|
AITSE Newsletter
|
August 2010
|
|
|
Greetings!
Last month I gave a presentation at Biola University in La Mirada, CA. Because I have experience as a professor, I could not resist the temptation to quiz the audience on what they remembered from my talk. They did pretty well--until I asked them to repeat the name of our nonprofit organization. Nobody could do it. So, let's work together--and make American Institute for Technology and Science Education a household word. After all, only ten years ago no one knew what an iPod was!
I am working hard doing interviews, giving presentations, talking to DC politicians, and writing articles. But, I need your help. As part of the public launch of AITSE, it is important that we make an appearance in as many places and reach as many people as possible. You can find a list of suggested presentation topics on the AITSE website. A booking form is coming soon, but meanwhile if you would like to schedule me to give a presentation in your city, let us know at info@aitse.org and we will see how we can work together to make it happen.
|
|
Scientific Integrity and Dr. Hauser
Can being disorganized lead to scientific fame?
Harvard University scientist Marc Hauser became famous for his work in cognitive evolution. As a psychologist who investigates the neurological basis for morality and works with primates and people, you would think he would know better than to, at the least, keep inadequate records or, much worse, fabricate data. But, Dr. Hauser is on "academic leave" after a Harvard University faculty committee found him "solely responsible for eight counts of scientific misconduct".
The history of the problems is long, starting in 1995, but the Harvard investigation was only initiated in 2007. Perhaps enough students had complained or maybe the comments from peers were becoming too embarrassing. Now Michael Ruse's concern is that the field of evolutionary biology itself will suffer from bad publicity.
But surely this should not be the main concern! Dr. Ruse makes the point that Dr. Hauser may have been under pressure to attract grant money, graduate students, and postdoctoral students--and this is mostly accomplished through publication. The pressure may have been exacerbated by the fact that Dr. Hauser holds a prestigious position at a leading university. In other words, Dr. Hauser may have succumbed to political, financial or even ideological temptation to forgo scientific integrity--thereby publishing at least three unsubstantiated scientific papers, possibly misleading numerous other scientists, and wasting countless tax dollars.
What is the answer? Raising the profile of scientific integrity in our nation. We need, as Kate Shaw said (quoted in the above-linked article), to "encourage responsible science, experimental replication, and an even more thorough review process."
Monkey business
|
 |
Where Dr. Crocker Will Be This Month
9/4/10 7:30 pm Calvary Chapel Logos Building, Costa Mesa, California--What You Shouldn't Ever Teach if You Want a Job. Link to video will be posted at www.aitse.org under News and Events.
Listen on September 18 and 25 to Frontiers: Defending Our Faith and Freedom. More details will be posted at www.aitse.org.
|
 |
The Tree of Science
Not so long ago an eminent scientist and successful politician advised me that, when speaking, it is vital to leave your audience with a mental picture that sums up your entire lecture. This is what I attempted to do in the July 28 legislative briefing held at the US Capitol building sponsored by Congressman Louie Gohmert and the Traditional Values Coalition. See what you think:
Imagine a tree of science. The bottom of the trunk represents elementary school, the middle level high school, the top level before the branches, college. The branches are analogous to the science professions: medicine, industry, teaching, etc. The leaves are the benefits for the public. It's a great tree-one people depend upon for their very lives. Now imagine that the tree contracts a fungal infection. The infection starts in the root system, works its way up the tree, and eventually the leaves turn brown and fall off and the tree dies. In our illustration, infections can also spread from branch to branch. This is what is happening in science. There is an infection called lack of scientific integrity-it starts at the bottom of the tree and works its way all over until the tree that we all depend on is severely compromised.
So what is scientific integrity? We know that basic integrity requires consistency, honesty, completeness, wholeness. Therefore, I would suggest that, to have scientific integrity, we must be willing to examine the whole truth about controversial subjects, encourage students do their own original work -all of it, and we need to persuade pharmaceutical companies to publish the whole story about their medications, allow scientists to consider the whole picture and follow evidence where it leads even if it deviates from consensus views-when you do all this, you get a truly comprehensive or whole understanding of a scientific idea, theory, or product. But this is not happening in many areas of science today. And the result is that our health, prosperity, and intellectual prowess as a nation are in jeopardy. If you like, the leaves of the tree of science are at risk of falling off. Addressing this issue is the purpose of AITSE...
Read more
|
 |
Professors Dealing with Hostility
National Public Radio reporter and author of The Fingerprints of God, Barbara Bradley Hagerty, may have suffered for doing the 2005 story about persecution of scientists who question aspects of evolution, but she is still out there fighting (see story below).
Bradley-Hagerty asks the question, "Do universities discriminate against religious conservatives?" According to a poll of 1,700 scientists conducted by Elaine Ecklund, over half admitted to being religious, but none would allow their name to be published. Kind of speaks for itself.
Could hostility towards religious conservatives stifle academic freedom and the ability of scientists to follow the evidence where it leads--even if interpretation of the data flies in the face of the politically correct consensus? You decide.
Christian Academics Cite Hostility on Campus
|
 |
Upcoming Conference
Vibrant Dance of Faith and Science
If you are in Austin, TX from October 26-28, you may want to check out this intriguing conference on faith and science sponsored by Hill Country Institute. Speakers include Andy Crouch, Alister McGrath, Steven Meyer, Hugh Ross, Darrel Falk and others--Christians from across most of the spectrum of faith and science. Should prove interesting.
