Homeopathic Medicine: Europe's #1 Alternative for Doctors
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dana-ullman/homeopathic-medicine-euro_b_402490.html
Dana Ullman
Expert in homeopathic medicine
Posted: March 3, 2010 09:27 AM
Dana Ullman, MPH, is America's leading spokesperson for homeopathy and is the founder of www.homeopathic.com. He is the author of 10 books, including his bestseller, Everybody's Guide to Homeopathic Medicines. His most recent book is, The Homeopathic Revolution: Why Famous People and Cultural Heroes Choose Homeopathy. Dana lives, practices, and writes from Berkeley, California.
Numerous surveys over the past 150 plus years have confirmed that
people who seek homeopathic treatment tend to be considerably more
educated than those who don't (1). What is not as well known is the
fact that homeopathic medicine is the leading "alternative" treatment
used by physicians in Europe...and growing numbers of the citizenry.
And despite homeopathy's impressive popularity in Europe, it is
actually even more popular in India where over 100 million people
depend solely on this form of medical care (2). Further, according to
an A.C. Neilsen survey in India, 62 percent of current homeopathy users
have never tried conventional medicines and 82 percent of homeopathy
users would not switch to conventional treatments (3).
Skeptics of homeopathy insist that homeopathic medicines do not
work, but have difficulty explaining how so many people use and rely
upon this system of medicine to treat themselves for so many acute and
chronic diseases; and a very large number of these people do not have
to use anything else. A previous article that
I wrote at this site presented a strong case for the scientific and
historical evidence for homeopathy. Further, other articles here have
provided additional scientific evidence for the use of homeopathic
medicines in respiratory allergies and in pediatrics.
Although a small and vocal group of skeptics of homeopathy continue to
deny its viability, homeopathy's growing popularity throughout the
world amongst physicians, other health professionals, and educated
populations continue to prove that skeptics are really simply medical
fundamentalists.
The entire field of "alternative and complementary medicine" was so
hot in the 1980s that, according to a respected market survey, the
field of alternative and complementary medicine in Europe was second
only to the computer industry for growth during this decade (4). This
explosion of interest in natural medicine has continued in the 21st
century.
In 1998, homeopathy was the most frequently used CAM therapy in five
out of 14 surveyed countries in Europe and among the three most
frequently used CAM therapies in 11 out of 14 surveyed countries (5).
Three out of the four Europeans know about homeopathy and of these
people 29 percent use it for their own health care. In other words,
approximately 100 million Europeans use homeopathic medicines (6).
The sales of homeopathic and anthroposophical medicines grew by 60
percent between 1995 and 2005, from 590 million Euros in 1995 to 775
million Euros in 2001 and to $930 million Euros in 2005 (7). Because of
homeopathy's impressive and growing popularity in Europe, this
alternative treatment poses a significant threat to conventional
medicine, which may explain why there are ongoing efforts to attack it
(and homeopaths) using devious and questionably ethical means.
France
Homeopathy is particularly popular in France, where it is the leading
alternative therapy. In 1982, 16 percent of the population used
homeopathic medicine, rising to 29 percent in 1987, and to 36 percent
in 1992 (8). In 2004, 62 percent of French mothers used homeopathic
medicines in the previous 12 months (9). A survey of French pharmacists
was conducted in 2004 and found that an astounding 94.5 percent
reported advising pregnant women to use homeopathic medicines (10).
Homeopathy is popular not only among the French public but also
among the French medical community. As many as 70 percent of physicians
are receptive to homeopathy and consider it effective, at least 25,000
physicians prescribe homeopathic medicines for their patients.
Homeopathy is taught in at least seven medical schools: Besancon,
Bordeaux, Lille, Limoges, Marseille, Paris-Nord, and Poitiers, and
there are numerous postgraduate training programs. Courses in
homeopathy are taught in 21 of France's 24 schools of pharmacy, and
also taught in two dental schools, two veterinary medical schools, and
three schools of midwivery.
United Kingdom
England's Royal Family has been homeopathy's strongest advocates,
thereby confirming that this system of natural medicine is not some
"new age" therapy. There are five homeopathic hospitals working within
the National Health Service, some of them with a two-year waiting list
for non-emergency visits to a homeopath.
