Pentecost B
May 31, 2009

Harry T. CookBy Harry T. Cook
5/26/09



RUBRIC

Observances of the Feast of Pentecost are so ordinarily fraught with pious treacle and theological aimlessness that it is tempting to let the day pass in hopes that neither the piety nor the theology proffered on and for its occasion will do much harm.

Any talk whatsoever about "spirits," holy and otherwise, of necessity partakes in such vagueness as to be an occasion for the vending of wholesale nonsense. The same goes for "spirituality."

It was once told me that I was the odds-on favorite to become pastor of a much-coveted church, but my singular failing was said to be my lack of "spirituality." The search committee assumed that I could not, therefore, lead the congregation adequately. The priest deemed to have had that very quality of spirituality was eventually chosen for the position and promptly led the parish into confusion and despair. Veni, creator spiritus.

Over 40 years, I was a voter-participant in four episcopal elections, and was in each case publicly chastised for being "political" in the process rather than relying on "the Holy Spirit" to make the choice. If a spirit did the electing in two of the cases, Its choices fell short on several important counts.

So now on Sunday, May 31, 2009, there will be much ado about . . . what? About an unseen but supposedly potent force that has been variously represented as a descending dove, as pillars of flame, as a mighty rushing wind, as the dispenser of essential charisms and as "just that feeling."

A case can be made that "the Holy Spirit" is a blank canvass stretched across a frame of questionable assumptions upon which anyone can paint what he envisions this spirit to be.

So, come Sunday, ego and industry applied to the homiletic task in tens of thousands of pulpits will drive nominal talent to its limit. Arrogance unsustained by serious scholarship may well rule the day.


WORKSHOP

For the principal liturgy this coming Sunday, the homilist and his/her audience will have five separate biblical passages with which to deal or from which to choose for emphasis. This section of FINDINGS II will briefly mention each and suggest what in them might be fruitful choices for homiletic consideration:

* Ezekiel 37: 1-14, which may have been heard at the Easter Vigil, being a hopeful image of restoration and revivification. It is the story of the valley of the dry bones. The key word is "breath" or the Hebrew רזח -- meaning, roughly, "wind" or "exhalation." The prophet imagines Yahweh speaking to the bones saying that "breath" will enter and re-animate them.

The relevance to Pentecost is that the emergence of a new "breath" or "spirit" among the dispirited apostolic community gave it new post-crucifixion life. That the new breath was an emanation of the crucified one is the point.

*Psalm 104: 25-35, which is a celebration of the natural order "with its living things too great to number" including even "the Leviathan" or great sea monster. When comes verse 31, you have the connection to Pentecost: "You send forth your Spirit (the 'breath' as accounted for above), and they are created."

*Acts 2: 1-21, which is Luke's highly imaginative fantasy of the descent of the Holy Spirit upon the waiting apostolic community. That it is fiction is not to be disputed. That it is really good fiction is also not in question. But to take it as reportage is always a mistake. The central image is of people of varying tribes, clans, kith and kin who speak their own peculiar languages being made to speak for all to understand and for them to hear as if others were speaking in their language. It was a wonderful vision, but, as the fractures moving toward a deeper crevasse in the Anglican Communion make plain, even Christians who speak the same language cannot understand one another.

*Romans 8:22-27, part of Paul's mediation upon the "Spirit." Assuming Paul was at Romans 8 of the same mind as he was at II Corinthians 3:17, he is fairly clear about the identity of the Spirit: "Now the Lord is the Spirit." In this passage, the Spirit is part of the inner self which "helps us in our weakness" interceding for us even "with sighs too deep for words." It is almost a psychological formula: what there may be of objective divinity found subjectively within a person's inward being. Thence comes the more careless misuse of the idea of "spirit." (See Homiletic Commentary below.)

*John 15: 26-27, 16: 4b-14, which is part of the Final Discourse the evangelist John gives Jesus to speak. We encounter here the idea of the Spirit as "advocate" (παράκλητος) - the one called to the side of. This unseen force also is the spirit of "truth" (αληθείας) - the reality lying at the basis of appearance. (See Homiletic Commentary below.)


HOMILETIC COMMENTARY

So we have 1) "breath of life," 2) life's causative power, 3) the supposed ability of cross-cultural/linguistic understanding, 4) the inner human self in communion with something greater than itself and the sum of all other human selves and 5) the one who advocates for the disclosure of what's real.