Conference
|
|
 |
New Presentation Offered by AITSE
Especially for the Church
Why Should Christians Care About Scientific Integrity? Most
of us
believe
we
live
in
a
free
country
-
but
do
we
really?
In
this
20-‐minute
presentation,
Dr.
Caroline
Crocker,
immunopharmacologist
and
Christian,
briefly
surveys
the
critical
need
for
scientific
integrity
at
all
levels
of
our
educational
system,
in
medicine,
and
in
industry.
Based
on
her
own
experience
and
research,
she
mentions
how
science
has
been
taken
hostage
by
politics,
finance,
and
religion
and
shows
that
this
is
damaging
the
health,
prosperity
and
faith
of
church
members.
Dr.
Crocker
ends
by
showing
why
and
how
we
can
restore
integrity
back
to
science
by
ensuring
that
our
people
are
free
to
think.
Free to Think--or Not?
This informative talk about the relationship between academic freedom and our health, economic success and religious views as a nation is suited for all audiences.
Evolution and Intelligent Design: What's the Fuss?
Have you ever wondered why people get so angry about evolution, creation, intelligent design, etc.? In this fascinating presentation, the reason for the antagonism is explored and questions are asked.
What You Shouldn't Ever Say--If You Want a Job!
If you wondered what Dr. Crocker taught causing her to lose her job at GMU, this is the presentation you want! An information-packed lecture that will leave you wanting more.
The Evolution and Extinction of a Teacher
Illustrated with highly-entertaining cartoons by Ayden Lopez, this presentation shows how Dr. Crocker lost her job, legal representation, and career. Since lack of scientific integrity affects us all, this talk is a must for anyone who is interested in academic freedom.
The page for booking a presentation is not yet complete on the AITSE website, so please click below, click on "contact", and fill out the form.
Book a Talk
|
 |
Quote of the month
How does the public view science, scientific statements, and scientific experts versus what can they rightly expect?
Scientists are considered the other provider of candid truth... The basis of public trust in science comes from the ideology of science itself. The activities of science, as well as the scientist, are considered to be objective, rational, and thereby embodying a virtuous means of finding truth (Jones 2001).
Obviously, this high view of science requires an equally high standard of scientific integrity--something AITSE and Dr. Jones are both working towards. I met Dr. Nancy Jones while attending the American Scientific Affiliation meeting in Washington DC--and am very glad that she is in place at National Institutes of Health!
Article
|
 |
Stem Cell Research
On August 23 a federal judge blocked the use of federal funds to destroy human embryos by using them as a source for stem cells. On August 31 the Obama administration asked him to reconsider--not whether embryonic stem cell research should be allowed, but whether American tax payers should pay for it. Since I am running out of time for this newsletter, I'll leave you to read about it yourself.
ABC news article
|
 |
Book Review
Sometimes a little controversy helps. Dr. Caroline Crocker has set one rolling that probably will not stop with the publication of her book. Having studied biology on the undergraduate level, I can only say that Dr. Crocker is one classy teacher: knows her field, is a proven scientist, and wants to reach for all she can to make her students learn. She does not just teach, she cares. Her help to students with heart-wrenching life stories has won her long term admiration and friendship. Any Ph.D. who is so successful at developing the uninitiated into competent scholars of the complexities of biology is what most colleges and universities crave.
It is unfortunate that George Mason University gave Dr. Crocker the boot. They lost one of their best professors. Caroline Crocker is obviously a person who challenges others to think. That brought her to grief in the university (and she has since not been able to find another faculty position elsewhere). But don't expect her to stop now that she is outside of it.
"Free to Think" is the stimulating story of a highly motivated college prof who ran into trouble through a little naivete. She raised questions about Darwinian evolution in some of her lectures. The university's loss is our gain. We get to see from the inside how sometimes the hallowed halls of the pursuit of ideas become machines of dogma. We also get to know what it is like to run afoul of one's superiors. We get treated to humor in tense situations: like meeting the Ebenezer Scrooge of the academic world in the grievance committee. He declares her cartoons are degrading for a university lecture.
You will not find a bitter vent in this book. It presents instead, the fascinating story of being the center of controversy on campus. We learn how the lady thinks, and how almost irresistibly she gets others to think as well. When you finish, you will probably say with me, "Keep at it, Dr. Crocker."
|
 |
AITSE Needs You!
Publicity coordinator, social media guru, and grant writer
Publicity Coordinator-- Locate and work with event coordinators to develop speaking engagements, radio and TV appearances. - Help write press releases as needed - Help to create publicity media and marketing collateral as needed
Social Media Guru--Develop, maintain, and test the AITSE website as needed - Develop and publish videos online as needed - Assist in the development and deployment of the AITSE newletter - Assist in development of Twitter/Facebook/other social networking
Grant Writer--Identify possible funding sources -Contact foundations, corporations, donors in an appropriate manner/ maintain relationships -Write grants (need previous experience)
If you are willing and able to help in these ways, please let me know!
|
|
In closing, as always, thank you
for your
past gifts and
support. It is a fact that AITSE cannot
function in its
efforts to educate to increase scientific
understanding
and integrity without contributions. Please
consider
helping us with a special donation or a
commitment to
give on a monthly basis. Please make checks
payable
to AITSE and send them to PO Box 15938, Newport
Beach, CA 92659. Alternatively, you can
donate
on line through PayPal or credit card at
www.AITSE.org.
Sincerely,

Caroline Crocker, MSc, PhD
American Institute for Technology and Science Education
|
|
|