According to a House of Lords report (2000), 17 percent of the
British population use homeopathic medicines (11). The respect accorded
homeopathy and homeopathic practice by British physicians is evidenced
by a 1986 survey in the British Medical Journal that showed that 42
percent of physicians referred patients to homeopathic doctors (12).
Other evidence of support from health professionals was a 1990 survey
of British pharmacists that found 55 percent considered homeopathic
medicines "useful," while only 14 percent considered them "useless"
(13). The normally conservative British Pharmaceutical Association held
a debate in 1992 to decide whether pharmacists should promote
homeopathic medicines (14). They concluded by a large majority that
they should.
The field of complementary medicine has gained much support in the
1990s. In 1993 the British Medical Association published a book
entitled, Complementary Medicine: New Approaches to Good Practice (15).
Britain's health minister (in 1994), Dr. Brian Mawhinney, stated,
"Complementary medicine has generally proved popular with patients, and
a recent survey found that 81 percent of patients are satisfied with
the treatment they received" (16). Another health minister stated that
80 percent of general practitioners want training in complementary
therapies; 75 percent now refer patients to complementary therapists.
Despite the use and acceptance of homeopathy throughout the U.K.,
there is a very active group of skeptics, with significant Big Pharma
funding, who work vigorously to attack this system of natural medicine.
Even though there is a wide variety of serious and significant pressing
issues in British medicine and science today, an active group of
skeptics of homeopathy successfully resurrected in October, 2009, a
House of Commons committee, called the Science and Technology
Committee, with the intent to issue a report on homeopathy. A leading
skeptics organization, Sense about Science, that has been pushing for
the re-creation of this Committee is led by a former public relations
professional who worked for a PR company that represents many Big
Pharma companies. Of additional interest is the fact that other
Directors of the Sense about Science organization are a mixture of
former or present libertarians, Marxists and Trotskyists who also, strangely enough, seem to advocate for the GMO industry
(ironically, libertarians normally advocate for a "live and let live"
philosophy, but in this instance, it seems that they prefer to take
choice in medical treatment away from British consumers).
Sense about Science is a registered UK charity despite being a
political pressure group. As such they have to divulge their sources of
income which they do on their website. Not surprisingly, much of this
comes from named pharmaceutical manufacturers.
One of the investigators for the House of Commons Science Committee
is a Liberal Democrat MP, Evan Harris. He has collaborated with Sense
About Science on various projects, and he was also one of the skeptic
demonstrators against the national pharmacy chain, Boots, which sells
homeopathic medicines. This advocacy role does not make him an unprejudiced observer as is required for this type of investigation.
A report from this kangaroo court was issued recommending that the
National Health Service stop funding for homeopathy and homeopathic
doctors, despite the support for homeopathy and for consumer choice
from Mike O'Brien, the country's present Health Minister. This report
is only of an advisory nature, and because the Health Minister has
already expressed his support for consumers' right to choose their own
health care, it is uncertain what, if anything, will result of this
report. What was most surprising about this report was that it verified
that when people repeat a lie frequently enough, such as "there is no
research on homeopathy," many people actually believe it, despite its
transparent falsity.
Any rational person should and must be very suspicious of this "report."
The MPs (Members of Parliament) who were a part of the Science and
Technology Committee which voted for this anti-homeopathy report
comprised of five members, with three members barely eking out their
victory. Of the three votes, two members did not attend any of the
investigational meetings, one of whom was such a new member of the
committee that he wasn't even a member of the committee during the
hearings, and the remaining "yes" vote was from Evan Harris, a medical
doctor and devout antagonist to homeopathy. This report was not exactly
a vote of and for the people.
In Scotland, 12 percent of general practitioners use homeopathic
medicines and 49 percent of all general practitioner practices
prescribe them (at least one medical doctor in a group practice)(17).
The use of homeopathic medicines is not simply popular in the
treatment of humans but also animals. Although there is little data
presently available on this subject, one survey discovered that 20
percent of Irish milk producers have tried homeopathic medicines to
treat mastitis or high cell count cows, and 43 percent believe that
they work. In the herds surveyed, 50 percent added homeopathic
medicines to the cow's drinking water, 27 percent administered
medicines via injection, six percent orally doses the cows, and six
percent of herds placed the medicines in the cow's vagina (18).
