The Church Doctor® Report
Sorry!:
 No Quick Fix to Become a Thriving Church
VOL. 6 NO. 3 MAY 2010
 
Forward this issue to a Friend
 Help us help other Christians thrive! Forward this today!
Join Our Mailing List
Get free resources, special offers, and valuable tools by joining our community.

Kent Hunter leads a growing number of consultants, spiritual architects, church leadership coaches, and diagnostic analysts who are the Church Doctor Ministries team.  Church Doctors consult churches, parachurch ministries, Christian corporations, and coach Christian leaders.

Featured Service 
 
Certified Christian Leadership Coaching
 
In this rapidly changing, increasingly complex world-a professional coach provides direction, support, and strategic objective input.
 
Coaching takes place by phone, once a month, for one hour.  You send your agenda to your coach who prepares to help you achieve your objectives.
 
"I just needed an objective expert to bounce off church ideas and plans.  We have become professional friends by phone.  I found it so helpful, I asked my church to fund it for another year."
                ~ Senior Pastor,      Ohio

Make a Donation 
 
Find us on Facebook
 
View our profile on LinkedIn
 
Follow us on Twitter
RESOURCES
 
Alvesson, Mats.  Understanding Organizational Culture. Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications, LTD, 2002.
 
Church Doctor Ministries. Healthy Churches Thrive: Measurable Results for the Local Church. Corunna, IN: Church Doctor Ministries, 2010.
 
Deal, Terry and Allan Kennedy.  Corporate Cultures. New York, NY: Basic Books, 2000.
 
Hunter, Kent R. Catalytic Efforts to Transform Churches into Mission. (audio).
 
Hunter, Kent R. Discover Your Windows: Lining Up with God's Vision. Nashville, TN: Abingdon Press, 2003.
 
Hunter, Kent R. Your Church Has Personality: Find Your Focus-Maximize Your Mission. Corunna, IN: Church Doctor Ministries, 1997.
 
Lewis, Robert, Wayne Cordeiro, and Warren Bird.  Culture Shift: Transforming Your Church from the Inside Out.  Hoboken, NJ: Jossey-Bass, 2005.
 
O'Donovan, Gabrielle.  The Corporate Culture Handbook: How to Plan, Implement, and Measure a Successful Culture Change. Dublin, Ireland: Liffey Press, 2007.
 
Schein, Edgar H.  Organizational Culture and Leadership. Hoboken, NJ: Jossey-Bass, 2004.
June 2011 Pilgrimage
Emersion Experience
 
Want to see what the church will look like in the U.S. in ten years?  Join this annual emersion excursion to the center of the growing movement of Christianity coming out of England.  The experience will "wreck you forever," in a good sense.
 
Watch the
 
Limit 20-filled for 2010.  Apply now for 2011.  This trip may be eligible for advance degree credit at some seminaries, Bible colleges, and Christian universities.

For an application e-mail: jasonatkinson@churchdoctor.org 
Join Us in Helping
Churches Thrive
Church Doctor Ministries has been helping churches, pastors, and ministry leaders become more effective for the Great Commission for over 30 years. We have helped literally thousands of Christians and churches with free and discounted resources.
 
We are committed to continuing to underwrite our ministry services and offer grants to churches that need a little extra help to reach the place in ministry that God is calling them to.
 
We are asking for your help in helping more churches thrive. In 2010 CDM has set in motion plans to help 40 churches and 10,000 ministry leaders experience spiritual transformation with two new ministry services that combine the best tools and resources we have developed in over 30 years of non-profit ministry work.
 
We are also seeking the Lord's guidance in other areas of ministry expansion for CDM. Specifically, in the area of post modern young adult leadership development and ministry network development.
 
We ask that you prayerfully consider joining us in prayer support and financial support as we continue to help churches thrive.
 
Healthy Churches Thrive Support Partners will receive updates on these new ministry initiatives along with access to all of the new tools and resources being developed for these initiatives.
 
If you are willing to become a Healthy Churches Thrive prayer partner please email Tracee. 
 
