Energy Control Systems

Energy Control Systems

Answers Your Questions
April 2009
 
Greetings!
 
Last month we asked you to send us some of your power quality related questions, and many of you took us up on that offer. This month we selected a couple of the tough questions and researched the best solutions for each situation.
 
In This Issue
Harmonics
PQ Solutions
Harmonics 
 
 Question- What can be done about harmonics and other low-frequency disturbances that can cause equipment i.e. computers, robotic manipulator controls, dynamic motor controllers etc. to run hotter, etc., 1. How can I test this without buying expensive testing devices? 2. What is the most cost effective way to correct this?
 
Answer:
 
Simply put: There is never a simple "one answer fits" all harmonics problems.
 
The solutions for Variable Speed Drives are somewhat different from other industrial harmonic issues. The need for harmonic mitigating devices is growing because of the increase in variable speed drive usage.
A new state-of-the-art passive universal harmonic filter (UHF) is designed for 3-phase 6-pulse diode bridge rectifier front end. These non-linear loads that are the product of pulse width modulators (solid state) used to generate D.C for speed control. These harmonic currents should be mitigated per the guideline of IEEE 519.
 
Most power systems in the commercial and industrial world can accommodate a certain level of harmonic currents, but will become a problem when they become a significant component of the overall load. Harmonics overheat equipment, generated by non-linear loads, and substantially increase the losses in conventional or K rated delta-wye distribution transformers. This increase in losses will increase operating costs and can shorten transformer life. These losses are considerable reduced when using a Harmonic Mitigating Transformer (HMT), by canceling certain harmonic fluxes without coupling them to the primary windings.
 
A power quality meter will record the level of harmonics, and at what frequency they occur, so properly sized equipment can be purchased. Do not be fooled into accepting anything less than qualified designers that have many years of practical hands-on experience to audit your system and create a design to meet or exceed your expectations. There is no "cheap" short cut to a good design that will protect your expensive equipment, and deliver systems that will have a longer life expectancy with zero "down-time".
 
A good audit will inspect your complete system, and deliver the most cost effective solutions.
 
For additional information please contact Ed Feitel at  feitel@ecsintl.com

Power Quality Solutions 
 
Question- What is the best solution to the protection of equipment and systems in an unsteady power supply environment like in Nigeria where power outages take place as frequently as once every five minutes? What is the solution for power alternatives when the power from the national grid is taken and not restored for up to 12 hours at times?
 
This question has a variety of components and is illustrative of not only the complexity of the electrical environment but of the necessity of multiple pieces of equipment to satisfy the needs of the facility.  A cursory review of this situation would lend one to immediately recommend a UPS solution.  That answer, while true should lead to number of other questions that must answered in order to recommend  the  most beneficial solution for the operational efficiency of the facility overall.  Questions such as "What type of equipment are we supplying back up power for?"; "How sensitive is this equipment?"; "Is this equipment scattered throughout the facility or are they in close proximity and fed from the same power panel?". 
 
Consider also the reality that if enough questions are not asked, then a square wave, standby UPS solution with 10 minutes of runtime might end up being recommended for a rack of quad core double density servers supplying support for a banking center that needs redundancy,  24/7 support and five 9's reliability! 
 
The other issue in this initial scenario is that each and every time a transformer de-energizes, the propensity for significant surge impulses to be released into the facility and propagate  downstream into the critical equipment is immense.  A cascade approach to surge protective devices is a key facet of full and complete power quality and efficiency implementation.  Secondarily not only will this approach mitigate the external surge sources (which account for 20-25% of the total) but more importantly mitigate the internally generated transients that contribute to long term degradation of microprocessor circuits but most significantly system upsets and is instrumental in preventing software confusion.
 
Therefore the "answer" to the first question - once more information is obtained - would be a combination the appropriate UPS units and as a system survey to provide a cascade SPD protection for the entire electrical distribution system in the facility.
 
Once you add in the balance of the scenario into the picture, the recommendation is radically altered.  At this point it becomes necessary to evaluate long term power sources such as standby power offerings as in motor generator sets of either diesel, CNG, or similar fuels. More questions are required... what exactly requires 24/7 uptime?  The data center?  The assembly line?  The entire facility?  The previous recommendation is by no means negated...  and still required in order to fully protect  and ready the facility to receive electricity from the stand by power source.
 
As we have been saying here at ECS for many years and as our research continues to support... there is not a one size fits all, PQ in a box solution.  Most every situation requires the assistance of a true professional, a systems integrator experienced in a myriad of power quality products and fields.  You can rely upon the experience we have assembled here at ECS as your source, your one stop for any and all power quality needs.
 
Thanks for all of your great questions! We'll continue to work on answers to some of the more popular question in future newsletters.
 
Sincerely,
 

Jeff Edwards
Energy Control Systems
Quick Links
Join Our Mailing List