Ireland
A survey in Ireland was conducted at 13 pediatric settings over a
4-month period (19). They found that 57 percent of parents reported
using CAM for their child. Use was significantly higher in the two to
four years age group. The most common medicinal CAMs used were vitamins
(88 percent), fish oils (27 percent) and Echinacea (26 percent). The
most common non-medicinal CAMs used were homeopathy (16 percent) and
craniosacral therapy (14 percent). Only 13 percent of parents had
informed their pediatrician of their child's CAM use.
Germany
The German people are so supportive of natural medicine that the German
government mandated that all medical school curricula include
information about natural medicines. Approximately 10 percent of German
doctors specialize in homeopathy, with approximately 10 percent more
prescribing homeopathic remedies on occasion. In 1993, there were 1,993
medical doctors who had formally qualified in homeopathy, while in
2006, this number jumped over 100 percent to 6,073 (20). In Germany
there are 9,000 natural health practitioners called heilpraktikers in
1993 and over 20,000 in 2007. Approximately 20-30 of heilpraktikers
specialize in homeopathy.
A cross-sectional survey was conducted in a large random sample of
516 German outpatient care physicians with qualifications in 13 medical
fields representative of a basic population of 118,085 statutory health
insurance physicians in November and December 2005 as part of a
national healthcare survey (21). In this survey, 51 percent were in
favor of CAM use (26 percent were very much in favor, 25 percent were
in favor). This survey found that 38 percent of the medical doctors
prescribed homeopathic medicines.
A survey of departments of obstetrics in hospitals in the state of
North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany, found that acupuncture and homeopathic
medicine were the two most commonly used CAM practices (22). A total of
187 department of obstetrics were identified, and 138 (73.4 percent)
responded to a questionnaire. Almost 96 percent of the obstetrical
departments offered homeopathic medicines for obstetrical care.
The 2003-2006 German Health Interview and Examination Survey for
Children and Adolescents (KiGGS) found a higher than expected use of
homeopathic medicine amongst German children (23). The survey found
that pediatric homeopathy is quite popular in Germany, particularly
among children from families with a higher socioeconomic status. Nearly
half of the homeopathic preparations were obtained by prescriptions
from medical doctors or Heilpraktiker (non-medical practitioners) and
used most often to treat certain self-limiting conditions. About 60
percent of homeopathy users concomitantly received conventional
medicines. Homeopathy use was closely related to socioeconomic factors,
with a significantly higher prevalence rate found in the zero to six
year age group, among children residing in the former West Germany or
the south of Germany, among children with a poor health status, with no
immigration background , who received breast-feeding greater than 6
months, were from upper social-class families, and whose children's
mothers were college educated.
In 2002, the British Medical Journal (BMJ) reported that 75 percent
of Germans have used complementary or natural medicine (24). They also
reported that 5,700 doctors received specialized training in natural
medicine, with this number doubling to 10,800 by 2000. Homeopathic
medicine is practiced by 4,500 medical doctors in Germany, almost twice
as many as did so in 1994. The German government conducted this survey,
and it also discovered that there was a 33 percent reduction in sick
days if people used natural therapies, especially homeopathy or
acupuncture. It was also reported that women used natural therapies
more than men did, but when men used them, they benefited more than
women did.
In 2009 a survey of Germans who used homeopathy or acupuncture was
published (25). This survey found that seven percent of the population
used homeopathy and 10 percent used acupuncture. Individuals who had a
high education level used homeopathy (68 percent), as compared with 53
percent who used acupuncture.
A survey of patients in Germany with chronic lymphocytic leukemia
found that 44 percent had used alternative treatments. No correlation
was seen with educational level, gender, or previous or current
chemotherapy. The most common alternative or complementary treatment
modality was vitamin supplementation (26 percent), followed by mineral
(18 percent), homeopathic (14 percent), and mistletoe therapy (9.2
percent) (26).
A 2008 survey of German children with cancer was conducted and which
found that 35 percent of the responders had used CAM (27). The most
frequently used methods were homeopathy, dietary supplements and
anthroposophic medicine including mistletoe therapy. Factors which
increased the probability of using CAM were the previous use of CAM,
higher social status and poor prognosis of the child's disease. An
impressively high percentage of parents of patients (89 percent)
reported that they would recommend CAM to other parents.