If you are interested in supporting these new initiatives financially, please make an online donation by clicking the "Make a Donation" button below or by contacting Jason for other giving options.
  
Make a Donation 
 
Your gift is tax deductible and you will be receipted by letter.
 
CDM is an affiliate member of the Evangelical Council of Financial Accountability. 
 
ECFA logo 
Greetings in Christ! 
The Church Doctor® Report provides a quick read of strategic and influential information. This information is free to share as long as the source is respected.

Forward The Church Doctor® Report to those in your network of influence and add value to their lives! Forward it to staff and leaders in your church, denomination, network, or fellowship.
Ever notice how many buzz words there are around those who want to fix your church?  "Church growth," "transformation," "renewal," and the big one lately, "church revitalization."  Oh yes, and my title, "thriving church."  So many are on the band wagon for the hottest new title.  The real fix is in a totally different direction. 
 
We get a hint from Dan and Chip Heath in their new book on change, Switch.  I'm dealing with this subject of change and the church in my next issue of the Church Doctor Report.  This hint, however, will help this discussion now.  Heath and Heath say that to really understand change, you have to look at the process in three parts:  the elephant, the rider, and the path.
 
Let's start with the rider.  That's the rational side.  Do you want your church to grow?  People to grow?  Impact the community?  Great.  A lot of people want, intellectually, to lose weight...but don't.  Then there is the path-clear direction.  This is the program side of church consulting-making recommendations.  Not bad, just not enough.  Most consultants don't focus on the elephant.  This is the feeling side.  The rider might really want the church to become "revitalized" and the consultant might arrange a clear path, but no matter what good intentions the rider has, if the elephant wants to go a different direction, at six tons, it is going to go the way it feels like going.  That is why there is no quick fix.  However, it can happen, if you are focused on changing the culture of the church.  In this discussion, that is the elephant in the room.  But first, let's look at the dismal long-term failures of most church consultations.
 
Most Church Consultations Don't Work
 
Hartford Institute for Religion Research recently reported a study called "Do Church Growth Consultations Really Work?"  by respected researcher C. Kirk Hadaway.  Hadaway analyzed 208 churches that participated in church growth consultations from 1983 to 1986.  The sampling was limited to Christian Churches (Disciples of Christ). 
 
Bottom line results?  Consultations worked, a little, short-term, but not for long.  Enthusiasm wanes.  In other words, in Hadaway's research, consultations don't revitalize, transform, or lead to healthy churches. 
 
Here are some general observations, from my perspective:
If you are looking for a quick fix, don't waste your time.
If you see transformation as an event, don't waste your money.
If you see revitalization as a process, you are beginning to get it.
If you use a consultation process that deals with culture, you are investing well.
If you think that it is more expensive and takes longer, you are right.
If you understand that using an outside specialist, the dynamic of intervention (consulting) is a key catalyst, you are wise.
 
Think of it this way.  We, consultants, make dozens of recommendations based on thorough diagnosis, respectable research, prayer, and divine guidance.  Think of those recommendations as seeds.  Now, think of the culture of your church as soil.  Culture is key!
 
 
Good Soil, Good Seed, Good Results
Consider this: 
 
Good soil + bad seed = poor results.
Bad soil + good seed = poor results.
Good soil + good seed = good results.
 
Most church consultants come up with some good ideas.  This is especially true of those who do a good job of diagnosis-research-to really understand your church.  That research is hard work, takes time and expertise.  It costs you money.  Consider that research as the cultivation of the soil.  That adds to the equation:
 
Good cultivation + good soil + good seed = very good results.
 
However, you can cultivate good soil, or your can cultivate bad soil.  Cultivation (diagnosis) doesn't make the soil good.  To press the agricultural metaphor further, soil can be enriched.  (I will overlook all the church and manure jokes-with some restraint).  Those who enrich soil use lime or fertilizer or both.  In order to determine the correct formula to choose among hundreds of calculations, you have to first take a soil sample.  In the church, this is a sampling of the culture.  This is where most church consultants fail to help churches achieve lasting results that can be described as "revitalization" or "transformation."
 
