NEPTA SPEAKER SERIES Minutes

SPEAKER: DR. NELITA TRUE  

Date of Meeting: March 19, 2012

Submitted by Linda G. Vieira  

MEMORIZATION and BEETHOVEN'S SONATA'S Op. 10, No. 2 and Op.14, No 1.

Dr. True is an internationally known performer, teacher and adjudicator and is currently Professor of Piano at the Eastman School of Music. Due to a computer glitch, Dr. True was not able to present her slide show as planned on three Beethoven Sonatas. Consequently, her presentation had two parts: memorization and Beethoven's Sonata Op. 10, No. 2 and Op.14, No 1.

She began her talk with techniques she uses in her own practicing and with her students to help memorize music reliably. All performers have a fear of forgetting but it can often become a self-fulfilling prophecy. To reduce the probability of memory slips, a performer should be prepared with an avenue of escape and be able to present an illusion of continuum if a memory slip does occur. She gives pep talks to students and recommended The Inner Game of Music by Barry Green.   

Why memorize music, other than continuing the tradition started by Clara Schumann and Franz Liszt? Dr. True pointed out several reasons:  

 

* It helps us develop a greater connection with the music   

 * There can be more flexibility in playing   

* A performer can shift the focus from themselves to the music   

There are four facets of memorizing which should include not just the notes and rhythm but everything on the page: dynamics, phrasing etc.  

 

1. Tactile memory
This is based on accuracy, slow practice and consistent fingering. Knowing and practicing scales and arpeggios in various ways including 3rds, 6ths and 10ths put those patterns in the fingers. Although this way of memorizing is the one most students rely on, it is not reliable by itself.  

 

2. Visual memory

This involves seeing the music as a blueprint in the mind's eye. Some people can also visualize patterns on the keyboard. Even after a piece is memorized, one should practice with the music sometime to insure that details are not forgotten or overlooked.  

 

3. Analysis
This is the most reliable way to memorize because it helps us understand and make a connection to the music. Analyze the keys, melody, rhythm, dynamics, harmony,cadences. The more theory,the better!  

 

4. Aural memory
This controls all the other facets but it is not reliable if the other three facets are not in place. How to get students to listen? Remind them to listen! Guide them to listen for patterns (e.g. the order of the notes: are they the same notes in a different configuration?) and to recognize chords and intervals.  

 

Dr. True said it was possible to memorize away from the keyboard but she does not recommend it because it takes so much time and there is no tactile aspect to memorizing this way.  

 

Since the human mind can only memorize five to seven patterns at a time, Dr. True suggested working with small sections and often has her students memorize music backwards.  

 

Start with the last phrase and look at:

  • how many voices, how do they move: parallel or contrary
  • does the melody move in steps, skips, are there scale passages
  • are there chords and what kind
  • how do the two hands relate

Then play at a slow tempo without stopping or breaking the pulse ten times with the music. Students often practice stopping which makes them more likely to stop in a performance because that is what they practiced! The next day, review the previous day's section. Then do the same process as above with the next to the last phrase. Then put it together with the last phrase. She noted that this process can be done forward but feels it is more effective if done from the end of a piece since the beginning is often practiced more by students.

To reinforce memory, review the previous day's work and also practice slowly (which forces one to focus on details) and in different rhythms and tempos, thinking of the music away from the piano (especially right before going to bed since you establish what you learn during REM sleep), playing 2 measures then thinking two measures, playing on the fall board are some helpful ways to review. Try to predict where a memory slip may occur. Pay special attention to the differences in the exposition and recapitulation. Playing for others is important; Dr. True has students overlap so they can play for each other.    

In starting a new piece, Dr. True has the student look at many aspects that tell you a lot about the style and character of the music:

  • the loudest and softest parts and the dynamic outline
  • how dense the music is, how many voices
  • tessitura of the piece, where it played on the piano, what is the range
  • harmonies especially augmented 6ths or Neapolitan 6ths
  • harmonic rhythm which helps determine the tempo
  • melody e.g. stepwise or active in changing direction (the flexion

    count is how many times the melody changes direction)

  • rhythm...is there a lot of variety or is it similar
  • melodic and/or rhythmic motifs, how many times do they occur *

    Dr. True recommended Guidelines for Style Analysis by Jan La Rue

    http://www.amazon.com/Guidelines-Style-Analysis-Jan- Rue/dp/0393099466

    Although Dr. True does not teach beginners (she tried it for one summer in college but found it did not suit her), she has a great respect for teachers who do and feels some of her suggestions may work with beginners.  Editor's note: I use many of these ideas with beginners, even young children and they work well (even memorizing backward!)  

On to Beethoven Sonatas!

According to Dr. True, Op. 10, No. 2 is one of the funniest pieces Beethoven wrote. The first movement is light hearted and rising thirds are the predominant theme (have students find all of them). He surprises us by going to the "wrong" key in a different register. In measures 136-137, the change of character and color within is a phrase is unique. Beethoven uses rests to create drama as is measures 44 -46. "Nothing is more dramatic in music that silence."   

 

Great composers such as Beethoven avoid using Alberti bass: instead, he uses permutations of the Alberti bass pattern. Dr. True always refers to the fingering in Schnabel editions. Although they seem awkward at first, the fingerings make the pianist play more expressively.   

  

She describes the Development Section as a battlefield with both sides agreeing on a key at the end. There is a sequence that goes on and on; it shouldn't be interesting since it is so repetitive but it is!   

The second movement, Allegretto, is a haunting movement that uses different registers to create a variety of atmospheres: dark with open octaves followed by a wandering section starting in measure 10 that brightens in a higher register, then to a solemn section staring in measure 39. To help students play this piece well, Dr. True stressed the importance of having students listen to orchestral music and imagine what instrument would be playing a particular section and/or voice.   

Beethoven's Op. 14, No. 1 is economical in the material that he uses: rising 4ths which are often disguised in chords, repeated notes or in ornamentation and the predominance of Bs. Beethoven seems transfixed by the note B (have students find all the rising 4ths and Bs). The 2nd theme could be a string quartet; again students should identify which instrument would be playing each voice.