The use of homeopathy and CAM in Germany by people with other
chronic disease is also high, as was observed in a survey of German's
with multiple sclerosis (28). A 53-item survey was mailed to the
members of the German Multiple Sclerosis Society, chapter of
Baden-Wuerttemberg. Surveys of 1,573 patients were analyzed. In
comparison with conventional medicine, more patients displayed a
positive attitude toward complementary and alternative medicine (44
percent vs 38 percent, P less than 0.05), with 70 percent reporting
lifetime use of at least one method. Among a wide variety of
complementary and alternative medicine, diet modification (41 percent),
Omega-three fatty acids (37 percent), vitamins E (28 percent), B (36
percent), and C (28 percent), homeopathy (26 percent), and selenium (24
percent) were cited most frequently. Most respondents (69 percent) were
satisfied with the effects of complementary and alternative medicine.
Use of complementary and alternative medicine was associated with
religiosity, functional independence, female sex, white-collar job, and
higher education (P less than 0.05). Compared with conventional
therapies, complementary and alternative medicine rarely showed
unwanted side effects (9 percent vs 59 percent, P less than 0.00001).
Sales of homeopathic medicines in Germany were approximately $428
million in 1991, growing at a rate of about 10 percent per year.
Evidence of the significant support from the German medical community
is the fact that 85 percent of these sales are prescriptions from
physicians. Surveys indicate that 98 percent of pharmacies sell
homeopathic medicines.
Switzerland
A government-sponsored survey was conducted in Switzerland that
evaluated patient satisfaction and side effects in primary care and
that compared homeopathic treatment and conventional medical treatment
(29). A total of 3,126 adult patients responded to a questionnaire,
1,363 of whom received conventional medical treatment and 1,702 who
received homeopathic treatment. This survey found that a higher
percentage of homeopathic patients had chronic and severe conditions
than the conventional medical patients, that homeopathic patients were
more often "completely satisfied" with their treatment (53 percent vs.
43 percent), that homeopathic patients experienced significantly fewer
side effects (7.3 percent vs. 16.1 percent), that the proportion of
patients reporting complete resolution of symptoms was
non-significantly higher in the conventional medical patients (28
percent vs. 21 percent). What is particularly important about this
survey is the observation that homeopathic patients had a higher
percentage of seriously ill patients but they expressed a much higher
amount of satisfaction with their treatment than the patients who
received conventional medical treatment. This survey also confirmed a
common observation about people who seek homeopathic treatment and that
is they were much more educated than those who didn't (32.4 percent vs.
24.7 percent received "higher education").
The Swiss Federal Office for Public Health issued a report to the
government of Switzerland which concluded that "the effectiveness of
homeopathy can be supported by clinical evidence, and professional and
adequate application be regarded as safe" (30).
Other European countries in which homeopathy has a relatively strong
presence include Switzerland, where different surveys have suggested
that somewhere between 11 percent and 27 percent of general
practitioners and internists prescribe homeopathic medicines; Italy
where nine percent of the medical doctors prescribe homeopathic
remedies sometimes; and the Netherlands where 45 percent of physicians
consider homeopathic medicines effective and 47 percent of medical
doctors use one or more complementary therapies, with homeopathy (40
percent of these select doctors) being the most popular (31).
The prevalence of CAM use in a sample of Swiss patients undergoing
kidney transplant was 11.8 percent. The most frequently used
alternative therapy used among these was homeopathy (42.9 percent)
(32).
Italy
In 2004 a total of 7.5 million Italians use homeopathic medicines, 2.5
million more than a survey showed in 2000 (33). Approximately 14
percent of Italian women and 10 percent of men prefer homeopathic
medicine to conventional medicine. A total of 9.6 percent of children
between three and five years of age are treated with homeopathic
medicines. Almost 90 percent of Italians who have used such medicines
say these treatments helped by them, with 30 percent saying that they
used homeopathic medicines for pain syndromes and 24 percent for severe
or chronic diseases.
