CREATIVE COMMUNICATIONS
Cast Your Ballot:
Advertising vs. Publicity

Issue: Eight                    November 2008
Logo Trans Rev
Creative Communications
Day School Services Include:

Strategic Development &
PR Plans

News Releases

E-Letters

E-Zines

Newsletters


Brochures

Recruitment & Retention Campaigns

Board & Lay
Leadership Development

Grant Research
& Writing

Dynamic Event Planning

Web Page Design
& Maintenance

Ghostwriting

Cost-effective Mentoring

Learn about the specific day school services available.
Visit us online.

mailbox

Need help submitting releases or developing a strategic calendar?
Please call me at

(516) 569-8070 or send me an email.


If you think your colleagues would like to learn why advertising should not be their only means of external communication, please forward this issue to them along with my invitation to subscribe to this newsletter.
 
 
Forward to a Friend 
 


Greetings!


I hope that you enjoyed the Chagim.  Last month, I promised to answer the challenge:
 
How do you continue to convey the first day of school's excitement to your parents, potential parents, and other target constituents?
 
Some readers wrote to me proposing that advertising is the secret solution to effective communication.

Well, advertising doesn't work- IF- it is the only element of your communications plan. Sure, advertising can be useful
but publicity is more effective and cost efficient. I'm devoting this issue to highlighting the distinction between publicity
and advertising and explaining why I advocate publicity. In the coming months, I will offer concrete, easy-to-implement suggestions to help you become a publicity whiz.

Advertising vs. Publicity
Advertising Button
Advertising is something you get by paying for it. You create an ad, paying meticulous attention to its content and design. You choose your media outlets, and pay. Your ad appears exactly - and as often - as you want.
 
Publicity, however, is something you try to obtain. You submit a request for coverage or a story after the fact. The assignment editor decides if a reporter should cover the story or if the submitted material should be published. Your perfectly chosen inter-generational picture may end up on the front page, your Chesed story may appear as a slightly edited feature, or the launching of your smart board program may become part of a larger feature about incorporating technology into the classroom. Your event may even end up on TV. Or, your request or release may be ignored, edited severely, buried in the back pages, or shelved until it is no longer relevant.
 
So, why try to get publicity that you can't control instead of paying for a sure thing: advertising? Doesn't that seem counter-intuitive?
 
There are two answers: cost and credibility.
 
1. Cost: advertising can be very expensive while publicity can be gained at relatively little cost.
 
2. Credibility: publicity has more credibility than advertising.
 
Cost: You pay not only for an ad's creation but also for each and every placement. Sure, you pay someone to write and submit your releases, but one release can be sent to many outlets - merely by clicking send!
 
Credibility: People who read or hear about you in the news know that you are not controlling the message. Therefore, they perceive the message to be credible.
 
The bottom line? Effective publicity is vital. It is simply good sense to ensure that your parents and other constituents including potential parents, grandparents, alumni, neighbors, vendors, and present and potential donors are exposed to positive, consistent publicity about your school.
 
Let's create a case study:
Perhaps you've heard some suspicious whispers from the cynics:
 
Sure those kids learn Torah. But, I wonder if they're prepared to enter the "real" world.
I bet they don't even know much about the presidential election.
 
Your job is to convince your constituent groups that your students will be tomorrow's responsible, savvy citizens.
 
Advertising
Let's say you decide to develop a low budget ad campaign. At the very least, in addition to your time, you'll spend the following:
ad creation (two ads): $600
ad placement
 2x in a small Jewish paper: $1200
 1x in the local Anglo paper: $1200
 
Your ad might pose the question: do you vote to produce students who can identify Plato, Palin, and the weekly Parsha? Perhaps it will include a picture of your students engaged in learning about the election - entering a "voting" booth, debating, or campaigning.
 
Publicity
Take the same $3,000. Put $1,800 in the bank (now, that's a good vote)! Invest $1,200 and pay to have one request for coverage for your "mock debate" and two election feature stories written (at $400 each). Each story would feature a unique focus and be sent with a different picture. In fact, each story could be tweaked slightly and sent to additional media contacts.
 
Chances are that for less than half the cost of advertising, your school's commitment to creating solid citizens will be featured in the newspaper, reaching your desired audience many more times than the three guaranteed by your paid ads. You might even be featured on TV or radio. And remember - due to enhanced credibility, one "earned-media" placement can have an advertising equivalency that far exceeds the value of a small ad.

Gaining solid, consistent editorial coverage requires more than simply submitting a well-written press release about a unique event. That is why it is known as "earned media" - you work to earn it! You work hard to know what news each editor needs, you craft pitches and stories in the format they desire, and you cultivate relationships with them. In an understandable effort to save money, many administrators simply add "monthly press release" to the list of responsibilities for their intern, assistant, or favorite English teacher. In the long run, this is not a good idea. If you don't have the qualified staff or time to earn the media coverage you want, let me know. I'm here to help out in a cost-effective way.

Should you have any questions about developing and implementing a winning 2008-09 PR and fund-raising plan or about any of my day school services, please call me at (516) 569-8070 or send me an email.


Sincerely,


Signature Revised Green
Candace Plotsker-Herman
Creative Communications