Ekklesia logo

Thinking For a Change

The weekly ezine from Ekklesia
exploring belief, politics and culture
 
Please help Ekklesia to continue its work by donating through PayPal here 
In This Edition
Marriage in the C of E - an honourable estate? by Kevin Scully
More media 'God versus God' by Martin E. Marty
Genocide - the Armenian saga continues by Harry Hagopian
Quota: Gene Stoltzfus and Walter Brueggemann
Update: Power and Poverty
Research Focus: Religious representation in the House of Lords
Media and web debate
Event:Global religious summit on HIV-AIDS
Thinking in Action: Third Way magazine
Reading allowed: The Naked Anabaptist
Quick Links
 
Our Partners
Ekklesia is an independent member of the Root and Branch Network which includes: 
Take Action
You can join Ekklesia and take action by asking your MP to sign the following Parliamentary motions:
 
EDM 1248 on Conflict Prevention
 
Ekklesia attends the All Party Parliamentary Group on Conflict Issues which is supporting this motion
 
 
 
Ekklesia is a founder member of Accord - mentioned in the motion - which seeks to make faith schools more inclusive
 
 
 
 
Ekklesia is working with the Still Human Still Here campaign which supports both these motions
 
 
More Ekklesia Bulletins
Find out which bulletins you are subscribed to, and change the ones you receive by using the "Update Profile/Email address" link at the bottom of this email 
 
Issue: # 70 19 March 2010
Controversy and contestation is a major feature of public life. Sometimes it gets decidedly overheated. To our surprise (to put it mildly), Ekklesia was accused by a church official of being 'anti-Christian' last week. Not just wrong, misguided or mistaken in our perspective, but opposed to the very thing we take as our ground.
 
Sadly, people of faith dismissing and de-churching each other is nothing new. The divisions within historic Christianity are deep indeed, and Muslims, Jews, atheists and others also frequently find themselves at loggerheads - not just with each other, but also within their own fold. Martin Marty's piece on 'God wars' illustrates the often tragic contours of this all-to-human tendency to exalt ourselves and reject 'the other'.
 
Seeking ways of turning destructive division into life-enhancing ways of facing genuine (and often profoundly significant) differences in the church and in other sections of society is a key concern for Ekklesia - though we don't pretend that we are always good at it. Conflict transformation requires the kind of deep 'recognition' spoken of in our quotation of the week, from an Italian Catholic writer.
 
How to negotiate commonality and difference is also a challenge from (and to) non-conformist understandings of the Christian life... something reflected in our book recommendation this week: Stuart Murray's forthcoming volume, The Naked Anabaptist. For those who may wonder, Ekklesia's own outlook - though broadly based - is strongly rooted in the convictions (http://www.anabaptistnetwork.com/coreconvictions) of the Anabaptist Network UK.
 
Meanwhile, the debates continue. This week, among our features, Anglican priest Kevin Scully says why he thinks that the Church of England is in a mess over its weddings policy, and suggests that properly distinguishing the civic from the religious would be a real step forward in rectifying this. He does this out of deep pastoral faithfulness as well as honest realism.
 
Contending for difficult truth can be a matter of life and death, too, as Harry Hagopian illustrates in relation to the move to encourage recognition of the Armenian genocide. This would be a further step towards challenging the culture of immunity around the politics of hatred as it descends into mass slaughter.
 
Our highlighted event this time is the first global religious leaders summit on HIV-AIDS, an issue that people of faith have sometimes been in denial about, but where Christians and others also have a life-bringing contribution to make.
 
The controversial issue Ekklesia has been involved in lately (one which has apparently galvanised some of the angry comments about us) is involving the public in engaging the C of E bishops who currently sit as of right in parliament. The aim is to encourage them to take a lead in reforming the second chamber, rather than preserving their own privilege. We think this is about setting a good Christian stance. Most Christians agree, according to the results of an ICM opinion poll that forms our research feature.
 
Last but not least, the 'thinking in action' is that of Third Way, the magazine of Christian comment and discussion concerning society and culture. The April 2010 issue contains a courageous leader encouraging the churches to question the 'special opt-out' approach equalities, sex and relationships education in schools, and much else. As the final poignantly paragraph says: "So, do we merely stand aside and accept a tide of secularism washing over us? No. But we must understand, as the apostle Paul did, that we operate as strangers in a strange land. Loud demands for concessions come from those who insist on their own strength. We insist, instead, on our own weakness, and offer it as a point of contact. We meet those who argue with us as equals, rescinding our historical claims to authority. What strength is left, then, is God's".
 
Ekklesia works on a not-for-profit basis, and deliberately maintains its independence from large institutions and their funding.  If you value this bulletin please consider making a donation to keep it going and support Ekklesia's work. You can do it through PayPal here
Marriage in the C of E - an honourable estate?
By Kevin Scully
 
Marriage in the Church of England is being seriously degraded, suggests a parish priest and Christian writer. The current confusion between its social, state and civic meanings and its religious and spiritual ones is eroding its Christian significance, he suggests. A better way is needed.
 