A 2005 survey on the use of complementary and alternative medicines
(CAM) among cancer patients in Europe reported that 73 percent of the
Italian cancer patients had used CAM, a number well above the European
average of 36 percent (34). The most popular treatment modalities used
by cancer patients in Italy were high use of homeopathy, herbal
medicine, and spiritual therapies. A 2008 survey in Tuscany, Italy
found that the incidence of CAM use after cancer diagnosis was 17
percent, with the most widely used forms being herbal medicine (52
percent), homeopathy (30 percent) and acupuncture (13 percent) (35).
Use was higher in the urban area and among women, breast cancer
patients, and persons with a higher education.
A survey of Italian children with cancer who were being treated at a
conventional pediatric oncology unit found that 12.4 percent of the
children used at least one type of CAM, with homeopathy being the most
popular (36). Eighty-three percent of the parents of these children
reported benefits, ranging from improved immune defenses, regression of
diplopia, or improved blood values. This study confirmed the
observation of many other surveys which found that users of CAM tended
to be more educated than those who did not use CAM (37)(38)(39).
Five hundred and fifty-two patients who had inflammatory bowel
disease and who were under treatment at an Italian tertiary medical
referral center completed the questionnaire (40); 156 (28 percent)
reported using alternative and complementary therapies, of which mainly
involved homeopathy (43.6 percent), followed by controlled diets or
dietary supplements (35.5 percent), herbs (28.2 percent), exercise
(25.6 percent) and prayer (14.7 percent). An improvement in well-being
(45.5 percent) and inflammatory bowel disease symptoms (40.3 percent)
were the most commonly reported benefits. A higher education (P equal
to 0.027), a more frequently relapsing disease (P equal to 0.001) and
dissatisfaction with the doctor's communication (P equal to 0.001)
correlated with alternative and complementary therapy use.
Non-compliance with conventional drugs, disease severity and curiosity
regarding novel therapies were predictors of alternative and
complementary therapy use.
Spain
In Spain, homeopathy has gotten so popular that INE, the country's
statistic institute, added expenditures on homeopathic medicines to
their calculations for monthly inflation rates (41). Sales of
homeopathic medicines in Spain are growing at 10-15 percent annually,
with approximately 15 percent of the population saying that they have
used a homeopathic medicine and 25 percent said that they would be
happy to try one (42).
Eastern Europe
When the Iron Curtain was up, Hungary, Czechoslovakia, and East Germany
banned homeopathy, but this medical iron curtain fell with communism.
Homeopathy holds a unique place in Russia, where it has been widely
accepted, but is not sanctioned by the state medical bureaucracy. Thus,
homeopathic care is not free and has been a part of the new Russian
economy where fees are paid for health services. Demand for homeopathic
care is so great that Russians prefer to pay for homeopathic care than
to receive free conventional medical care.
Some skeptics have asserted that homeopathy and natural medicines
are becoming increasingly popular in Russia because "real medicine" is
either unavailable or too expensive (43). However, this assumption has
been disproven, because the trend toward homeopathic and natural
medicine is particularly popular among those Russians who are more
educated and are in higher economic classes. Journalists and skeptics
tend to assume that homeopathic medicines simply do not work, and thus
they create fanciful theories about why the use of homeopathy is
increasing.
A survey of Russian physicians in three academic hospitals in St.
Petersburg was published in 2008 (44). This survey found that 100
percent of the respondents had practice CAM and/or referred patients to
at least two CAM therapies. On average, each physician had practiced or
referred patients to 12.7 different CAM treatments. Homeopathic
medicine was the 8th most popular, with 58 percent using or referring
for homeopathic treatment, 31 percent using on themselves, 29 percent
using it on their own patients, and 38 percent referring for
homeopathic care.
In Hungary, homeopathic literature was banned for 40 years until
1990. Homeopathy has now been accepted and integrated into regular
medical education and is taught in two medical schools. The Hungarian
Homeopathic Medical Association started with 11 members in 1990, grew
to 75 after 18 months, and grew further to 302 members in 1994.
After the fall of communism in Czecholslovakia, a homeopathic
organization in the Czech Republic was established in November, 1990,
and it was immediately accepted and integrated within the larger
conventional medical society. Within a year, the Ministry of Health
officially recognized homeopathy as a medical specialty.
