fish report header

Levee Improvements - Is vegetation beneficial or harmful?

In this post-Katrina world, California is struggling to find a balance between the protection of its environment and its citizens. Much of the destruction and loss of life in New Orleans resulted from levee failure and subsequent flooding. In the wake of the devastation the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (Corps) began a nation-wide evaluation of levee systems and many didn't make the cut. In 2007, the Corps released a white paper announcing that they wanted the removal of a substantial amount of vegetation from the banks levees maintained by both federal and non-federal entities nation-wide to increase stability of the levee systems. The levee vegetation removal policy was in response to the Katrina disaster, however, before the Corps released the new policy, it was determined that levee failures that occurred during Katrina were a result of engineering and construction issues and not the vegetation. In response to the new national policy, the California Department of Fish & Game (CDFG) has filed suit against the Corps, stating that the policy does not comply with the federal Endangered Species Act, National Environmental Policy Act, and federal Administrative Procedure Act.


The national policy that the Corps adopted seems counterproductive to what they have been working towards in recent years in California. Since 2006, the Corps, CDFG, California Department of Water Resources, U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service, National Marine Fisheries Service and other agencies have been involved with the Sacramento River Bank Protection Interagency Working Group in an effort repair levees and increase habitat by planting a substantial amount of vegetation on the banks. The white paper lists reasons why vegetation can be destructive to levees including impeding access for maintenance and inspections, hindering emergency flood fighting operations and removing soil from the levee when uprooted by wind. However, CDFG states that the newly adopted policy disregards other national policies, and is a complete reversal of studies previously conducted by the Corps. CDFG argues that studies conducted by the Corps reveal that vegetation on levees can minimize the effects of flooding and in the past the Corps has encouraged (even in some cases required) the planting of trees and shrubs on California levees. The removal of riparian habitat would likely have detrimental effects on several endangered species including Chinook salmon, steelhead, valley elderberry longhorn beetle, riparian brush rabbit, western yellow-billed cuckoo and Swainson's hawk. It is estimated that only five percent of the original riparian forests remain in the Central Valley and the new policy would reduce this further at a steep price of $7.5 billion. The Corps recognizes some of the beneficial elements of vegetation on levees, such as forming habitat for wildlife, decreasing surface erosion caused by rain, and creating visually appealing landscapes, but determined that the dangers are not worth the risk.


With a quickly growing population and considerable development within the floodplains, efforts to protect lives and property have sometimes caused destruction of habitat for endangered species in the Central Valley. In order for both society and the environment to benefit, the federal, state and local agencies need to work together to come to an agreement on the best approach to the levee system. Recently, the Corps declared 180 miles of levee systems in California ineligible for federal rehabilitation assistance if they are damaged during a flood due to a lack of detail in a new state and local levee maintenance plan along with inadequate inspections. Their intentions are good, but the conflict has only been worsening in recent weeks and there is no resolution in sight. 

Follow Us!  Like us on Facebook  View our photos on flickr  View our videos on YouTube

email list
Recent Blog Post
Got teeth?   

When Pacific salmon, in particular males, undertake their final spawning migration they develop rather fearsome sets of teeth, which they may use to defend their spawning territory against competitors. Though impressive, salmon teeth can't hold a candle to some of the largest fangs (relative to body size) in the animal kingdom, which belong to species in the family Stomiidae (viperfishes and dragonfishes). The Pacific viperfish (Chauliodus macouni), pictured below, is a deep-sea predator that occurs in the North Pacific from the Mexican coast to Japan in depths of up to 5000 meters (16,405 feet). In a world where food is generally scarce and predators can hardly afford to miss a meal, large teeth and long, hinged jaws that appear out of proportion to the rest of their body allow viperfish and other deep-sea predators to capture and swallow both large and small prey... Read more > 

IN THE NEWS: Recent stories you might have missed...
Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta historical ecology study
San Francisco Estuary Institute


The San Francisco Estuary Institute-Aquatic Science Center, in collaboration with the California Department of Fish and Game, has completed a historical ecology study of the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta. The project improves understanding of what the Delta looked like and how it functioned prior to the significant modification that has occurred over the last 160 years... Read more>

Feeding the river
Spokesman Review

Chinook salmon

Two major Bonneville Power Administration projects are tending to the welfare of Kootenai River fisheries, which have been starved for more than attention since Libby Dam went online in 1972. The success of the multiyear, multimillion dollar projects is easy to confirm with an Idaho fishing license and a fly rod. Trout, whitefish and suckers are bigger in the river's Idaho stretch, and their numbers have increased... Read more>

Savvy tribal fishermen hit the Columbia River for peak of the migration

Three tribal fishermen pull the 300-foot-long gillnet over their fiberglass boat, untangling and sorting dozens of salmon as an orange sun rises. Will Zack and two helpers tend nine nets on the both sides of the Columbia River upstream from Cascade Locks. Early morning pulls are best, hauling in some 50 fish in 30 minutes. Zack and his crew speed to a landing at Stevenson, Wash., where the salmon are loaded into ice-cooled bins... Read more > 

Big stink in L.A. may be dying Salton Sea
San Francisco Chronicle

The saltwater lake that could be to blame for a rotten-egg stench that seeped through greater Los Angeles on Monday has bigger problems than its public image. The massive body of water 150 miles southeast of the City of Angels is a dying lake, plagued by increasing salinity, receding shorelines and periodic fish die-offs caused by plummeting oxygen levels in its briny waters. Regional air quality officials were awaiting test results Tuesday to determine if the stench came from the lake,... Read more >

Globally, little forage fish net big profits


A first-time analysis estimates three kinds of contributions from small schooling species such as herring, anchovies, and sardines:  direct catch, as food for other commercially important fish, and as a link in the food web in marine ecosystems, representing 20 percent of the global catch values of all marine fisheries combined. Additionally, in 75 percent of the ecosystem models analyzed, at least one of the highly dependent predator species of forage fish,... Read more >