously staring.
He looked around, apparently bewildered by our unexpected action, and gestured a faint greeting with both arms, a mechanical smile lighting his pale face for an instant. Somewhat embarrassed, we sat down again. Then, in a rough hoarse voice he called out, "Brahms!" He looked at us piercingly for the briefest moment, then raised his arms. In one smashing stroke, the baton came down. A vibrant sound suddenly gushed forth from the tense players like blood from an artery.
With each heart-pounding timpani stroke in the opening bars of the Brahms First Symphony his baton beat became more powerfully insistent, his shoulders more strained and hunched as though buffeting a giant wind. His outstretched left arm spasmodically flailed the air, the cupped fingers pleading like a beseeching beggar. His face reddened, his muscles tightened, eyes and eyebrows constantly moving. As we in the violin section tore with our bows against our strings, I felt I was being sucked into a roaring maelstrom of sound-every bit of strength and skill called upon and strained into being. Bits of breath, muscle, and blood, never before used, were being drained from me. Like ships torn from their mooring in a stormy ocean, we bobbed and tossed, responding to these earnest, importuning gestures. With what a fierce new joy we played!
Playing with Toscanini was a musical rebirth. The clarity, intensity, and honesty of his musical vision-his own torment-was like a cleansing baptismal pool. Caught up in his force, your own indifference was washed away. You were not just a player, another musician, but an artist once more searching for long forgotten ideals and truths. You were curiously alive, and there was a purpose and self-fulfillment in your work. It was not a job, it was a calling." From "This Was Toscanini" by Samuel Antek & Robert Hupka (Vanguard, 1963) MP3 Sample - Brahms, 3rd movement ListenDownload purchase links: Ambient Stereo MP3mono 16-bit FLACAmbient Stereo 16-bit FLAC Ambient Stereo 24-bit FLACCD purchase links and all other information: PASC 275 - webpage at Pristine Classical
|
PETER KATIN plays TchaikovskyProducer and Audio Restoration Engineer: Andrew Rose TCHAIKOVSKY Piano Concerto No. 1 in B flat minor, Op. 23 [notes/score]London Symphony Orchestra* conducted by Edric Cundell Recording producer: Erik Smith Recording Engineer: Alan Reeve Recorded 11 May, 1959 Kingsway Hall, London *Although originally attributed to the New Symphony Orchestra of London in its US release, this recording was later listed by Decca as being by the London Symphony Orchestra TCHAIKOVSKY Concert Fantasia in G major, Op. 56 [notes/score]London Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Sir Adrian Boult Recording producer: Ray Minshull Recording Engineer: Alan Reeve Recorded 17-19 February, 1958 Kingsway Hall, London Transfers from Decca LP SPA168 Peter Katin, piano Web page: PASC 276 Short Notes We continue our short series of Peter Katin's stereo recordings from the late 1950s for Decca with this all-Tchaikovsky set. The main feature is of course his brilliant rendition of Tchaikovsky's Piano Concerto No. 1, under the baton of the English composer and conductor Edric Cundell, coming to the end of a lengthy and distinguished musical career. This is coupled with the Concert Fantasia - at the time a relatively little-known and rarely heard piece - this time under the expert baton of Sir Adrian Boult. Both recordings were benchmarks for high quality and high fidelity sound in their day, and both stand up brilliantly to the test of time over fifty years later. This is analogue recording - and virtuoso piano playing - at its finest!
Recording Notes
This, the second in our series of stereo concerto recordings made in the late 1950s by Peter Katin for Decca and its subsidiaries, brings together his two orchestral Tchaikovsky releases. The Concert Fantasia derived from the same sessions with Boult which produced the Rachmaninov Concerto No. 1 in February 1958, and were issued in mono and stereo both in the UK and the USA at around the same time. The Concerto No. 1 however was initially destined only for the American market - credited originally to the New Symphony Orchestra of London, its UK reissue in the early 1970s gave the London Symphony as the orchestra, though it does not appear in the official discography of the orchestra. It is the only recording in the Decca catalogue credited to English composer and conductor Edric Cundell (1893-1961), whose name was mis-spelt "Kundell" on both Decca and Olympia re-issues, though the original Richmond issues were correct in this matter.
Spellings and questions over orchestras aside, these are both excellent recordings and, taken from near-mint 1970s Decca pressings, were very straightforward to transfer and restore barring a curious low-frequency tone which appeared intermittently in the Concert Fantasia. Indeed it is fair to say this is among the least interventionist remasters ever to appear on the Pristine label. MP3 Sample - Piano Concerto, 3rd movement ListenDownload purchase links: Stereo MP3Stereo 16-bit FLACStereo 24-bit FLACCD purchase links and all other information: PASC 276 - webpage at Pristine Classical
|
PADA Exclusives Streamed MP3s you can also download
W. H. SQUIRE
with H P Draper & Hamilton Harty
BRAHMS
Trio for Clarinet, Cello & Piano, Op. 114
W. H. Squire, cello H. P. Draper, clarinet Hamilton Harty, piano
Recorded 21 November 1924 Issued as UK Columbia 78s, Cat Nos. L1609/11 Matrix Nos. AX692/7
New 78rpm transfers by Dr. John Duffy
This transfer is presented with Ambient Stereo remastering by Dr. John Duffy.
Over 400 PADA Exclusives recordings are available for high-quality streamed listening and free 224kbps MP3 download to all subscribers. PADA Exclusives are not available on CD and are additional our main catalogue.
Subscriptions start from €1 per week for PADA Exclusives only listening and download access. A full subscription to PADA Premium gets you all this plus unlimited streamed listening access to all Pristine Classical recordings for just €10 per month, with a free 1 week introductory trial.
|
|