REFERENCES:
(1) Rothstein, W. Physicians in the Nineteenth Century. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1972.
(2) Prasad R. Homoeopathy booming in India. Lancet, 370:November 17,
2007,1679-80. (Additional note: Even though the overall mortality rate
in India is quite poor compared with most modern First World countries,
this is primarily due to the large number of exceedingly poor people.
The mortality rate of urban middle and upper class people in India is
comparable, if not better, than similar populations in the USA.)
(3) A C Neilsen survey backs homeopathy benefits. Business Standard.
September 4, 2007.
http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/a-c-nielsen-survey-backs-homeopathy-benefits/295891/
(4) "Alternative Medicine/Alternative Medical Market," Frost and Sullivan Ltd. Report #E874, London, 1986.
(5)
Norges offentlige utredninger, NOU 1998:21 Alternativ medisin.
(Official report published by the Norwegian Department of Health.
Available at:
http://www.regjeringen.no/en/ministries/hod/Documents/NOUer/1998/NOU-1998-21.html?id=141407
(6)
di Sarsina PR, Iseppato I. Looking for a person-centered medicine:non
convent8onal medicine in the conventional European and Italian setting.
eCAM, 2009; doi:10.1093/ecam/nep048.
(7) ECHAMP, Facts and Figures, Second edition, 2007. www.echamp.eu
(8) L'Homeopathie en 1993. Lyons: Syndicat National de la Pharmacie
Homeopathique, 1993 (Quoting COFREMCA and IFOP public opinion surveys).
(9) Transactions, Nutrition Business Journal, July 7 2004.
(10) Damase-Michel, C., Vie, C., Lacroix, I., Lapeyre-Mestre, M.,
Montastruc, J.L. Drug Counselling in Pregnancy: An Opinion Survey of
French Community Pharmacists, Pharmacoepidemiol Drug Saf. 2004 March,
18;13(10):711.
(11) House of Lords Science and Technology Report, November, 2000
http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld199900/ldselect/ldsctech/123/12303.htm
(12) Richard Wharton and George Lewith, "Complementary Medicine and the
General Practitioner," British Medical Journal, 292 (June 7, 1986):
1498-1500.
(13) Nelson, op. cit.
(14) Steven Kayne, "Homeopathic Pharmacy: Education, Research and Optimism," British Homoeopathic Journal, October, 1993: 225.
(15) British Medical Association, Complementary Medicine: New Approaches to Good Practice, Oxford: Oxford University, 1993.
(16) Universal News Services, June 16, 1994.
(17) Ross, S, Simpson, CR, McLay, JS. British Homoeopathic and herbal
prescribing in general practice in Scotland. Journal of Clinical
Pharmacology, 62,6: December 2006, 647-652.
(18) Buss, Jessica. Irish Turn to Homoeopathy. Farmers Weekly, October 16, 1998.
(19) Low E, Murray DM, O'Mahony O, O'B Hourihane J. Complementary and
alternative medicine use in Irish paediatric patients. Ir J Med Sci.
2008 Apr 22.
(20) Joos S, Musselmann B, Miksch A, Rosemann T, and Szecsenyi J. The
role of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) in Germany - a
focus group study of GPs.
BMC Health Services Research 2008, 8:127. doi:10.1186/1472-6963-8-127
(21) Stange R, Amhof R, Moebus S. Complementary and alternative
medicine: attitudes and patterns of use by German physicians in a
national survey. J Altern Complement Med. 2008 Dec;14(10):1255-61.
(22) Munstedt K, et al. Clinical indications and perceived
effectiveness of complementary and alternative medicine in departments
of obstetrics in Germany: A questionnaire study. Eur J Obstet Gynecol
(2009), doi:10.1016/j.ejogrb.2009.05.013
(23) Du Y, Knopf H. Paediatric homoeopathy in Germany: results of the
German health interview and examination survey for children and
adolescents (KiGGS). Pharmacoepidemiol Drug Saf. 2009 Feb 23.
(24) Tuffs, Annette, Three out of Four Germans Have Used Complementary or Natural Remedies, BMJ, November 2 2002;325:990.