1) and 2) Without dissing Darwin, we can definitely say that some force beyond even our most hallucinogenic imaginations must have been implicit in the Big Bang and, by extension, all that has flowed from it. We can compose tone poems and hymns to it (see the psalm of the day) or commune with it in the laboratory or observatory or in the e=mc2 world. Dare we say the various deities of our various imaginations can be credited with numbering every hair and the fall of every sparrow? Probably not, but some will try.

3) The idea of simultaneous translation came to pass early on in the life and work of the United Nations. As we can see, all that worked very well as U.S. and Chinese delegates could understand each other's seething anger throughout the Korean and Vietnam conflicts. The same goes for the Iraq and Afghanistan campaigns. We can listen to each other and get the translation, but we cannot talk to each other in good faith. And, as has been pointed out already, English-speaking bishops in the United States cannot really hear each other, never mind their Anglophone contemporaries in Africa.

4) "The inner workings of the Spirit" -- here is dangerous territory in which everyone becomes his or her own arbiter. "God has told me a.b.c.," says Person I. "But," says Person II., "God has spoken to me and said d.e.f." A third person angrily responds, "No, no. It's g.h.i." And so it goes. We should worry about inner voices and sighs too deep for words. Such exhalations are akin to speaking in tongues. Don't sigh and don't babble. Be silent until you find the words to express what you are feeling - even better, what you are thinking.

5) Perhaps the best bet for the homilist on the occasion of Pentecost is to pick up on the evangelist John's image of the advocacy of truth. Seldom in the human epoch has there been such a crying need to see the core of realities behind the appearance of things. The evangelist was on to something big at 8:32 when he said "the truth will make you free." When?


EDITOR'S NOTE: Thanks to the several readers of FINDINGS II for their comments on my method of transliterating New Testament Greek terms. Several readers took notice of and approved my somewhat unorthodox method, while others objected to it as misleading. The purpose of my idiosyncratic transliterations, when I use them, is to allow non-Koine Greek readers to pronounce the words, to get a feel of how they sound.



� Copyright 2009, Harry T. Cook. All rights reserved. This article may not be used or reproduced without proper credit.

Readers Write
Re FINDINGS II 5/18/09

Ralph McCoy McMasters, Vancouver BC, Canada:
You are the first clergy-type I've ever known of who gives such complete accounts of bible passages. Your material is tough going for a layman, but now that I have read through several of the Findings, I find I am catching on. Of course, that makes going to church sometimes difficult. Guess why.

Margaret Anne Matthews, Madison WI: Your Friday essays are stimulating, and your Monday FINDINGS are challenging. I don't go to church anymore because for years I had felt no intellectual connection -- kind of like "no there there." Well, now you're my "there." Thanks for being "there" and there.

The Rev. Ralph R. Carskadden, Seattle, WA: These weekly explorations of the text in the light of fine scholarship are very good, sort of an updated Reginald Fuller without the agenda which limits deeper consideration of the scriptures. Might these be a book in progress?  Keep it up.  And thank you.  I wish I were preaching weekly with the help of these insights.


Lecture Schedule

The Thursday Forum
Birmingham Unitarian Church
38651 Woodward Ave. (at Lone Pine)
Bloomfield Hills, MI 48304
Admission: $10/students free


May 28
10-11:30 a.m.
Whence & Whither the World & U.S. Economics
Speaker: Harry Cook

June 4
10-11:30 a.m.
"Angels & Demons" - A Movie Review
Dan Brown continues to addle the Catholic Church
Speaker: Harry Cook

June 11
10-11:30 a.m.
Will Michigan Vote For A Constitutional Convention?
What's At Stake If They Do or They Don't?
Speaker: Harry Cook

June 18
10-11:30 a.m.
The Future of the U.S. Supreme Court Post-Souter
Will President Obama Try To Re-make It ? Will He Succeed?
Speaker: Harry Cook

* * * *  June 25 - 7:30-9 p.m. * * * *
What Are We Doing to Our Children?
Dr. Sonya Friedman is the guest speaker
Refreshments will follow

* * *
Summer University: 10 a.m. Thursdays
July 16: Eco-Wisdom: Saving Earth From Us
July 23: Knowing v. Believing: A Brief For Reason
July 30: News Round-up: What's Happening?
Speaker
: Harry Cook






WHAT DO YOU THINK?

I'd like to hear from you. E-mail your comments to me: [email protected].



ARCHIVES NOW AVAILABLE
To read previously published essays and sermons, click  on the link below.





Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon Add your name to our mailing list
For Email Marketing you can trust