When I started Church Doctor Ministries, God gave me the vision for this mission statement, which guides our consultations: "...to help Christians and churches through transformational change, toward the effective implementation of the Lord's Great Commission...."  The definition of "transformational change" is best expressed when, 18-months after a consultation, a member or leader of the church will spontaneously say, "Since we worked with Church Doctor Ministries, we are a different church."  Though I didn't realize it in the beginning, this lens of results has driven us, over the years, to focus relentlessly on what really provides lasting vitality in a church.  This focus led us to capture, with clarity, the key ingredient of church culture.
Church Culture: The Key Ingredient
Your church has a culture.  Every church has a culture.  Every church culture is shaped by key elements.  Unfortunately, most church cultures are primarily shaped by neglect.  Without intentionality, the culture of many churches is a hodgepodge of influences from within, outside, some biblical, secular, helpful, or divisive.  Culture, sometimes called (or related to) ethos, includes these elements:
 
Values-what we consider important.
Beliefs-what we consider true.
Priorities-what we most often would do first.
Attitudes-what we feel about various aspects of the church.
Worldviews-how we understand the world of our church and the way our church works.
 
The sum total of these elements represent the soil.  Whatever you preach, teach; whatever program you propose; whatever recommendations your consultant offers-the lasting impact toward true revitalization, real transformation, depends on this: to whatever degree you can accurately diagnose (sample) the culture, and shape it in a biblical way.
 
The New Testament church was a dynamic movement, not only because it had truth (divine, rational input)-the rider, but also it had a clear path: to follow Jesus, to make disciples, to be witnesses to the ends of the earth, to care for widows and orphans, etc.  It was also a changed culture, so shaped by Jesus it had to be called a new wine and required a new wineskin.  If you want your church "revitalized' or "transformed," you are asking for new wine-a revitalized, transformed culture.  
 
This is not impossible to achieve in the thorough process of a consultation.  We see it all the time.  The following table represents nine categories that reflect cultural benchmarks that lead to transformational change.  Growth in these areas occurred within six months of the consultation process.  Research was conducted through anonymous questionnaires given to everyone in worship: a) before the Church Doctor Consultation Process and b) six months after the Church Doctor Consultation Process began.  The churches measured include every church consulted by Church Doctor Ministries in 2008 and 2009.  They represent several different denominations, fellowships, and independents.  They include large, medium-sized, and small churches located throughout the U.S. in various preconditions of health.  The table has three categories: 1) cultural element; 2) description; 3) six-month increase (see chart to the right).
 
These nine categories do not exhaust the cultural issues that are important to each church, but represent areas that impact long-term, sustainable change toward healthy churches.  With this type of soil preparation, tangible results like worship attendance, membership growth, and community impact are more likely to follow.
 
Remember, if you don't move the elephant, and you want long-term results, you are wasting your time.  The good news is this:  the elephant, the culture, can be cultivated.  The result is transformational.  Healthy churches thrive!
Nine Categories for
Transforming Church Culture
 
 
Category              Description                6-month increase 
 
Spiritual Health      As a result of this                      +13%
                            church's ministry,
                            my spiritual life is
                            growing faster than
                            before.

Bible Study           I attend a regularly                   +15%
                           scheduled Bible study
                           either at church or in
                           a home.
 
Proportionate        I choose to give                        +15%
Giving                  financially to my church
                           as a percentage rather
                           than a dollar amount.
 
Tithe                    I give 10% or more of my          +13%
                           income to the work of the
                           Lord in my church.
 
Ministry                I volunteer regularly,                 +16%
Involvement         or once in a while.

Purpose of            I view the primary purpose        +34%
                           of the church as
                           "making disciples."

Open to                I believe the greatest era           +28%
Innovation &         in the history of the church
Change-               will be the next ten years.
Early Adopters

Positive Attitude     I strongly agree I have a           +15%
about Church         positive attitude about
                            this church. I would
                            recommend it to my friends.

Ownership             I strongly agree I feel like          +23%
                            I am a part of this church.