Some pipe makers are offering both African Blackwood and Polypenco pipes. What are the pro's and con's of each?

Poly pipes are easy to maintain as you wouldn't have to worry about oiling them as you would with a set of Blackwood pipes. They are considerably lower in cost as you can get a basic set for around $700 compared to a basic set of Blackwood for $1400. They will not crack from moisture and are great for performances in tough weather conditions. They are very durable and can take a bit more bumping. There are many different mount options available. Some makers (like McCallum) offer a 10 year warranty. However, these pipes will not absorb moisture like a Blackwood set would so you may get a build up if you are a wet blower. They are also not as traditional looking.

Blackwood pipes will produce a richer tone, however many new pipers won't hear the difference. They have a more traditional look and feel to them. There are many different mount and ornamentation options. Most sets offer a 2 year warranty. Because they are a natural material, they require maintenance of oiling and drying. Changes in moisture can result in cracks in the wood. Temperature and moisture changes can cause the wood to swell and shrink.

It is important to remember that it is the set up of the reeds and the player, not the material, which influences the sound of the pipes. Many people can not tell the different between plastic and wood from the same maker until they get up close to them.