Public Safety Update: Suing vandals for damages
During an "Occupy Oakland" protest in the early morning hours of Nov. 3, a 24-year-old man from Elk Grove deliberately smashed almost $7,000 worth of windows in a public building.
The man, Cesar Aguirre, was arrested after police witnessed him destroying the windows of a building in City Hall plaza with a metal chair.
Oakland cannot afford this behavior, and we will not tolerate it.
My office champions the First Amendment, peaceful protest and dissent. Unfortunately, on a number of occasions in recent years, peaceful demonstrations have been marred by small groups of people who use the crowd as cover to vandalize public buildings, set fires and damage local businesses. In some recent protests, these acts have undermined the legitimate goal of addressing economic inequality.
Individuals who come to Oakland to destroy the public's property should be held accountable and make taxpayers whole. People who live, work and run businesses here should not have to shoulder the costs. I directed the Neighborhood Law Corps, the community law unit of the City Attorney's Office, to sue Aguirre for the cost of repairing the windows, plus punitive damages to be determined by the court.
This is the first person we have sued to recover damages for vandalism related to the Occupy protests. We are now reviewing other vandalism cases, and I plan to file more lawsuits if evidence warrants doing so. I hope these actions will deter those who come to Oakland not to protest, but merely to act out in destructive ways.
more information |