(25) Bussing A, Matthiessen PF, Ostermann T. Differential usage of
homeopathy and acpunture in German individuals. 2009 North American
Research Conference on Complementary and Integrative Medicine, May
2009, Minneapolis, MN. Published in Alternative Therapies. May/June
2009, 15,3:S141.
(26) Hensel M, Zoz M, Ho AD. Complementary and alternative medicine in
patients with chronic lymphocytic leukemia. Support Care Cancer. 2008
May 6.
(27) Laengler A, Spix C, Seifert G, Gottschling S, Graf N, Kaatsch P.
Complementary and alternative treatment methods in children with
cancer: A population-based retrospective survey on the prevalence of
use in Germany. Eur J Cancer. 2008 Oct;44(15):2233-40.
(28) Schwarz S, Knorr C, Geiger H, Flachenecker P. Complementary and
alternative medicine for multiple sclerosis. Mult Scler. 2008
Sep;14(8):1113-9.
(29) Marian F, Joost K, Saini KD, et al Patient satisfaction and side
effects in primary care: an observational study comparing homeopathy
and conventional medicine. BMC Comp Alt Med 2008, 8:52.
doi:10.1186/1472-6882-8-52.
(30) Bornhoft, G, Wolf, U., von Ammon, et al, Effectiveness, Safety,
and Cost-Effectiveness of Homeopathy in General Practice--Summarized
Health Technology Assessment, Forschende Komplementarmedizin,
2006;13(suppl 2):19-29.
(31) Fisher, Peter and Ward, Adam. "Complementary Medicine in Europe," British Medical Journal, 309, July 9, 1994: 107-10.
(32) Hess S, De Geest S, Halter K, Dickenmann M, Denhaerynck K.
Prevalence and correlates of selected alternative and complementary
medicine in adult renal transplant patients. Clin Transplant. 2008 Sep
11. Clin Transplant. 2008 Sep 11.
(33) ANSA English Corporate Service, 7.5 Million Italians Use Homeopathic Drugs, May 20, 2004.
(34) Molassiotis A, Fernadez-Ortega P, Pud D, et al, Use of
complementary and alternative medicine in cancer patients: a European
survey. Ann Oncol, 16: 655-663, 2005.
(35) Johannessen H, von Bornemann Hjelmborg J, Pasquarelli E,
Fiorentini G, Di Costanzos F, Miccinesi G., Prevalence in the use of
complementary medicine among cancer patients in Tuscany, Italy. Tumori.
2008 May-Jun;94(3):406-10.
(36) Clerici CA, Veneroni L, Giacon B, et al., Complementary and
alternative medical therapies used by children with cancer treated at
an Italian pediatric oncology unit. Pediatric Blood Cancer. June 2009.
doi 10.1002/pbc.22093.
(37) Gomez-Martinez R, Tlacuilo-Parra A, Garibaldi-Covarrubias R. Use
of complementary and alternative medicine in children with cancer in
Occidental, Mexico. Pediatr Blood Cancer 2007;49:820-823.
(38) Gozum S, Arikan D, Bu¨yu¨kavci M. Complementary and alternative
medicine use in pediatric oncology patients in eastern Turkey. Cancer
Nurs 2007;30:38-44.
(39) Nathanson I, Sandler E, Ramı´rez-Garnica G, et al. Factors
influencing complementary and alternative medicine use in a multisite
pediatric oncology practice. J Pediatr Hematol Oncol 2007;29:705-708.
(40) D'Inca R, Garribba AT, Vettorato MG, Martin A, Martines D, Di Leo
V, Buda A, Sturniolo GC, Use of alternative and complementary therapies
by inflammatory bowel disease patients in an Italian tertiary referral
centre, Dig Liver Dis. 2007 Apr 10.
(41) Reuters (Madrid) Tummy tucks join inflation calculation. February 12, 2007.
(42) Izmirlieva, Milena. Global Insight, March 28, 2007 (found in Homeopathy Today, May/June 2007, p.9).
(43) Clines, F. "With Medicine Itself Sick, Russians Turn to Herbs," New York Times, December 31, 1990.
(44) Brown, Samuel, Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicine by
Physicians in St. Petersburg, Russia. The Journal of Alternative and
Complementary Medicine Apr 2008, Vol. 14, No. 3: 315-319.