Read the full article here
More media 'God versus God'
By Martin E. Marty

We are in for another intense round of "God vs. God," "Our God vs. Their God," "Good God vs. Bad God=Devil", says a leading US religion commentator and academic. The mimetic "them and us" rivalry underlying this is profoundly spiritually (and physically) damaging.
 
Read the full article here
Genocide - the Armenian saga continues
By Harry Hagopian
  
Is the cost in spoilt US relations with Turkey outweighed by respect for the memory of well over one million Armenian victims? A legal and political analyst from the region asks tough questions about the past and future of a genocide which many wish to deny, but which truth and humanity demands must be acknowledged in full. 
 
Read the full article here
Quota
Sayings from the week and wisdom from the tradition
  
"If you are in class, recognize one another; if you are in the store, recognize one another; if you are in the housing estate, recognize one another; if you are in the parish, recognize one another: you are members of one another if you are members of Christ. This is the most revolutionary sentence that can be expressed: 'you are members of one another.' ... And this recognizing one another ... is witness to Christ. This is the first expression of our yearning for Christ."
- Luigi Giussani, Italian Catholic priest (courtesy of www.sojo.net)
Update
Power and Poverty
 
Ekklesia's co-director Jonathan Bartley has produced a short FAQ in relation to the various questions that have been posed about our initiative with Power2010 on engaging Church of England bishops and archbishops in House of Lords reform. 
 
More material will also be appearing shortly in relation to the forthcoming General Election, and the question about what kinds of Christian and faith interventions might be forthcoming - and how to assess them.
 
As Lent draws to a close, we are also drawing together the series of reflections from Mennonite pastor Willard Roth on places of particular spiritual significance in Britain and Ireland, together with other material

Research Focus
Public attitudes towards bishops in the Lords 
 
A March 2010 opinion survey conducted by professional polling organisation ICM Research shows that the population of the UK is equally split over the importance of institutional religion in public life, but three-quarters of the public and 70 per cent of Christians believe it is wrong for bishops to have reserved places in the House of Lords. 
 
Study the full survey here
 
Media and web debate
Ekklesia in the news this week  
 
Jonathan Bartley appeared again on the BBC1 discussion programme on ethics, religion and belief, 'The Big Questions' last Sunday.
 
The Winnipeg Free Press was among those picking up our response to the sad news of the death of Christian Peacemaker Teams (CPT) founding director Gene Stoltzfus.
 
There has been a fair bit of response to the question of House of Lords reform, ranging from a small piece in The Scotsman, to a news report, critical comment and cartoon in The Church Times. We will include a more thorough summary in the next bulletin.
 
Keep up-to-date with Ekklesia's Comments on Twitter here: http://www.twitter.com/ekklesiaComment
 
Ekklesia works on a not-for-profit basis. Please support Ekklesia's work with the press and other media by donating through PayPal here
Event: Global religious summit on HIV-AIDS
 
The first-ever Summit of High Level Religious Leaders on HIV and AIDS will be held in Den Dolder, Netherlands, from 22-23 March 2010. The gathering aims to generate greater involvement from religious leaders of many of the world's faiths in the global response to the pandemic. The summit is being organised by the Ecumenical Advocacy Alliance (EAA) - a broad network of churches and Christian organisations including the WCC - along with the Catholic Dutch development organisation Cordaid. It is being supported by the Dutch Ministry of Foreign Affairs, UNAIDS, the International Network of Religious Leaders Living with or Personally Affected by HIV or AIDS (INERELA+), the World AIDS Campaign and the European Council of Religious Leaders (Religions for Peace).
 
Thinking in Action
Third Way magazine  
 
Third Way magazine was launched in January 1977 by a wing of the Church that had begun to rediscover the imperative of social responsibility which, with some notable exceptions, it had long neglected.
 
Its title refers to a comment by the theologian Os Guinness in a book entitled The Dust of Death: 'How often in the contemporary discussion a sensitive modern man knows that he cannot accept either of the polarised alternatives offered to him. In Christianity, however, there can be a Third Way, a true middle ground which has a basis, is never compromise and is far from silent.'
 
Find out more: www.thirdwaymagazine.co.uk
Reading Allowed
The Naked Anabaptist: The bare essentials of a radical faith by Stuart Murray  

Anabaptist Christians have been around for almost 500 years. But what does Anabaptism look like when not clothed in Mennonite or Amish traditions? Writing from Britain, Stuart Murray peels back the layers to reveal the core components of Anabaptism-and what they mean for faith in his context and ours. It's a way of following Jesus that challenges, disturbs, and inspires us, summoning us to wholehearted discipleship and faith. The book is due in July 2010 but can be pre-ordered from Ekklesia now.
 
ISBN: 9780836195170 (Herald Press, 2010), 300pp, �13.95
 
For more information and to find out more, click here
Thinking of Unsubscribing? 
 
Ekklesia runs a number of different emal bulletins.  If you unsubscribe you may be removed from all our mailing lists, so take care.
 
If you want to be removed from all our mailing lists permanently then use the "SafeUnsubscribe" link below. 
 
If you just want to unsubscribe from this email, or change which emails you receive from Ekklesia, then use the "Update Profile/Email Address" link.   You will then be able to change which emails you receive.